
- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Posted on 10/28/26 at 11:51 am to FooManChoo
quote:
He obeyed the law perfectly. How can one do better/greater than perfection, if He was talking about mere obedience to the law (He wasn’t)?
If you keep the commandments, "good works" will follow.
If you do not keep the commandments, then your good works will not save you.
It's not that complicated.
Posted on 10/28/26 at 1:04 pm to Mo Jeaux
quote:The clarify of the doctrine certainly developed over time, but the truthfulness of it is rooted in the Scriptures. The divinity of Jesus and the Holy Spirit are attested to in non-biblical writings within the first 100 years of the Church.
It really isn’t though. It’s a Fran that was slowly developed over at least 150 years (likely longer) and then read into biblical texts by those who believed in that framework.
Posted on 10/28/26 at 1:13 pm to 3down10
quote:Good works are associated with the 10 commandments in the Bible. The first 4 commandments are summarized by loving God, and the second 6 commandments are summarized by loving your neighbor. All good done for God or neighbor are related to the 10 commandments.
If you keep the commandments, "good works" will follow.
If you do not keep the commandments, then your good works will not save you.
It's not that complicated.
You didn't answer my question: if you are just referring to good works and obedience to the law, how can we do greater works than what Jesus did?
Posted on 10/28/26 at 1:21 pm to FooManChoo
quote:
Good works are associated with the 10 commandments in the Bible. The first 4 commandments are summarized by loving God, and the second 6 commandments are summarized by loving your neighbor. All good done for God or neighbor are related to the 10 commandments.
You didn't answer my question: if you are just referring to good works and obedience to the law, how can we do greater works than what Jesus did?
You are the one that claims keeping the commandments is impossible, not Jesus or God.
And since I already know your response:
When Jesus spoke about adultery or murder in the heart, he wasn't raising the bar to prove obedience is impossible. He was explaining the basic physics of a clean soul.
He was showing you that a society cannot truly be free of theft, murder, or adultery if people are still harboring those exact corrupt desires on the inside. The outward sin is just the natural fruit of an unclean heart. He wasn't giving you an excuse to give up and look for a loophole. He was telling you to clean the inside of the cup so that the outside would be clean too.
You look at his words and see an impossible trap because you don't want to change your internal nature. You want to keep your internal corruption and use his death as a magic shield.
But true understanding doesn't see the commandments as impossible. It sees them as the only logical blueprint for a peaceful reality. If I or anyone else fails at that, it doesn't change the requirements or make your free gift valid. It means we failed.
Posted on 10/28/26 at 2:19 pm to 3down10
quote:Keeping the commandments perfectly is certainly impossible. Sin is breaking the commandments, and we are taught all throughout the Bible that there is no one without sin, which necessarily means there is no one who keeps it perfectly.
You are the one that claims keeping the commandments is impossible, not Jesus or God.
Examples (outside of Paul's teachings, which are very clear): 1 Kings 8:46; 2 Chronicles 6:36; Ecclesiastes 7:20; Psalm 14:1-3; Psalm 53:1-3; Psalm 130:3; Psalm 143:2; Jeremiah 17:9; James 2:10; 1 John 1:8, 10; Acts 15:10.
I could go on, but the law is given as an impossible standard to keep, and no one has kept it perfectly except for Jesus. Not because we just need an example, but because only Jesus is the God-man without stain of original sin and corruption.
I've already addressed your other statements elsewhere, but happy to do so again if you want.
Posted on 10/28/26 at 3:41 pm to FooManChoo
And you're back to quoting things out of context to create a false narrative. What makes it even worse is you do it deliberately.
You take things like "there is no one who does good" and refuse to apply the context of what it was talking about. Such as an invading army of fools in Psalm quotes, but you try to make it some generic law or statement.
Even Jesus said that of himself, but you call him perfect. Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone,
If that is actually what those verses meant, then the bible is contradicting itself when it praises a good man or commands a pure heart.
You take historical observations of human failure and twist them into a divine mandate for human helplessness. You do this because you desperately need a false narrative that claims obedience is impossible. If you can convince yourself that everyone is a hopeless failure, then you don't have to feel guilty about using a blood sacrifice as a magic shield to stay corrupt.
Ripping verses out of their settings to turn God into a trap-maker who demands a standard he knows you can't keep is the ultimate lie. The commandments are a logical blueprint for a peaceful society. Ripping poems out of context doesn't change that reality. If you fail, you failed. Stop blaming the text for your own unwillingness to clean the inside of your cup.
