re: Overturning Roe is a losing issue

quote:

---

all easily legislated and decided at the STATE LEVEL

---

I don’t think a state should be able to make a life saving medical treatment illegal. You do. That’s ok, we disagree on the extent of federal regulation in this case.

Libs love “muh science” except when it comes to topics like when life begins, the number of genders, “Man made” climate change (arson), and Nanshy’s resting blood alcohol content.

we can abort most of the adult democrats, if they prefer

quote:

---

are your people this stupid? all row v wade will do is kick it back to the states. states can still choose to endorse abortions. some can ban it. no more federal oversight or endorsement.

---

I know what it is, god damnit, I’m just saying people out here are still very much for it.

Majority of women are pro life.

Vast majority of citizens are against 3rd trimester unless mom is physically dying.

That is where it should probably go. Ban 3rd trimester (very few) unless physically dying and kick the rest back to the states to deal with. Elective abortions past 25 weeks people do not support. This can be a winning issue if you dont get extreme.

If you want to ban all of them then be prepared to have plan B and birth control pills easily available to the public for free.

I would go free plan b and birth control and limited abortion areas nationally with zero elective abortions after 20 weeks unless mom is dying.

Someone convince me this is wrong. I want to hear others.

The progressives want abortion on demand thru delivery and after. I disagree bigly with that. The righties would say no birth control of plan b....but I would give into those to get get fewer abortions.

quote:

---

That is where it should probably go. Ban 3rd trimester (very few) unless physically dying and kick the rest back to the states to deal with.

---

The federal government probably lacks the constitutional authority to make this law.

Planned Parenthood v. Casey (our current abortion law) isn’t prohibitive. It is a limit on state actions against individual choice.

quote:

---

I don’t think a state should be able to make a life saving medical treatment illegal. You do. That’s ok, we disagree on the extent of federal regulation in this case.

---

you can always travel to another state that allows abortion.

quote:

---

It means what I said. A woman comes into the ED at 20 weeks with a BP of 210/120. The fetus is not viable out of the womb and medications failed. The mother has two choices, abort the pregnancy or die. I believe in those situations that a decision to abort the pregnancy should not lead to arrest of a physician or the mother. Apparently some people here disagree.

---

This is exactly it!! Roe vs Wade is a Supreme Court decision - not legislation - the states should be able to handle this how their constituents want

quote:

---

There are rare instances where terminating a pregnancy is life saving for the mother. You can’t criminalize physicians who decide terminating the pregnancy of a dying preeclamptic woman is in their best interest and offer it as a treatment option.

...people on the right believe that a mother unnecessarily dying during pregnancy was all a part of Gods plan for her.

---

I've lived in the south and been a republican - that also goes to church every Sunday - my entire life... I've never ONCE heard anyone say or espouse this.

NOBODY wants to make medically-necessary abortions illegal, or criminalize the doctors that perform them; at least nobody that I've ever had contact with in any way.

I don't think you're a liberal/Dem based on the context, but this is the kind of misinformed view of pro-life people they run around and villainze people with. Because pro-choice people have a misunderstanding of what the opposing side actually wants and is saying, the two sides will always be at odds.

Most people on the Right that want to overturn RvW simply want to take it back to a state's right to decide and remove the federal government and constitution from the equation. Your misinformed views only serve to further the left's incorrect opinion of us.