Favorite team:LSU 
Location:
Biography:
Interests:
Occupation:
Number of Posts:8603
Registered on:4/26/2006
Online Status:Not Online

Recent Posts

Message
quote:

This is what I don't understand about the courts, in general. Obviously I'm not a legal expert, though I generally have a decent cursory knowledge, but when a court issues an order, and the order isn't followed, why does anyone have to file charges? Shouldn't there just be immediate repercussions for defying court orders? It makes no sense to me.
A judge can issue a rule to show cause on the court's own motion, but in practice, that almost never happens. Instead, the aggrieved party files a motion for contempt or sanctions.
quote:

Do you think the SEC was really close to expelling LSU?
Probably not expulsion, but the SEC had severe alternatives to expulsion.

Under the August 2026 rules targeting schools with players who previously signed pro contracts or entered pro drafts without properly withdrawing, Sankey had authority to issue several penalties:

- Financial fines up to 50% of the sport's annual operating budget.

- Coach suspensions of up to half a season.

- Loss of voting rights on SEC issues.

- Additional penalties levied at Sankey's discretion.

Would the SEC impose a 50% financial fine? Probably not. Would the SEC impose a 10% fine. I don't know. What about a 5% fine?

Is Luis worth a 10% fine? Is he even worth a 5% fine?

Would the SEC leave the penalty at a 5% fine if LSU continued to play Luis?

Sometimes, you've got to look down the road and anticipate the obstacles.
quote:

They were told they couldn’t punish LSU, and they threatened them with expulsion.

They even lied and said we wouldn’t be punished.

Surely, they’ll have to answer for that.
No. At the request of his client, Clayton is not going to pursue it.
quote:

quote:

And slavery was still legal in the Union until after the Civil War.
This is true.
It's at least misleading.
quote:

Lincoln had stood up and sat down within the space of three minutes, thus disallowing Alexander Gardner and his photographers to capture the moment on film.
The point of RollTide1987's post is that the speech was so brief, the photographer did not have time to take a photograph of Lincoln giving the speech. The moment was not captured on film.

RollTide1987 is correct. Your post that a photo was discovered several years ago of the event while Lincoln was NOT giving the speech does NOTHING to controvert RollTide1987's point.
quote:

Ole Miss isn’t following the rules and the sec did shite about it.

Bama pushed the line last year and there was zero talk about kicking them out. Bama played their guy 5 times longer and in conference.

Either we have rules or we don’t, the problem here is others were allowed to bend and break them, we did it and it was an uproar and then our leadership just took the dumbest route possible. Weak Mcneese state level leadership
I have repeatedly stated that Sankey is attacking LSU because LSU's targets are much easier to attack. I'm very happy that Kiffin and Wade are coaching at LSU, but their past makes them easy targets.

You're absolutely correct that the SEC has to apply its pressure evenly, and the SEC is not doing that currently.

The question becomes: Is it worth risking expulsion from the SEC? It appears clear to me that some person or persons decided that it wasn't worth it for LSU to continue fighting it.
quote:

For all those crying about how LSU mismanaged all this, ask yourself a question. Should LSU pursue every legal avenue to gain as much competitive advantage as we can? If you are just a big pussy and say no, then you shouldn’t wine whenever we lose a game. If you actually have a sack and think YES, then everything LSU has done should make sense. Let me explain to the big pussies.
Here is the problem with your approach.

Do you want every school to pursue every legal avenue to gain as much competitive advantage as they can?

You may like a Baton Rouge court declaring LSU's players eligible, but are you as sanguine about an Oxford court declaring Ole Miss's players eligible? Will you feel as good when a Gainesville court declares Florida's players eligible or a Lexington court declaring Kentucky's players eligible.

I generally trust the judicial system, but I also recognize that many trial court rulings are reversed on appeal. And a big problem the judicial system has with college sports is that seasons are shorter than the time it takes to get an appellate ruling. Thus, those initial trial court rulings on player eligibility never get reviewed by a higher court.

Ad hoc judicial rulings in friendly jurisdictions is no way to determine player eligibility for an entire league.

