re: Astronomy or Geology easier?

Took the first two Geology courses at LSU to fulfill my science requirement for business majors. Two relatively easy A's. Lots of gross memorization cramming the night before tests, but nothing really difficult. However, we didn't have to take a lab.

Geology rocks!

I took Rocks for Jocks. Wasn't that hard.

quote:

---

Once you get into astronomy there is tons of math, and astrophysics I would imagine bleeds over into it. I would think that a legit astronomy degree would be very math heavy.

---

My undergrad major was in Physics and Astronomy and you are absolutely correct. There are plenty of Physics subfields that don't involve Astronomy at all and vice-versa but there's lots of common ground too.

FWIW, geology and planetary astronomy can also overlap.

But the OP sounds like he's just looking for how to deal with an intro class to satisfy a requirement, and neither intro Astro or Geo involves much math. I'd say it mostly depends on the grad student teaching the class - the right instructor can make either one fascinating, the wrong one will be utterly boring.

quote:

---

need to take two consecutive semesters of a sequential science with a lab.

---

astronomy labs are night classes

Since your post is nearly a year old, I know it's unlikely that you're still seeking information about this, but I wanted to share my own experience because the amount of math in a course was the deciding factor for me when I had to choose which science courses to take to satisfy the core curriculum requirement for a BA (in history) when I was in college during the 1990s. My college was still on the quarter system then, so the core curriculum was different than what's found under the semester system. I've always been good at arithmetic, but any math beyond that, such as algebra, turns my brain into a jumbled mess. In high school, I passed the classes I had to take, but just by the skin of my teeth. My inability wasn't from a lack of trying. I was typically an A student. My quarterly average for Spanish 104 would've been a 100, had I not lost a half point on my final test, and I had a 97 end-of-quarter average in French. I always made As in history, English, psychology, etc., but in the one math course I took in college during my last quarter, I made a D. I was absolutely okay with it. I mention all of this so you'll understand that this info is from someone who seriously sucks in math. I had to take either 3 science courses (2 in a sequence/all 3 had labs) and 1 math, or 2 science/2 math courses. I went with the former. I took the intro astronomy course (105, I think) which had some math that was above my ability. I couldn't solve the equations, nor could I make heads or tails of Einstein's theory of relativity, but I could memorize everything else, so I made a B for the quarter. I didn't take Astronomy 106 because my professor told me it was heavy on the math and was essentially astrophysics. This might not always be the case for Astronomy 102/106 (or whatever comes after the intro class), but I knew I had to find something else because the math in astronomy is just too complex for this dumb-dumb. I decided to take my 2 course sequence in geology, and I loved it. A young, newly-hired professor, who'd just received his PhD, taught my class. He was excited about teaching, and he made geology interesting. He was even able to teach me how to do whatever math was in GEO 105 & 106. I'm sorry this is a book, but I'm willing to risk writing too much in case my experience can help someone else who doesn't care that they'll never know whether Train B catches up to Train A, or what time Train C will arrive in Chicago. I hope you chose the course that was best for you.

First year of astronomy isn't too bad. First year geology is an insomnia cure. This was at LSU over 20 years ago so I don't remember who the instructors were. Geology was in Howe Russell Hall, which to me for some reason was a creepy place.

Astrology... Scorpios rule!

Geology... rocks for jocks.

Both are fascinating