re: Investigators When they KNEW Murdaugh lied (Page 112)

quote:

---

Then...some have said he cleaned up with the kennel hose and showered before he called 911-was there time?

---

Based on the Onstar, I don't beleive there was time for that. He was only in the house a minute or so when he got back.

quote:

---

Even going 80 miles an hour down a dirt road?

---

Who said it was a dirt road? Also, the top speed was very briefly 80 on the way back. It actually took him longer to get there, than get back. And SLED drove the same route and had the same overall time.

Offshoot Question: The area around back at Miss Libbys house. Did LE ever search the area for the blue tarp, blue jacket?

Was it a wooded area?

Whats the deal with the blue lights?

Well this witness is not helping the state.

This trial is going downhill quick. These rebuttal witnesses are terrible.

quote:

---

Well this witness is not helping the state.

---

I cringed at the cell phone expert’s testimony.

I cannot believe the state thought that was a good idea to present his experiment that had no real support behind it.

quote:

---

I actually like this theory, but don't understand why you would try to have the rest of your family killed outside of Buster because you are an idiot POS. Also there's no financial benefit for AM to murder Maggie and Paul which seems to be AM's entire MO.

---

Paul was looking at jail time for the Timmy boat accident death. Paul had to be killed in AM's drug addled mind because the motive was hate from the boat accident.

Even the death of AM's housekeeper never opened up the entire ball of wax. Paul's dumbass boat accident did.

Maggie is rumored to have found a large amount of AM's pills (her browser history showed her looking up 30Mg oxycodone after finding a duffel bag of pills)

Maggie is rumored (news articles) to have ordered a forensic audit of the family finances.

Maggie most likely would not have kept all of the current day secrets to herself. She would have been left broke, ashamed, in hiding. Paul going to jail for even 5 years would have killed Maggie. The boys were her life.

So in AM's drug addled, psychotic, narcissist mind it was a mercy kill.

With the alibi of hatred of Paul. I think he wanted them all 3 dead to give his brothers/family a clean slate and remove the sudden family shame?

Then Buster would get the million dollar ins. policy Alex has (and tried to use when he had Cousin Eddie try to kill him) Buster would get back in law school and carry on the 100 year tradition?

But at the last minute he chickened out and hid; and it was too late to call off the hit? Maggie was closing in on not being the quiet wife. AM's number one life source and concern-his addiction, was being exposed.

Maggie honing in on the larger drug running.

It is nuts, but it matches the past conniving sick schemes especially wanting cousin Eddie to kill him.

If AM was not there within minutes I would say it was a drug related Paul boat accident hit.

But he lured Maggie and Paul there and found Maggie's phone on the golf cart the three of them took to the kennels... after they were executed?

He ditched Maggie's phone--As he panicked and saw it on the golf cart leaving the kennels-- and drove 80 miles an hour to hide the hit he arranged and chickened out of.

Then 40 miles an hour to throw the phone out the car window into the woods because he couldn't go place it back at Maggie's body.

He never thought the video on Paul's phone went through because the coverage at the kennels was terrible.

I reserve the right to change my cocklemaney opinion.

quote:

---

I cringed at the cell phone expert’s testimony.

I cannot believe the state thought that was a good idea to present his experiment that had no real support behind it.

---

Witness testing the phone alone in his office and not recording anything, yeah not sure that was a good call.

quote:

---

Also there's no financial benefit for AM to murder Maggie and Paul which seems to be AM's entire MO.

---

If he arranges a hit on all 3 then BM ends up with all of the money. Any of PM or MM are going to be somewhat of a financial burden. If it's PM his legal defense, civil judgements, etc would all come from AM's estate. If it's MM then she's going to be a much bigger beneficiary than BM.

This theory is the one that I subscribe to. I also think it gives it a little more credence because he tried to have himself killed afterwards anyway.