You take things like "there is no one who does good" and refuse to apply the context of what it was talking about. Such as an invading army of fools in Psalm quotes, but you try to make it some generic law or statement.
Even Jesus said that of himself, but you call him perfect. Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone,
If that is actually what those verses meant, then the bible is contradicting itself when it praises a good man or commands a pure heart.
You take historical observations of human failure and twist them into a divine mandate for human helplessness. You do this because you desperately need a false narrative that claims obedience is impossible. If you can convince yourself that everyone is a hopeless failure, then you don't have to feel guilty about using a blood sacrifice as a magic shield to stay corrupt.
Ripping verses out of their settings to turn God into a trap-maker who demands a standard he knows you can't keep is the ultimate lie. The commandments are a logical blueprint for a peaceful society. Ripping poems out of context doesn't change that reality. If you fail, you failed. Stop blaming the text for your own unwillingness to clean the inside of your cup.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 8:14 am to 3down10
quote:I’m not taking anything out of context. The verses exhibit a pattern of broad and generalized condemnation for sin/disobedience. These in combination with the sacrificial system for the OT and Jesus’ teaching of His mission to save sinners are an abundance of evidence that all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, as Paul states.
And you're back to quoting things out of context to create a false narrative. What makes it even worse is you do it deliberately.
You take things like "there is no one who does good" and refuse to apply the context of what it was talking about. Such as an invading army of fools in Psalm quotes, but you try to make it some generic law or statement.
quote:Read it again. He didn’t say He isn’t good. He doesn’t say He isn’t God. He asks a question and states that only God is good. Since Jesus is God, He is good and worthy of being followed by faith. That’s why the rich man was in idolatry. He loved his possessions more than God (Jesus).
Even Jesus said that of himself, but you call him perfect. Why do you call me good? No one is good but God alone
quote:Not at all. There is a difference between someone who is blameless and upright in terms of consistent in his moral integrity and devotion to God and someone who is perfect according to the law. God shows mercy to the weak sinners, but no one is perfect. Even Job, who was described as blameless and upright, later repents in dust and ashes for his sins against God. No one in the Bible is described as being perfect and sinless except Jesus. Noah is said to be perfect in his generations but sins in drunkenness, for example.
If that is actually what those verses meant, then the bible is contradicting itself when it praises a good man or commands a pure heart.
quote:All biblical interpretation seeks to make the most sense out of the totality of the data with the understanding that God cannot contradict Himself. Given that principle, the totality of the data points to only Jesus being sinless. If only Jesus, as the God-man, is sinless, then by good and necessary consequence, humans tainted by the sin of Adam are not able to be perfect this side of glory.
You take historical observations of human failure and twist them into a divine mandate for human helplessness. You do this because you desperately need a false narrative that claims obedience is impossible.
This is the natural reading of the Bible, by the way. No one would read the Bible and hear the arguments from Christians and come away from it with a belief that anyone can be perfect except someone who already assumes the possibility beforehand, and who then forces that belief into the Bible, like you.
quote:If I understand you correctly here, you are breaking the 9th commandment. I’ve said repeatedly that I believe the Bible teaches continued obedience. Nowhere have I said that Jesus is a shield against having to obey God at all. It seems you are now lying about me, since I’ve corrected you many times and you refuse to correct your language.
If you can convince yourself that everyone is a hopeless failure, then you don't have to feel guilty about using a blood sacrifice as a magic shield to stay corrupt.
quote:First, you repeat the lie that I’m trying to get away from obedience to God. I’m not.
Ripping verses out of their settings to turn God into a trap-maker who demands a standard he knows you can't keep is the ultimate lie. The commandments are a logical blueprint for a peaceful society. Ripping poems out of context doesn't change that reality. If you fail, you failed. Stop blaming the text for your own unwillingness to clean the inside of your cup.
Second, the context of the Bible is on my side. It is why you continue to reference the rich man but refuse to acknowledge what Jesus says about him immediately after he walks away. This why you have to arbitrarily dismiss certain books of the Bible that go against your interpretation. You are being intellectually dishonest, and I believe you have to be in in order to hold on to your idolatry.
