
- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: A prayer to SATAN.
Posted on 11/2/26 at 2:50 pm to Squirrelmeister
Posted on 11/2/26 at 2:50 pm to Squirrelmeister
So you’ve conceded Nicaea wasn’t a vote on whether Jesus was divine… but now you’re making several more historical mistakes.
First, where exactly does the Bible say Jesus was created? John 1:3 explicitly says all things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made. Colossians 1:16-17 likewise says all things were created through Him and that He exists before all things.
Second, “our God” doesn’t imply other gods exist any more than saying “our Lord” implies multiple Lords. Ignatius was writing within a Christian tradition rooted in Jewish monotheism, not pagan patron-deity worship.
Third, claiming Eusebius forged Ignatius because Theophilus didn’t mention the historical Jesus is an argument from silence, not historical evidence. Theophilus was writing apologetics to a pagan audience, not a comprehensive history of Christianity. His failure to discuss particular events doesn’t prove he knew nothing about them.
And your claim about Roman legions enforcing Nicaea is historically misleading. Constantine convened the council to resolve a theological dispute, but the controversy continued for decades afterward. Athanasius, one of Nicaea’s greatest defenders, was repeatedly exiled by Christian emperors.
Most importantly, Paul’s letters already identify Jesus as divine and describe His crucifixion and resurrection nearly three centuries before Constantine. You’d have to explain away those texts too.
You’re replacing established historical evidence with speculation about forgery and imperial conspiracy.
First, where exactly does the Bible say Jesus was created? John 1:3 explicitly says all things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made. Colossians 1:16-17 likewise says all things were created through Him and that He exists before all things.
Second, “our God” doesn’t imply other gods exist any more than saying “our Lord” implies multiple Lords. Ignatius was writing within a Christian tradition rooted in Jewish monotheism, not pagan patron-deity worship.
Third, claiming Eusebius forged Ignatius because Theophilus didn’t mention the historical Jesus is an argument from silence, not historical evidence. Theophilus was writing apologetics to a pagan audience, not a comprehensive history of Christianity. His failure to discuss particular events doesn’t prove he knew nothing about them.
And your claim about Roman legions enforcing Nicaea is historically misleading. Constantine convened the council to resolve a theological dispute, but the controversy continued for decades afterward. Athanasius, one of Nicaea’s greatest defenders, was repeatedly exiled by Christian emperors.
Most importantly, Paul’s letters already identify Jesus as divine and describe His crucifixion and resurrection nearly three centuries before Constantine. You’d have to explain away those texts too.
You’re replacing established historical evidence with speculation about forgery and imperial conspiracy.
This post was edited on 11/2/26 at 2:51 pm
Posted on 11/2/26 at 5:07 pm to METAL
quote:
First, where exactly does the Bible say Jesus was created?
You know the one about Jesus being the firstborn (Prototokos) of creation. The root of the Greek word is “first” and “brought forth”. Also in scripture the question is asked to which of the angels did God say “today I have begotten you” (talking about Jesus). No doubt you will argue that “first-brought-forth” and “today I have begotten you” means something other than the plain meanings, but you asked and I’m giving you the answer. It literally says he was brought forth, and he was begotten.
quote:
John 1:3 explicitly says all things were made through Him, and without Him nothing was made. Colossians 1:16-17 likewise says all things were created through Him and that He exists before all things.
Let me quote Philo of Alexandria.
quote:
For the Father of the universe has caused him to spring up as the eldest son, whom, in another passage, he calls the firstborn; and he who is thus born, imitating the ways of his father, has formed such and such species, looking to his archetypal patterns.
A generation or two before “the historical Jesus” it was a fact that (some) Jews had a theology of the Logos of god being created by God, who he called his firstborn son and mediator between God and man and the beloved and the highest ranked archangel who was responsible for the salvation of mankind. And through the Logos, God created “everything”. It’s 100% clear if you read Philo. Then it’s up to you if you think Paul shared the same theology or if his differed.
quote:
Second, “our God” doesn’t imply other gods exist any more than saying “our Lord” implies multiple Lords. Ignatius was writing within a Christian tradition rooted in Jewish monotheism, not pagan patron-deity worship.
Judges 11:24
quote:
Will you not possess what Chemosh your god gives you to possess? And all that Yahweh our God has dispossessed before us, we will possess.