Everyone has to follow the rules, or no one will follow the rules.

re: Spineless leadership

Posted by Salviati on 11/19/26 at 6:42 pm to
quote:

Especially from your mom's basement.
I'm pretty sure my mom wouldn't let these guys in her basement.

Right?

Right?!?!


re: Spineless leadership

Posted by Salviati on 11/19/26 at 6:23 pm to
quote:

Sal, I fear for the future looking at the newer site members :lol:
Piss and vinegar doesn't work against a 500 pound gorilla.

re: Spineless leadership

Posted by Salviati on 11/19/26 at 5:15 pm to
quote:

Let the dude hoop. Makes me sick to think we caved to that POS stankey.

re: LSU President says no RJ Luis

Posted by Salviati on 11/19/26 at 5:09 pm to


I assume Rouse made the decision as part of a deal with the SEC.
quote:

quote:

It's literally the technical term for what happened.
Except the terms hallucination and negligent were gratuitous characterizations, and added little to the argument
Correct. Counsel is supposed to simply point out the error and provide the correct law. Counsel is not supposed to argue motivation, cause, or the egregiousness of the error.

I admit, however, I may have filed briefs in my younger days that may have included gratuitous characterizations that added little to the argument.

I have learned to eliminate such comments even though there are times when I question whether opposing counsel made an error intentionally or whether a particularly egregious error calls into question the accuracy of the remainder of opposing counsel's brief.
Oh sure.

Keep that thread but lose the Great Zombie Apocalypse Manifesto.

quote:

quote:

It's literally the technical term for what happened.

It is not. What happened was an erroneous interpretation caused by improperly reviewing what was spit out by an AI.
I hear you. I hate to quibble. (That's a lie. I love to quibble sometimes.)

But if Harvey hallucinates an erroneous interpretation, and counsel fails to catch it, doesn't the error remain a hallucination?

Or more appropriately to this case, doesn't the error "appear to be negligently supplied or hallucinated because they reject the in-line proposition"?
Your post is accurate even though downvoted.

SEC counsel filed the motion to strike to expand on their narrative that Louisiana officials fail to control themselves. The hearing went badly in that regard for the "LSU" Defendants. I was surprised at Judge Axon's extreme reaction.
quote:

If the SEC used a citation that doesn’t exist, I think it is fair game for us to call it an hallucinated citation. There is nothing improper about that. It’s not like we stood up in court and said STTDB.
AI is far from foolproof and lawyers getting paid as much as the SEC lawyers are getting paid should make sure they confirm all of their citations.
Let's be clear. The cited case exists. The cited case does not, however, say what the SEC says that the cited case says. Someone made a mistake. If Harvey made the error, that's hallucination. The SEC's counsel, like all counsel, need to make sure that their cited cases say what they say the cited cases say.
quote:

Who is Liz Murrell speaking for in that letter? Is she speaking for all named defendants?
Murrill is the Louisiana Attorney General. Her office appears to be doing the heavy lifting. I sincerely doubt that Bruce Rogers is doing much other than acting as local counsel: sign and appear. Bob Barton is a terrific attorney, and I'm sure he is significantly involved, but this appears to the AG's show.
quote:

“I have directed my attorneys to submit this letter on my behalf explaining that Defendants cannot comply with this directive.”

She’s just one defendant here.
She's just one Defendant, but she's the Louisiana AG. She runs a department full of attorneys. Her attorneys drafted the brief that was called into question by the SEC.
quote:

Also “I would also be grateful if the Court would relieve Defendant’s local counsel of his role in the case”

Wtf is this? Coming in a *letter* from *one* of the defendants who are all represented by the same local counsel.
In all likelihood, she selected and retained local counsel.
quote:

Murrell wasn’t even a part of any of this until she inserted herself into the local litigation.
The Defendants are all LSU affiliated. She's the Louisiana AG. LSU and the LSU Board of Supervisors are arms of the State of Louisiana. That's why they were informally dismissed by the SEC. Defending the "LSU" Defendants is kind of her job.
quote:

A hand was slapped. That’s about it.
That's what happened in court yesterday.