Lastly, you keep focusing on the concept of a peaceful society, as if that is God’s primary focus. It isn’t. His own glory is the focus, which is why sin isn’t merely about hurting others but offending God. You miss this completely because your god is not righteous and holy, nor is it just.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 11:13 am to FooManChoo
quote:
I’m not taking anything out of context. The verses exhibit a pattern of broad and generalized condemnation for sin/disobedience. These in combination with the sacrificial system for the OT and Jesus’ teaching of His mission to save sinners are an abundance of evidence that all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, as Paul states.
All you do is take things of out context. That's why you quote 10 single verse from different chapters instead of 10 verses from the same chapter.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 12:14 pm to 3down10
quote:I actually believe the Bible comes from one person: God. That means when I reference verses from all over the Bible, it shows the consistency across the corpus. When I do that, it is intended to strengthen the argument.
All you do is take things of out context. That's why you quote 10 single verse from different chapters instead of 10 verses from the same chapter.
The problem you have is that you reject the Bible entirely, and only quote or reference it when it happens to agree with you (as you believe it). You are the one who is inconsistent, because you don't need to be consistent, in your perspective.
I'd be happy to write out a defense of every verse I quote and how they prove my point, but I'm already long-winded. You can look them up, yourself.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 12:19 pm to FooManChoo
Why are you continuing this dialogue with him?
he has no sincere interest in having an honest conversation
he has no sincere interest in having an honest conversation
Posted on 10/29/26 at 12:28 pm to OWLFAN86
When talking scripture and God's word I can't help but fall back on that classic Ezekiel 23:20
Posted on 10/29/26 at 12:29 pm to FooManChoo
quote:
I actually believe the Bible comes from one person: God. That means when I reference verses from all over the Bible, it shows the consistency across the corpus. When I do that, it is intended to strengthen the argument.
The problem you have is that you reject the Bible entirely, and only quote or reference it when it happens to agree with you (as you believe it). You are the one who is inconsistent, because you don't need to be consistent, in your perspective.
I'd be happy to write out a defense of every verse I quote and how they prove my point, but I'm already long-winded. You can look them up, yourself.
You are just using the other verses to change the context of the original verses. If your claims were legit, you wouldn't need to do this in the first place - especially if it's all written by the same "God".
You are basically constantly saying "What he really meant was". And then using other verses, also out of context, to then justify your own claims.
You are just proof-texting and you do it to IGNORE parts of the Bible and the context. Not to gain understanding, but to IGNORE IT. You claim this book is all from one person, yet to create your message you need to quote multiple books out of context.
I've been consistent. You just make claims like that but never actually show where, other than saying, "You didn't agree with me." And your trying to claim I reject the Bible entirely because I reject your claim that God wrote it is just you trying to make it so someone has to accept your version of what it means, or accept none of it. Which is just a cheap attempt at dodging criticism.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 2:16 pm to OWLFAN86
quote:He's probably the only true self-aware gnostic that I've encountered. He keeps sharing his ungodly beliefs, so I'm doing this for a few reasons:
Why are you continuing this dialogue with him?
he has no sincere interest in having an honest conversation
1) I want to answer a fool according to his folly lest he be wise in his own conceit
2) I want anyone who reads his heresies to see how ridiculous he is and not even be tempted to consider it
3) I want to sharpen my own abilities to refute such heretical nonsense, given this is the first person I've encountered who believes these things
Posted on 10/29/26 at 2:24 pm to 3down10
quote:I don't need to do it because the immediate context speaks for itself. It's why I give you the references. I'm not hiding from them but promoting them.
You are just using the other verses to change the context of the original verses. If your claims were legit, you wouldn't need to do this in the first place - especially if it's all written by the same "God".
I do it to show continuity between the other books of the Bible to show you that you don't need to treat them as if they are unrelated. They share the same message.
quote:Nope. I've explained individual contexts of verses before and I'd be happy to do it with every one of them I listed, but it would be a waste of time because you don't actually care about them. You just want to stick to your talking points that you use to bolster your own confidence in your heretical beliefs and your disregarding the Bible. When I do land a point with you, you go radio silent on it afterwards.
You are basically constantly saying "What he really meant was". And then using other verses, also out of context, to then justify your own claims.
quote:Again, I'm not ignoring or creating anything. I'm explaining to you what Christians for a few thousand years have believed before I was born. This isn't my personal revelation and theology. You're the only person in this conversation that is claiming to have some new revelation.
You are just proof-texting and you do it to IGNORE parts of the Bible and the context. Not to gain understanding, but to IGNORE IT. You claim this book is all from one person, yet to create your message you need to quote multiple books out of context.
