re: 17 yo HS baseball player dies suddenly. RN says that Covid vaccine is likely cause

AlterEd:

quote:

---

Nor should you, in that case.

---

AlterEd:

quote:

---

She has just as much a right to comment on the case, regardless her proximity to it, as you do.

---

So . . . RN should not comment on it.

LOGIC:
Premise 1: SFP should not comment.
Premise 2: RN has as much right to comment as SFP.
Conclusion: RN should not comment.

Laugh at it all you want, clown. Everyone here can see what you said.

You skipped the part where SFPLC said that she shouldn't comment on it first.

quote:

---

You skipped the part where SFPLC said that she shouldn't comment on it firs

---

If she truly is a medical professional, she shouldn’t be commenting on someone’s cause of death without data behind the conclusion.

But if she’s a random bot on the Internet, she can yap as much as she wants.

just a couple of questions.

do you think the vaccine was billed as advertised? was it effective?
did you take it?

after taking it, how many times did you catch covid?

quote:

---

No I didn't, because I never said SFPLC shouldn't comment on it. You're putting words in my mouth.

I can see this is going to be one of those topics where multiple shill types flock here and lie their frickin asses off.

---

Hmmm.

quote:

---

Nor should you, in that case.

---

Look, I understand that you're not very intelligent.

But you can't use your stupidity as an excuse.

quote:

---

do you think the vaccine was billed as advertised? was it effective?

---

No

quote:

---

did you take it?

---

Yes but not for medical reasons

quote:

---

As usual, you just love to say stupid stuff to start an argument.

---

Of course. He is a paid shill. When a topic is created people can literally predict when this dipshit is going to enter the thread and what he is going to say.

quote:

---

Does she even know if he got the vaccine or when his last booster was?

---

Of course she doesn't. But never miss an opportunity to get that X clout!

Sigh. You really aren't very bright are you.

Let's examine what transpired:

1. The RN began her comment with a post about her credentials and then gave her opinion on the cause of death:

quote:

---

I'm an RN, and this is the 3rd case like this just this week. These are strokes in the very young likely caused by the covid vaccine. Hospitals in AZ are trying to say Valley Fever caused it, yeah right

---

2. You suggested that people should not dismiss her opinion just because she is an RN. You made an oblique appeal to her authority:

quote:

---

In before people dismiss this because it's a nurse saying it.

---

3. SFP did not say that she has no right to comment. To the contrary, SFP rebutted her and your appeal to authority by stating that her credentials as a health care professional are irrelevant if she does not know the health care facts:

quote:

---

Did this nurse actually treat the kid?

If not, regardless of her credentials, she should not be weighing in like this.

Does she even know if he got the vaccine or when his last booster was?

---

4. You said that SFP should not give his opinion on the cause of death if he does not know the health care facts:

quote:

---

Nor should you, in that case.

---

At no point did SFP say that RN had no right to comment. At no point did SFP give his opinion on the cause of death.


5. Ergo, your retort to my post is inaccurate and illogical:

quote:

---

What I said is that if he is going to try to deny someone's right to comment on the case, he shouldn't either.

---

I don't think you're pretending to be fricking retarded.