Yesterday evening, however, AG Murrill's letter put Judge Axon in a box. I don't know how Judge Axon will respond to an attorney declining to do what Judge Axon directed her to do. Murrill was not present in court when Judge Axon stated the directive, and no written order was issued. That might mitigate some.
quote:

First, as I understand it, there were 2 other citations that were at issue. Molecular Pathology was the most egregious. The other 2 were less so. I believe those were Great Western and PTI. Salviati, Have you looked at those 2 cites?
Honestly, I have not glanced at them. The cite check for the first citation took only a couple of minutes, but drafting the explanation of why it was an erroneous citation took too much time to repeat.

quote:

Second - LA AG's response sort of centered on the fact that in legal scholarship, the term AI hallucination, is not solely used for for fake cases that AI invented from the ether... that it also applies to real cases with hallucinatory holdings. In CLEs over the last couple of years, this use is consistent with how I've understood Professor Norton to use it. IE, the term AI hallucination in the legal sphere also refers to erroneous holdings of real cases.
Absolutely correct. There are various sources for AI created legal research. With Harvey, for example, at least some versions allow you to eliminate the general internet as a source for caselaw; thus, you won't get wholly hallucinated cases. However, that doesn't prevent Harvey from misinterpreting a case. AI hallucinations refer to misinterpretations too. Using Harvey requires a full citation check: (1) check citation format, (2) Shepardize, (3) validate, and (4) review the cited case to make sure it says what you say it says. The first three can be performed in seconds. The fourth step requires you to read the cited case. No attorney wants to file a brief with citations that contain hallucinated holdings or applications.

quote:

In that light, I do understand the federal judge requesting/demanding counsel to be kind to one another. But her reaction does seem to be excessive. Especially, given (what appears to be factual) that SEC counsel's arguments/conclusions of Molecular Pathology were egregiously incorrect (very possibly AI conclusions that SEC counsel did not adequately investigate). And the fact, that LA AG counsel just offered AI hallucination as one possible explanation for why it was so egregiously incorrect.
One could say that counsel is only supposed to point out the errors in the opposition's brief and not the possible cause for those errors. Nevertheless, it appears clear to me that the citation was either the product of hallucination (Harvey error) or negligence (attorney error). Which cause is worse?
quote:

This why it makes almost no sense to shell out all this paper for these high school kids.
Then explain away this graph:

In arse'n for Molecular Pathology v. U.S. Patent & Trademark Office, 669 F. Supp. 2d 365 (S.D.N.Y. 2009), the Directors of the University of Utah Research Foundation (UURF Director Defendants) were sued in New York. Obviously, the UURF Director Defendants were from Utah. Judge Robert W. Sweet ruled that the Southern District of New York had personal jurisdiction over the UURF Director Defendants.

1. Whose Contacts with the State of New York Count? (Individual Officials or Entity)

Because UURF is a Utah state-affiliated entity, plaintiffs sued its Directors in their official capacities (Ex parte Young) to bypass Eleventh Amendment immunity. The court evaluated whether personal jurisdiction depends on the entity's contacts or the individual officials' contacts.

Judge Sweet ruled that personal jurisdiction requires assessing the contacts of the individual state officials themselves as representatives of the state, rather than imputing the entity's contacts to them. 669 F. Supp. 2d at 394–96.

2. Why UURF's Director Defendants Were Subject to Jurisdiction in New York

The Directors held title to the BRCA patents and granted an exclusive license to co-defendant Myriad Genetics, which commercialized and enforced the tests in New York.

Under federal circuit precedent, this exclusive licensing structure, paired with the Directors' official acts managing the patents, established sufficient purposeful availment directed at the State of New York, satisfying the long-arm statute and Due Process for claims arising from those patents.

3. Why This Matters in SEC v. "LSU"

The SEC cited Judge Sweet's opinion to argue that LSU's institutional contacts with Alabama could establish personal jurisdiction over individual Louisiana officials. As the "LSU" Defendants argued, Judge Sweet actually held the reverse: jurisdiction over state officials must be measured by the officials' personal forum contacts, not imputed from the institution.

Hmmm . . . negligently supplied or hallucinated or SHENANIGANS?



This legal analysis or information is provided for general informational and educational purposes only. Receiving or reviewing this analysis is not a substitute for formal legal advice from a licensed attorney who has reviewed all relevant facts and jurisdiction-specific laws.