re: American Idol Season 18

Happy with the top 10

Jonny & Dillon had best performances imo

quote:

---

Louie
Julia
Jovin
Grace
Jonny
Sophia
Arthur
Just Sam
Dillon
Francisco
Makayla - judges save

---

Damn that really is a very good group.

The only two I don’t love are Johnny and Grace. But neither of those were a surprise because they’ve played up Johnny all season and the one country girl was always going to top 10, which is why I was so bummed to see her get in over Lauren Miscitti who I really think is a star. Hopefully she’ll be back next year.


The only ones I was sad to see go we’re Franklin and Olivia, but I can see why they didn’t make it.


Other than that this is right group. Pumped for my girl Julia!! Wasn’t sure she’d make it.


Here’s my order:

1. Arthur
2. Sam
3. Jovin
4. Sophia
5. Dillon
6. Julia
7. Louie
8. Francisco
9. Makayla
10. Johnny
11. Grace


Again, still bummed we aren’t getting to see these guys on the real Idol stage. This home video shite is so lame.

Would be awesome if they surprised us with a true live finale for the final 5. The risk at this point for such a small group of people is just practically nothing. They could easily keep them separated and give them the performances they deserve imo.

Based on their performances last night, my top 7 would be:
Louie
Jovin
Grace
Johnny
Arthur
Julia
Makayla

Jovin was the best last week and now he doesn't make it..

Wow.. Some of these people tonight, especially the girl who sang Beauty and the Beast absolutely sucked.

I’ve kinda lost interest since a Jovin is out

ETA
I’m not an Idol watcher
My Grandpa started watching it because of Jovin
It gives us something to talk about since we can’t visit right now

Who was your 2nd favorite?

quote:

---

tHis format at home..I just can't get into it at all...

---

Yeah, it's a shame.

I really didn't think they would go to this, but I suppose it's better than just abruptly ending the season.

It has been so damn anticlimactic for one of the best groups they’ve had to have this webcam bullshite. Really bummed we didn’t get to see what they could do with the coaching and the big stage

Kingbob, was Jovin disappointed with the way the season was so different? Hopefully he still caught the eye of some producers and gets break, I’m sure he will


Seems to me it’s a pretty clear two horse race between Arthur and Sam.

I’ve been a Gunn advocate since Day 1, hoping he pulls it off

My pick is Just Sam.

Don’t really care who wins it as my favs are all gone