That’s Foo’s boy Jepthah, the one that sacrificed his daughter to Yahweh, and Yahweh accepted it and rewarded him with victory over the Ammonites.
quote:.
Third, claiming Eusebius forged Ignatius because Theophilus didn’t mention the historical Jesus is an argument from silence, not historical evidence.
I’m convinced of it. I don’t have great evidence yet but I’m putting the puzzle together. That’s not the only writing I’m convinced he forged or edited.
quote:
And your claim about Roman legions enforcing Nicaea is historically misleading
I don’t think it is.
quote:
Athanasius, one of Nicaea’s greatest defenders, was repeatedly exiled by Christian emperors.
Ummm… which authority with which military enforced such a thing????
quote:
Most importantly, Paul’s letters already identify Jesus as divine and describe His crucifixion and resurrection nearly three centuries before Constantine. You’d have to explain away those texts too.
There’s nothing to explain away, I agree Paul wrote that Jesus was divine (in the sense he was the beloved archangel who volunteered to do a dirty job and then was highly exalted by God) and was really crucified (by the other gods who controlled the earth and who lived in the firmament) in the firmament and really was resurrected and exalted from the lowest heaven (firmament) to the 7th heaven to sit at his own throne at the right hand of God.
quote:
You’re replacing established historical evidence with speculation about forgery and imperial conspiracy.
There are many forgeries and many conspiracies. You probably don’t know about what I’m going to tell you. Scholars group Ignatius’ writings into a short, middle, and long recension. In the second version, scribes added a lot of “our god” to Jesus, among other things. There’s no way to know if the first version that we have was the first letter he really wrote, or if the real Ignatius wrote it at all. What we do know 100% is that early Christians loved to make up shite and add and redact earlier stories and letters. Call if a conspiracy if you want. But I’m not a conspiracy theorist. I simply point out the verifiable confirmed conspiracies.
Posted on 11/2/26 at 7:01 pm to Champagne
quote:
You're a Jewish person.
I don't belong to any religion.
Posted on 11/2/26 at 9:22 pm to 3down10
quote:
I don't belong to any religion.
When you said "I AM" and you said that a Christian breaks the First Commandment, I thought to myself "A Jewish person might have these beliefs".
Posted on 11/2/26 at 10:20 pm to Champagne
quote:
When you said "I AM" and you said that a Christian breaks the First Commandment, I thought to myself "A Jewish person might have these beliefs".
If a religious Jewish person heard me claim the "I AM" authority of the Father within, they wouldn't think I shared their beliefs. They would want to stone me for blasphemy. That is exactly what the religious elite tried to do to Jesus in the gospels when he made the same statement.
Posted on 11/3/26 at 12:25 pm to Squirrelmeister
quote:In the verse, the issue isn't with what the word means, but what they were claiming for themselves. They were being called out for trying to take the place of God. The entire chapter is a call to repentance and a warning to those nations for their sin and rebellion.
Zephaniah 2:15
Should we take this as the city of Nineveh claiming that no other cities existed? Same Hebrew word. Try to be consistent and use your head for once.
Even with that said, the context of what God claimed for Himself is understood in light of what else He says about Himself, and what He says about the other idols and gods.
quote:I understand that you think that's the case, but it isn't. God speaks of the other gods in relation to what was believed about them, and He says that they are nothing, can do nothing, do not hear, do not speak, and cannot help anyone, because they are nothing but mere idols of the people. God using the language of the peoples is not Him admitting they were really gods, but rather that whatever the peoples believed about them was not true, and that Yahweh, God, is the only God, and He is the creator of all things.
Nope, he is jealous of the other gods - his brothers. And he says he’s going to judge Bel in Babylon and he judges the gods of Egypt. They believed that those other gods were real. That you don’t understand that shows your foolishness.
Posted on 11/3/26 at 1:58 pm to METAL
First, prototokos means “firstborn,” not “first created.” Look at Colossians 1:15-17. Paul literally says all things were created through Christ, that He existed before everything, and that everything holds together in Him. Being firstborn doesn’t necessarily mean being the first thing created. Psalm 89:27 calls David God’s firstborn, even though David wasn’t the first king or even his father’s oldest son. It’s about rank and authority. Hebrews 1 also makes a pretty clear distinction between Jesus and the angels, so calling Him an archangel creates another problem for your argument.
