Favorite team:Georgia 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:27250
Registered on:5/11/2012
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
The article also says there is a redline process.

My strong suspicion is that this has minimal competitive impact.
I think it remains to be seen if these articles are a sign of real concern for players or just agents clawing for more leverage.
I don’t think any of them should be playing, but there is no national enforcement mechanism right now. If that puts the SEC/UGA at a small disadvantage, so be it.

I have no interest in watching mediocre pro washouts play for UGA.

ETA: I have more sympathy for Europeans who became “pros” at 15 in their development system, but the 23+ year olds shouldn’t be eligible. If it takes banning all euro pros, even younger ones, to create a clear distinction, then I am in favor of that.
quote:

Does he or Kirby try to lure Baker or Aranda? Or does he call his own defense?

Kirby and Schumann likely wouldn’t hire someone outside of their defensive “school” of coaching. Both would stick to the Saban/Smart tree.
quote:

As far as these guys getting an extra year? Is that not the only basis for the 5/6th year lawsuits etc.

It is definitely not the only basis that’s been used, and the five year limitation itself will certainly be challenged in the future.
quote:

This is a very specific legal situation that only applies to this class of athletes because of rule changes and court rulings related to it.

You don’t really believe that, do you?
quote:

As a conference should we not vote on a governance structure and enforcement?

The new rule and punishments were voted on this summer.
quote:

They could argue that the SEC’s new rules could not be enforced in an ex post facto stance from the originating date of the concerns requisite to RJ Luis (for example) if the original judicial actions associated with RJ Luis began prior to the implementation of the SEC’s new rules.

I don’t know enough about the timeline to opine legally, but that is an absurd position from a “good faith” perspective. RJ Luis, and players like him, would never have been considered remotely eligible for college basketball prior to about 8 months ago, and LSU recruited him anyway.
quote:

Inconsistent enforcement.

These are new rules. How could LSU prove inconsistent enforcement?
quote:

IF the SEC tries to kick LSU out of the conference, it will go before an actual judge (most likely at the Federal level) who won’t be able to rule in favor of the SEC without undermining state judiciaries…

If the state of Georgia were to hypothetically pass a law declaring all eligibility restrictions on prospective UGA athletes null and void, should the other SEC schools be forced to allow UGA to continue playing in their conference with a significant competitive advantage? Clearly no.
quote:

LSU just needs to prove that the SEC didn’t act in good faith on its by-laws.

How could setting eligibility rules consistent with standards over the past century of college sports be construed as “bad faith?”
quote:

If LSU generates a civil suit against the SEC saying the removal was not justified then yes

Do private organizations get to decide their own criteria for membership?
College sports are a mess in general, but men’s basketball may be beyond repair.

re: Masterful job by Bobo.

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 6:54 pm to
quote:

It wouldn’t be shocking if 30 players on this roster end up in the NFL.

I feel like that’s a relatively low number compared to the recent past, if we include underclassmen. I think it will be more than that.

re: QB Transfer Portal Market

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 2:22 pm to
I’d be surprised at this point if Georgia pursues a high-end QB if the market is $5M+.

re: Kiffin gonna Kiffin...

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 2:01 pm to
quote:

Kiffin and LSU spent a shite ton of money in the portal because you wanted and thought you could be great right away. 63 total recruits brought in.

At the very least, this was a huge error from a resource allocation perspective, especially if he thought the roster would still be lacking.

I don’t know the intricacies of LSU’s roster, but will they be in a meaningfully better position than they were a year ago when the portal opens? It seems like a lot of their guys are upperclassmen and/or known mercenaries.

re: Kiffin gonna Kiffin...

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 1:30 pm to
quote:

Oh, ok, so it isn't that they're not good enough. It's just that he needs players that are better. I see.

I would think that most people would be hesitant to be too critical of players they recruited and bought with a shite ton of other peoples’ money. I guess not in his case.

re: Kiffin gonna Kiffin...

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 1:20 pm to
If I’m a booster, I’m a little concerned that apparently my coach needs more than $50M to assemble what he views as an adequate roster.

re: Masterful job by Bobo.

Posted by Crowknowsbest on 11/15/26 at 4:44 am to
He’s on a roll. The screen game has become a relatively smaller part of the plan, which suits our personnel better.
quote:

Top nfl qbs get 20% of the budget. Slight overspend but not totally out of line.

How many teams have won a Super Bowl paying a QB 20% of their cap?