No, I'm not ignoring anything. I'm interpreting words according to other words. When a message can mean multiple things, you go with the meaning that makes the most sense according to what the author has already said elsewhere. It's giving charity to the author and not assuming they just didn't know what they were talking about.
If you want to discuss the Bible, you need to use the whole Bible, otherwise you need to leave it alone and do something else. You seem to be arbitrarily picking and choosing what parts to use and reference, otherwise, which hurts your argumentation. If you're going to use the Bible, you can't complain that I'm using it, too.
quote:If you want to use the Bible when talking to a Christian, you can't turn around and blame the Christian for using the Bible. I wouldn't try to argue with a Muslim from the Qur'an and then try to discount any part of the Qur'an as something we can't discuss. You've said previously that you only talk about the Bible to use my language. That's fine, but you can't then turn around and dismiss the parts that don't agree with you.
I've been consistent. You just make claims like that but never actually show where, other than saying, "You didn't agree with me." And your trying to claim I reject the Bible entirely because I reject your claim that God wrote it is just you trying to make it so someone has to accept your version of what it means, or accept none of it. Which is just a cheap attempt at dodging criticism.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 2:40 pm to FooManChoo
You just openly confessed to the exact text-twisting I called you out for. When Jesus says a direct, plain sentence like "keep the commandments," it doesn't mean multiple things. It means exactly what it says. The only reason you claim it has multiple meanings is so you can perform mental gymnastics, drag in other books, and force his words to bend until they match your loophole. You aren't giving "charity" to the text; you are manipulating it because the literal words expose your theology as a lie.
I am not arbitrarily dismissing parts of your book. I am holding your own text up to your face and pointing out the direct conflict between what Jesus tells people to DO, and the cheap escape hatches Paul invented to tell people they don't have to do it. You are the one dismissing the literal, direct commands of the man you claim to worship because you prefer a system that lets you stay corrupt.
You keep hiding behind what "Christians for a few thousand years have believed" because you have no personal understanding of your own. You need a crowd and an institution to make you feel safe in your delusion. I have been completely consistent. I look past your traditions, your proof-texting, and your loopholes, and I tell you the truth: a society without theft requires people to stop being thieves. No magic brush or blood payment changes that reality.
All I see is you trying to pigeonhole the conversation into a box where you are allowed to ignore any points that actually conflict with your own delusions.
I am not arbitrarily dismissing parts of your book. I am holding your own text up to your face and pointing out the direct conflict between what Jesus tells people to DO, and the cheap escape hatches Paul invented to tell people they don't have to do it. You are the one dismissing the literal, direct commands of the man you claim to worship because you prefer a system that lets you stay corrupt.
You keep hiding behind what "Christians for a few thousand years have believed" because you have no personal understanding of your own. You need a crowd and an institution to make you feel safe in your delusion. I have been completely consistent. I look past your traditions, your proof-texting, and your loopholes, and I tell you the truth: a society without theft requires people to stop being thieves. No magic brush or blood payment changes that reality.
All I see is you trying to pigeonhole the conversation into a box where you are allowed to ignore any points that actually conflict with your own delusions.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 3:26 pm to 3down10
quote:Even the example you keep repeating, you assume a few things, including the purpose for keeping the commandments and whether or not we have the ability to keep them perfectly.
You just openly confessed to the exact text-twisting I called you out for. When Jesus says a direct, plain sentence like "keep the commandments," it doesn't mean multiple things. It means exactly what it says. The only reason you claim it has multiple meanings is so you can perform mental gymnastics, drag in other books, and force his words to bend until they match your loophole. You aren't giving "charity" to the text; you are manipulating it because the literal words expose your theology as a lie.
Jesus later said, "therefore you shall be perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect." God is absolutely sinless. That's the type of perfect He is. He has never sinned even once. How can we keep that command given that we have sinned in our lives and continue to do so?
Your interpretation is what causes contradictions, not mine. I can reconcile the commands to believe (without an appeal to obey) and the commands to obey. You can't. It's why you only focus on obedience.
quote:Again, when I've responded to you, I've gone out of my way not to support my position and attack yours using non-Pauline bible verses. I've been able to show you that you are wrong on your own arbitrary standard.
