re: What is the logic behind this deportation? What is the purpose?

quote:

---

She’s part of the fabric of her neighborhood. WTF is wrong with some of you? You actually want to be the exaggerated villains of a bleeding heart movie?

---

Oh wow. You know… I also remember you bleeding all over the board when elderly people with no records were being rounded up by the FBI for J6.

I remember you bleeding all over the board also for people being arrested for religious gatherings during the asinine Covid lockdowns. While rioting was allowed.

I remember you bleeding all over the board when first term Trump allies were being raided by the FBI in the early morning and being marched out barely clothed in front of media that was tipped it would happen.

OH WAIT!!! We didn’t see that did we??

AGAIN.. not funny when the rabbit has the gun isn’t it?? It was fun fun fun fun fun for 4 years. The ball got rolling. Don’t get mad when someone takes it and begins rolling it.

You folks better start hammering the left when they start shite that’s political theater and political revenge. You have a mayoral candidate in NY right now who has said he would arrest a foreign leader. You can start there.

I disagree with this one also. This is not one of Biden’s problem children.

quote:

---

Your mind is so twisted and incapable of operation without allowing your emotions to take over ,

---

Why is it that old men want to call a younger woman emotional but can never provide any evidence of me being emotional outside of their own feelings?

When you have to launch emotional personal attacks to win a debate, you’ve already lost.

quote:

---

I said this 20 something pages ago, your political party(Marxist Dems)

---

Oh look, another emotionally driven personal attack based on your feelings and no actual evidence.

quote:

---

Do you have children????
When you fuss at em over and over, until you finally have enough and theres no more negotiation.

---

Are you claiming the government fussed at this woman over and over when it repeatedly told her she could stay in the country?

quote:

---

She tried to apply for a green card under a program for spouses of U.S. citizens, but was rejected due to a previous marriage she had in the 1980s that officials had deemed fraudulent, her daughter said.

---

This seems like a pretty important part. They should have deported her after the fraudulent marriage and never followed up.

Yeah. I'm not sure some on here read the entire article. Basically, her student visa expired, they denied her asylum, she panicked and tried to marry a random for a green card, and the feds said no bueno.

This is why she can't have a green card with her current husband and likely why she isn't allowed to be a citizen.

quote:

---

That’s exactly why she can’t become a citizen. I cited the immigration law permanently forbidding citizenship to someone who participates in a marriage the government deems fraudulent a few pages ago.

---

I like how you phrase it like the gov arbitrarily deemed it a sham. She admitted it.

quote:

---

Under the leadership of Kamala Harris’s running mate, Gov. Tim Walz (D), Minnesota’s laws regarding the care of born-alive infants have been repealed or re-written with vague language that no longer explicitly includes such a requirement. Member of the press simply haven’t bothered to check their facts. “[T]he statute that [Walz] signed into law,” Vance said during the Oct. 1 vice presidential debate, “it says that a doctor who presides over an abortion, where the baby survives, the doctor is under no obligation to provide lifesaving care to a baby who survives a botched late-term abortion.”

---

The Hill “JD Vance was right about Minnesota’s abortion laws”
It makes more sense than allowing babies born to die without medical care just because you are a Democrat. This lady isn’t here legally. She was allowed to stay at the discretion of our government, but she isn’t anymore. She isn’t being left to die like an animal like what’s happened in Minnesota over the last few years to babies who have survived botched abortions. Fix this murder and we can talk.

quote:

---

It makes more sense than allowing babies born to die without medical care just because you are a Democrat. This lady isn’t here legally. She was allowed to stay at the discretion of our government, but she isn’t anymore. She isn’t being left to die like an animal like what’s happened in Minnesota over the last few years to babies who have survived botched abortions. Fix this murder and we can talk.

---

Abortion is against the law in the state this woman lives in. I haven’t seen anyone claim she sought any abortions. Not sure of the relevance here.

I would also love to see poverty and homelessness eradicated but deporting this woman won’t do anything to further those goals. It would likely create a new homeless person since I doubt this woman has anywhere to stay in Iran or wherever else the government will send her.

quote:

---

As stated by many posters before, given the circumstances at the time if there was any reason to have given asylum to her it would have been. That she wasn't given asylum speaks volumes.

---

She came to the US on a student visa in 1978. Presumably it was a 4 year visa. She overstayed it, then applied for asylum. I don't know the year she applied for asylum but let's just say it was 1985.

According to the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) in Washington, 3,216 Iranian asylum cases were denied in 1985. This is in comparison to 5,017 cases that were granted asylum and 3,213 cases that were still under consideration.

28% of Iranian asylum seekers were denied in 1985. 44% were approved and 28% were left "under consideration." It doesn't seem that remarkable that she was one of the 3,216 asylum seekers that was denied asylum.

If she was a threat to the US, the court would not have told her she can stay in the country legally for 47 years.

ETA: from the link you posted:

quote:

---

Eventually, an immigration judge (IJ) denied Milne's request for asylum, ruling, inter alia, that she failed to demonstrate that she would suffer extreme hardship if deported.

---