Second, just because Philo called the Logos “firstborn” doesn’t automatically mean Paul shared his entire theology. It shows that Jewish thinkers were using that language, sure. But it doesn’t prove Paul thought Jesus was a created archangel. You still have to establish that connection.
Third, Judges 11:24 doesn’t prove Ignatius believed multiple gods actually existed. Jephthah was speaking to a foreign nation using their own religious beliefs as a point of reference. That doesn’t somehow cancel out Deuteronomy 6:4 or Isaiah 45:5, which explicitly teach monotheism. And nowhere does the passage say God approved of Jephthah sacrificing his daughter.
Fourth, you literally admitted you don’t have good evidence that Eusebius forged Ignatius, but your still treating it like an established fact. Yes, there are different versions of Ignatius’s letters. Nobody disputes that. But scholars generally recognize the seven-letter middle recension as substantially authentic, while the longer version contains later additions. The fact that manuscripts were edited doesn’t mean Eusebius invented the original writings. Thats a pretty big jump.
And finally, your whole celestial crucifixion theory has some serious problems when you actually read Paul. Galatians 4:4 says Jesus was born of a woman and born under the Law. Romans 1:3 says He descended from David according to the flesh. Galatians 1:19 mentions James, the Lord’s brother. And 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 describes the resurrection appearances to Peter, James, and others.
How exactly do those passages fit with your claim that Jesus was an archangel crucified by celestial gods somewhere in the firmament? None of them naturally suggest that. You’re having to reinterpret multiple passages to make them fit a theory that Paul never actually states.
I’m not saying you can’t propose an alternative explanation of early Christianity. But you need actual historical evidence supporting it. Simply pointing out that ancient manuscripts sometimes contained additions or changes doesn’t establish that the historical Jesus was invented or that your celestial crucifixion theory is correct.
Second, just because Philo called the Logos “firstborn” doesn’t automatically mean Paul shared his entire theology. It shows that Jewish thinkers were using that language, sure. But it doesn’t prove Paul thought Jesus was a created archangel. You still have to establish that connection.
Third, Judges 11:24 doesn’t prove Ignatius believed multiple gods actually existed. Jephthah was speaking to a foreign nation using their own religious beliefs as a point of reference. That doesn’t somehow cancel out Deuteronomy 6:4 or Isaiah 45:5, which explicitly teach monotheism. And nowhere does the passage say God approved of Jephthah sacrificing his daughter.
Fourth, you literally admitted you don’t have good evidence that Eusebius forged Ignatius, but your still treating it like an established fact. Yes, there are different versions of Ignatius’s letters. Nobody disputes that. But scholars generally recognize the seven-letter middle recension as substantially authentic, while the longer version contains later additions. The fact that manuscripts were edited doesn’t mean Eusebius invented the original writings. Thats a pretty big jump.
And finally, your whole celestial crucifixion theory has some serious problems when you actually read Paul. Galatians 4:4 says Jesus was born of a woman and born under the Law. Romans 1:3 says He descended from David according to the flesh. Galatians 1:19 mentions James, the Lord’s brother. And 1 Corinthians 15:3-8 describes the resurrection appearances to Peter, James, and others.
How exactly do those passages fit with your claim that Jesus was an archangel crucified by celestial gods somewhere in the firmament? None of them naturally suggest that. You’re having to reinterpret multiple passages to make them fit a theory that Paul never actually states.
I’m not saying you can’t propose an alternative explanation of early Christianity. But you need actual historical evidence supporting it. Simply pointing out that ancient manuscripts sometimes contained additions or changes doesn’t establish that the historical Jesus was invented or that your celestial crucifixion theory is correct.
Posted on 11/3/26 at 3:41 pm to FooManChoo
quote:
In the verse, the issue isn't with what the word means, but what they were claiming for themselves. They were being called out for trying to take the place of God. The entire chapter is a call to repentance and a warning to those nations for their sin and rebellion.
This is retarded gibberish. When Yahweh says there is no god besides (bahd) him, it’s the same word used when Nineveh says there is no city besides (bahd) itself. Both are boasts of incomparability (as the late Dr. Michael Heiser put it) and neither is saying Yahweh is literally the only god that exists nor is it meant that Nineveh was the only city that existed at the time. It’s a boast. It’s propaganda. It’s shite talking.
quote:
I understand that you think that's the case, but it isn't. God speaks of the other gods in relation to what was believed about them, and He says that they are nothing, can do nothing, do not hear, do not speak, and cannot help anyone, because they are nothing but mere idols of the people
More shite talking and propaganda. Yahweh isn’t denying the existence of those other gods, but rather he’s saying he’s better than all the others.
