Question for song writers. How do you put together a song like this?

Usually whoever writes the song will write it and then play what they came up with for the rest of the group.

Then the band gets together and expands on that original idea.

In some cases it may be a team effort for the writing process. Some people work better when they can bounce ideas off each other or sometimes you get a writers block and need someone to help get you over it.

ETA: I typically write lyrics first then music but most others I know do the opposite.

Different people work differently

Dylan usually wrote lyrics first

Paul McCartney came up with the music for "Yesterday" a couple of years before writing the lyric we now know. This was the original "dummy" lyric:

Scrambled Eggs
Someday soon you'll have to shave your legs...

Music is written first 99% of the time.

Someone in a band will bring a melody, riff, bass line, drum beat, etc and then they'll iterate it on it

quote:

---

I dont see the point in coming with lyrics only. The melody is what makes the song

---

Classic if almost certainly apocryphal Broadway story:

Mrs Jerome Kern and Mrs Oscar Hammerstein were at a party. Mrs Kern introduced herself by saying, "My husband wrote 'Old Man River'".

To which Mrs Hammerstein replied, " No, my husband wrote 'Old Man River'. Her husband wrote, 'Daaah dah, dah dah'".

quote:

---

ETA: I typically write lyrics first then music but most others I know do the opposite.

---

Yeah, that's definitely the opposite of the way most people do it. But if it works for you, it works.

From what I’ve read. Ronnie normally wrote lyrics after hearing a melody. For example when Ed King came up with the Sweet Home riff, he told Ed to keep playing it. After a little while he sent the rest of the band outside and penned the lyrics.

I think he was inspired by melodies to write lyrics

quote:

---

2 Broadway show teams:

Rodgers & Hart - Rodgers wrote the music first

Rodgers & Hammerstein - Hammerstein wrote the lyrics first

---

Thank you. Someone needed to please the OT’s broadway show tunes crowd.

quote:

---

After a little while he sent the rest of the band outside and penned the lyrics.

---

Ronnie went down to the river and fished off the dock at hell house, coming up with lyrics, as he could hear the band inside the shack playing.

In college, I would collaborate with a friend of mine who also played the guitar. We would sit around and come up with some chords and just start adding lyrics. Sometimes he would take the lead and vice versa. Most of the songs were pornographic and raunchy but we were a big hit at parties and sang at a local juke joint from time to time.

Watch the Get Back documentary on the Beetles. As someone with no experience or musical talent, it was fascinating watching them work and morph songs until they turned into the hits most people know today.