I am not arbitrarily dismissing parts of your book. I am holding your own text up to your face and pointing out the direct conflict between what Jesus tells people to DO, and the cheap escape hatches Paul invented to tell people they don't have to do it. You are the one dismissing the literal, direct commands of the man you claim to worship because you prefer a system that lets you stay corrupt.
Here's a tip for you: instead of just saying the equivalent of "nuh uh", try attacking a specific point of mine and supporting it with exegeted Scripture.
And yes, you are arbitrarily rejecting books. You reject anything written by Paul and I believe even 2 Peter.
If you want to argue Christian doctrine, you have to use Christian standards, otherwise you are being arbitrary.
quote:The reason why I appeal to tradition in this matter is not because it is authoritative in itself, but because you keep using language that makes it seem like you think I'm just making this stuff up out of the blue, and that you have the right interpretation while I don't. You are the one arguing against Church history on this one, and it's because you claim to have had a private revelation. Get in line. There are thousands just like you, and they are say something different. Clearly it's not all from "god".
You keep hiding behind what "Christians for a few thousand years have believed" because you have no personal understanding of your own. You need a crowd and an institution to make you feel safe in your delusion. I have been completely consistent. I look past your traditions, your proof-texting, and your loopholes, and I tell you the truth: a society without theft requires people to stop being thieves. No magic brush or blood payment changes that reality.
quote:I'm not ignoring anything at all. I respond to everything you say. You haven't done the same. There are many arguments I've made that have gone unaddressed by you. So again, you accuse me of the very thing you are doing, yourself.
All I see is you trying to pigeonhole the conversation into a box where you are allowed to ignore any points that actually conflict with your own delusions.
Posted on 10/29/26 at 3:45 pm to Athis
quote:Perhaps they'll be awarded exactly what they are praying for.
This crap is crazy... HOW IS THIS HAPPENING?
The juxtaposition of "pray" and "prey," or "prayer" and "preyer" is always interesting
Posted on 10/29/26 at 3:54 pm to FooManChoo
You're just further exposing the fraud of your theology here. You're basically arguing that because a person has made a mistake in the past, they are permanently disqualified from keeping the laws of a clean society today, and that is ridiculous. Furthermore it's not even what Jesus taught, he taught forgiveness for those who repented for their sins. Which literally means to fix your mistakes. I've explained to you how that works already.
When Jesus said to be perfect as the Father is perfect, he was pointing to the ultimate standard of alignment. He wasn't setting up a trick question to make everyone give up and look for a loophole as you claim.
A teacher tells a student to write a perfect paper to give them a target to aim for, not to make them drop out of school. If you fall short, you take responsibility, you correct the fault, and you do better next time. It means you failed, not that the blueprint changed.
I don't need your "theological exegesis" or your institutional boxes to prove this. True understanding stands on its own logical merit. You demand that I play by your "Christian standards" because you are terrified of the plain, simple physics of reality: a society without theft requires people to stop being thieves. A blood payment doesn't change your internal nature; it just lets you hide your corruption behind a name.
You keep screaming that I'm heretical because I won't bow to your church history. But really you are no different than people on TV selling miracle pills that allow them to keep their current habits, but still reap the rewards those habits would otherwise prevent.
And that's the exact reason we have the version of Christianity we have today. People want the free gift because doing it themselves was too hard, but you don't find out the pill doesn't work until you're dead.
When Jesus said to be perfect as the Father is perfect, he was pointing to the ultimate standard of alignment. He wasn't setting up a trick question to make everyone give up and look for a loophole as you claim.
A teacher tells a student to write a perfect paper to give them a target to aim for, not to make them drop out of school. If you fall short, you take responsibility, you correct the fault, and you do better next time. It means you failed, not that the blueprint changed.
I don't need your "theological exegesis" or your institutional boxes to prove this. True understanding stands on its own logical merit. You demand that I play by your "Christian standards" because you are terrified of the plain, simple physics of reality: a society without theft requires people to stop being thieves. A blood payment doesn't change your internal nature; it just lets you hide your corruption behind a name.
You keep screaming that I'm heretical because I won't bow to your church history. But really you are no different than people on TV selling miracle pills that allow them to keep their current habits, but still reap the rewards those habits would otherwise prevent.
And that's the exact reason we have the version of Christianity we have today. People want the free gift because doing it themselves was too hard, but you don't find out the pill doesn't work until you're dead.
This post was edited on 10/29/26 at 4:03 pm

Popular
Back to top


1