Yahweh fights the other gods - even losing in battle to Chemosh. Yahweh says he will judge Bel Marduk in Babylon. It would be pretty silly to claim that Yahweh is saying he will judge something which doesn’t even exist. In psalm 82 Yahweh will judge the other gods and defeat them and take their inheritances. In exodus Yahweh says he will judge the gods of Egypt. Again, it would be retarded to claim Yahweh is saying he is going to pass judgement on non existent figments of the imagination.
The 10 plagues were judgments on 10 Egyptian gods… gods that they believed were real, and gods that enabled the Egyptian priests to replicate some of Yahweh’s miracles like turning their staffs into snakes.
1. Turned the Nile into blood - Hapi (god of the Nile)
2. Frog infestation - Heqet (god of fertility, depicted with the head of a frog)
3. Dust of the earth turned to Lice - Geb (god of the earth)
4. Swarming bugs - Kepri (god of creation, depicted as a scarab beetle)
5. Livestock destruction - Hathor (goddess depicted with the head of a cow)
Note: Yahweh sent the Canaanite god Deber (normally translated as “pestilence” in english) which is the same Canaanite deity sidekick that is said to walk with Yahweh when he’s creating evil.
6. Boils - Sekhmet (god of healing)
7. Hailstones - Nut (sky god protector)
8. Locusts - Osiris (god of agriculture)
9. Darkness - Ra (sun god)
10. Murder of Firstborn - this was directed towards the Pharoah who was considered a somewhat divine firstborn son of the gods and mediator between the gods and mankind.
Psalm 82
quote:
1God has taken his place in the divine council; in the midst of the gods he holds judgment:
Psalm 89
quote:
5Let the heavens praise your wonders, O LORD, your faithfulness in the assembly of the holy ones! 6For who in the skies can be compared to the LORD? Who among the heavenly beingsb is like the LORD, 7a God greatly to be feared in the council of the holy ones, and awesome above all who are around him? 8O LORD God of hosts, who is mighty as you are, O LORD, with your faithfulness all around you?
Only retards like you can read that and conclude there are no other gods.
Posted on 11/3/26 at 9:47 pm to Squirrelmeister
quote:"Everything I disagree with or don't understand is retarded gibberish"
This is retarded gibberish.
quote:Nope, and if you were correct, that wouldn't be anything for God to condemn Nineva for. Saying that they were merely a great city that was unrivaled isn't something to be judged for. And even if you were right that the particular statement is only about incomparability, it still doesn't fit with other statements where God denied any other gods existed in reality. "Before Me there was no God formed,
When Yahweh says there is no god besides (bahd) him, it’s the same word used when Nineveh says there is no city besides (bahd) itself. Both are boasts of incomparability (as the late Dr. Michael Heiser put it) and neither is saying Yahweh is literally the only god that exists nor is it meant that Nineveh was the only city that existed at the time. It’s a boast. It’s propaganda. It’s shite talking.
Nor shall there be after Me." (Isa 43:10).
quote:See above. And no, not everything that you disagree with is "propaganda".
More shite talking and propaganda. Yahweh isn’t denying the existence of those other gods, but rather he’s saying he’s better than all the others.
quote:Nope. The text doesn't say God lost to Chemosh. There are multiple interpretations as to what happened and why. You are taking the Moabite interpretation because you'll take any bias that goes against the Bible.
Yahweh fights the other gods - even losing in battle to Chemosh.
quote:God parallels the judgement of the gods with judging their idols and temples. He's simply using figurative language to show that God is the judge of all things. He is not on equal footing with non-existent gods, as if they were merely brothers like you said. Instead, He is the judge with authority over all things. He is El, the highest of all beings, and only God over creation. He frequently says as much, and belittles the gods, who are but mere idols that can do nothing.
Yahweh says he will judge Bel Marduk in Babylon. It would be pretty silly to claim that Yahweh is saying he will judge something which doesn’t even exist. In psalm 82 Yahweh will judge the other gods and defeat them and take their inheritances. In exodus Yahweh says he will judge the gods of Egypt. Again, it would be retarded to claim Yahweh is saying he is going to pass judgement on non existent figments of the imagination.
When you cherry-pick verses, I can understand why you might come to the false conclusions that you do.
quote:The plagues were judgements against the nation of Egypt, not the "gods", because the "gods" were not affected by the plagues, only the things the people worshipped. The judgement against those "gods" was only in the sense that God was demonstrating His power over the so-called gods of Egypt in the eyes of the people of Egypt. They believed those gods existed, and God was showing that He could do with them as He saw fit, because they were nothing.
The 10 plagues were judgments on 10 Egyptian gods… gods that they believed were real, and gods that enabled the Egyptian priests to replicate some of Yahweh’s miracles like turning their staffs into snakes.
And yes, there are demons that allow people to do "miracles". They weren't gods.
quote:The "gods" there are earthly rulers. They aren't like Yahweh.
Psalm 82
I know you like to appeal to Michael Heiser, but was not orthodox in his positions, no matter how he liked to think he was.
quote:I take the majority position of the Church throughout the ages. You call me names because you are a bully and you think that by tearing me down, it somehow validates your own wrong opinions. Keep it up if you must. It only shows how weak your position is.
Psalm 89
Only retards like you can read that and conclude there are no other gods.
Posted on 11/4/26 at 12:45 am to FooManChoo
quote:
"Everything I disagree with or don't understand is retarded gibberish"
You’re playing dumb or perhaps really are retarded. You used a specific example with Hebrew (bahd) to show that besides Yahweh there is no god. I then showed you the same format - the same boast - using the same Hebrew word that besides Nineveh there is no city. Applying the same context and logic to both near identical boasts using the same verb- the verb you specifically addressed, you’d have to either say well either Yahweh was the only god and Nineveh was the only city. Or also logically Nineveh was not literally the only city, and Yahweh was not literally the only god.
quote:
Nope, and if you were correct, that wouldn't be anything for God to condemn Nineva for. Saying that they were merely a great city that was unrivaled isn't something to be judged for.
You’re off in La La land.
quote:
And even if you were right that the particular statement is only about incomparability, it still doesn't fit with other statements where God denied any other gods existed in reality. "Before Me there was no God formed, Nor shall there be after Me." (Isa 43:10).
I’m definitely right, and you’re cherry picking. You’re rejecting psalm 82 and 89 and exodus and all the prophets who admitted the Israelites were lusting after and whoring themselves to other gods. You’re ignoring Yahweh warring with the other gods, sometimes winning and sometimes losing, and judging and defeating the other gods and stealing their inheritances because of their wickedness. You’re not just cherry picking Isaiah 43 but you’re taking it out of context and you don’t know what the Hebrew words even mean. The same language is used in the first set of the 10 commandments - you shall have no other gods before my face. Verse 10 of Isaiah 43 is talking about the commandment - that the Israelites didn’t put strange gods in the presence (in front of the face) of Yahweh.
Let’s look at the very next three verses.
quote:
11I, I am the LORD, and besides me there is no savior. 12I declared and saved and proclaimed, when there was no strange god among you; and you are my witnesses,” declares the LORD, “and I am God. 13Also henceforth I am he; there is none who can deliver from my hand; I work, and who can turn it back?”
Verse 12 presumes other gods existed, but that the Israelites were being faithful and not worshipping those gods. Verse 13… you think Yahweh is talking about who exactly that can not deliver from his hand? People? That wouldn’t be impressive at all. Angels? Still not impressive. Verse 13 is a boast that the other gods, that he mentions in verse 12, which are very powerful (they are his brothers and the sons of El), cannot defeat him. It’s a boast that he is the strongest among the strong.
quote:
See above. And no, not everything that you disagree with is "propaganda".
You should read some Dr. Heiser material.
quote:
Nope. The text doesn't say God lost to Chemosh.
You’re right. It only says Yahweh promised victory through his prophet, and when the Moabites sacrificed the king’s son, divine fury roasted the Israelites into a retreat. Only an idiot would argue that divine fury was Yahweh, the one who just promised victory. Yahweh didn’t lie. He just didn’t know he was going to get smoked by his brother. Don’t worry - there’s a big block of rock that king Mesha inscribed to tell the whole story that the Israelites were too embarrassed to mention. All the credit goes to Chemosh! And the Israelite scribe was like “man they cheated with that burnt offering… if it wasn’t for that, we’d have won… well I’ll write the story but I’m not mentioning Chemosh by name!”
quote:
He is not on equal footing with non-existent gods, as if they were merely brothers like you said.
The author of psalm 89 wants to ask you something, Foo. Who in the skies amongst the gods is as bad arse as Yahweh????
quote:
When you cherry-pick verses
quote:
The "gods" there are earthly rulers. They aren't like Yahweh.
Damn Foo you are so stupid but I can’t reply to all of your stupidity.
quote:
1God has taken his place in the divine council; in the midst of the gods he holds judgment:
quote:
5Let the heavens praise your wonders, O LORD, your faithfulness in the assembly of the holy ones! 6For who in the skies can be compared to the LORD? Who among the heavenly beingsb is like the LORD, 7a God greatly to be feared in the council of the holy ones, and awesome above all who are around him?
So the divine council of Psalm 82 we see exists in the skies in Psalm 89. So of course the “human rulers” of Psalm 82 live in the sky, right?
quote:
6I said, “You are gods, sons of the Most High, all of you; 7nevertheless, like men you shall die, and fall like any prince.”
You’re a dumb son of a bitch Foo, or a troll. Nevertheless like men you shall die. If those “earthly rulers” were men, they wouldn’t be “like men” and they would already know they are going to die due to their mortality rather than being told that like men they will die.
quote:
I take the majority position of the Church throughout the ages.
Yeah, prioritize that Catholic tradition rather than reading and understanding the scripture in context. Screw the scripture, right? Go after that tradition.
quote:
You call me names because you are a bully and you think that by tearing me down, it somehow validates your own wrong opinions
You’re the one that promotes that babies deserve endless torture and you support “objective moral standard” of slavery, rape, and genocide, and the worse thing about you is your hypocrisy. One thing Jesus couldn’t stand was a hypocrite. You’re a Pharisee, Foo.
If you would stop with the hypocrisy, stop projecting your faults onto others, admit that you believe what you believe without any supporting evidence (the blind faith you are supposed to be blessed to have), and admit not taking a staff is different than take nothing except a staff, we could have some common ground and maybe even have a reasonable discussion.
You could be like “well I just believe there is one God and that the psalms are about earthly rulers because that’s how Jesus interpreted it, but I can see how you might think what you think even though I disagree.” But no, you have to be an a-hole and keep arguing with baseless assertions as though you have proven them to be factual.
Posted on 11/4/26 at 11:21 am to Squirrelmeister
quote:The word means what it means, and the context drives how that word is used. I explained that Nineveh was boasting as if she were God, because only God uses that language for Himself. The boast is what they were being condemned for.
You used a specific example with Hebrew (bahd) to show that besides Yahweh there is no god. I then showed you the same format - the same boast - using the same Hebrew word that besides Nineveh there is no city.
quote:Nope. You are wrong, and I'm not cherry-picking. I'm taking the totality of the Scriptures into account. You're the one who treats the Bible as a bunch of disconnected writings that have no bearing on what is around them. That's cherry-picking.
I’m definitely right, and you’re cherry picking.
quote:I'm not ignoring them. I'm interpreting them in light of the countless of passages that reject your interpretation.
You’re rejecting psalm 82 and 89 and exodus and all the prophets who admitted the Israelites were lusting after and whoring themselves to other gods.
quote:I'm not ignoring those at all. I explained them. God isn't going to war with them or judging them personally, but judging those who worship those false, non-existent gods.
You’re ignoring Yahweh warring with the other gods, sometimes winning and sometimes losing, and judging and defeating the other gods and stealing their inheritances because of their wickedness.
If your Heiser-inspired view is correct (it isn't), then Yahweh would just be one god among many, equal in power and authority as the other gods. Yet Yahweh has power over the "gods of Egypt" and utterly mocks and destroys their supposed work. He dominates them in their own backyard, leading to the deliverance of the people of Israel from Egypt, and it's not even a fight. The best you've got is some magicians throwing some sticks on the ground and taking a loss from it.
But not, there are no other gods, and God doesn't lose fights to non-existent things.
quote:It's not cherry picked at all. It's read in its context. Ex. 20:3 says that no one should worship any other gods but Yahweh. It doesn't say they exist, only that no one should worship any others, as if they existed. All glory belongs to God alone.
You’re not just cherry picking Isaiah 43 but you’re taking it out of context and you don’t know what the Hebrew words even mean. The same language is used in the first set of the 10 commandments - you shall have no other gods before my face. Verse 10 of Isaiah 43 is talking about the commandment - that the Israelites didn’t put strange gods in the presence (in front of the face) of Yahweh.
In Isaiah 43, you can tell how "before me" is used by its context. When the phrase is used on its own, it usually means "before my face" (as you said) or "in my presence", but when the phrase is used in connection with some form of "afterwards", it changes its meaning to time rather than space/location. That's how it's used in Isaiah 43. So you're wrong again.
quote:You can't even make sense of this in light of the previous chapter. In Isa 42:5, it says, "Thus says God (El) the Lord (Yahweh), Who created the heavens and stretched them out, Who spread forth the earth and that which comes from it, Who gives breath to the people on it, And spirit to those who walk on it". This isn't some boast of God being one among equal brothers, but Yahweh being El. El and Yahweh are the same God in the Bible, and there are no brothers, and no other gods. Yahweh created all things and He is worthy of all glory. He says as much in 42:8, where He says He will not share glory and praise with another, and equates that with carved images. Carved images are the "gods" that Yahweh rails against and mocks, because they are not really gods. They are just worshipped as such.
Verse 12 presumes other gods existed, but that the Israelites were being faithful and not worshipping those gods. Verse 13… you think Yahweh is talking about who exactly that can not deliver from his hand? People? That wouldn’t be impressive at all. Angels? Still not impressive. Verse 13 is a boast that the other gods, that he mentions in verse 12, which are very powerful (they are his brothers and the sons of El), cannot defeat him. It’s a boast that he is the strongest among the strong.
quote:I used to be good friends with one of his proteges. I've read a lot of Heiser's materials and was even onboard with that stuff for a while.
You should read some Dr. Heiser material.
quote:God gave victory over the cities of Moab leading up to that event. No other child sacrifices effected any result in the Bible, so if it worked (it didn't), this would be the first instance. Instead, God condemns Moab in Jeremiah 48 and gives no hint that Chemosh has any power at all. So according to the text, itself, it doesn't actually say Chemosh defeated Yahweh. There are multiple explanations for what happened. You take the one that fits your own position best and reject all others as even possible.
You’re right. It only says Yahweh promised victory through his prophet, and when the Moabites sacrificed the king’s son, divine fury roasted the Israelites into a retreat. Only an idiot would argue that divine fury was Yahweh, the one who just promised victory. Yahweh didn’t lie. He just didn’t know he was going to get smoked by his brother.
quote:You will believe the Mesha Stele over the Bible because it suits your purposes, but it proves my point: you aren't reading the Bible within its own context. You cherry-pick what you want and then try to interpret it all in light of all extra-biblical writings or viewpoints. The Mesha Stele is biased towards the Moabites and doesn't refer to all the details that the Bible provides.
Don’t worry - there’s a big block of rock that king Mesha inscribed to tell the whole story that the Israelites were too embarrassed to mention. All the credit goes to Chemosh! And the Israelite scribe was like “man they cheated with that burnt offering… if it wasn’t for that, we’d have won… well I’ll write the story but I’m not mentioning Chemosh by name!”
quote:None of the angelic host are. They are not "gods" in the sense that you think they are.
The author of psalm 89 wants to ask you something, Foo. Who in the skies amongst the gods is as bad arse as Yahweh????
quote:Yes, even Jesus interpreted it this way when talking to the Jews in John 10.
So the divine council of Psalm 82 we see exists in the skies in Psalm 89. So of course the “human rulers” of Psalm 82 live in the sky, right?
Nevertheless like men you shall die. If those “earthly rulers” were men, they wouldn’t be “like men” and they would already know they are going to die due to their mortality rather than being told that like men they will die.
quote:The Scripture is the ultimate and only infallible authority, but tradition can be helpful when it agrees with Scripture. This isn't an either-or situation. I'm not siding with tradition over Scripture. I'm just telling you that the majority report of the Church agrees with my understanding of Scripture on this.
Yeah, prioritize that Catholic tradition rather than reading and understanding the scripture in context. Screw the scripture, right? Go after that tradition
quote:You are ignorant of the Bible so it's no wonder you think this. You don't actually care, though, because you don't believe the Bible is true. You don't actually have a rational leg to stand on with moral outrage, so you are framing my position incorrectly on purpose.
You’re the one that promotes that babies deserve endless torture and you support “objective moral standard” of slavery, rape, and genocide

Popular
Back to top

2









