0
- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: Miami - ND game...Catch or no catch?
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:00 am to lsupride87
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:00 am to lsupride87
quote:
He had possesion with two feet in the endzone and then took a third atep with possession
I think he lost possession just before the 3rd step happens.
quote:
How many seconds is required for possession
I don't think it's about time. It's about that 3rd step. And, to be honest, I'm assuming the rule in college is the same as the NFL. That's an assumption on my part.
So, I think you had the rule right. Did he have firm possession when the 3rd step came down. If yes, it's a catch. If no, it's not.
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:01 am to East Coast Band
I think it’s a catch.
But I payback is a bitch. Miami was bailed out a few times this season.
But I payback is a bitch. Miami was bailed out a few times this season.
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:06 am to Andrew82
quote:
It should be no different than a ball carrier crossing the plane of the goal line
Agree with this. A runner can hit the pylon with the ball coming out his hand and it’s called a TD
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:17 am to SoggyCerealClub
quote:
Agree with this. A runner can hit the pylon with the ball coming out his hand and it’s called a TD
But the WR never had possession of the ball in the first place according to the ruling.
Runners who hit pylons have control/possession when they hit it, then lose the ball.
Just not the same scenario
Posted on 11/9/26 at 9:44 am to Buckeye06
He had both hands on the ball with 2 feet in the endzone. That’s a catch.
If he loses control of the ball once he’s out of bounds, it’s irrelevant because he’s already out of bounds.
If he loses control of the ball once he’s out of bounds, it’s irrelevant because he’s already out of bounds.
Posted on 11/9/26 at 10:10 am to East Coast Band
In my perfect world where what a catch is is common sense again that's a catch. In the current world it's a toss up, but as he was bringing the ball down it surely didn't look secure.
Ref on the field called it incomplete, and don't think there is enough there to overturn. If he had called it a touchdown think that stands too.
Obviously it changes that ND would still have had to go down and score, but ND would have been getting the ball back with ~3 minutes and 3 timeouts. I like the chances still of winning the game.
Miami getting screwed by the refs narrative is stupid. They didn't get a single false start or holding called the whole game and they were doing a ton of each. Refs didn't really make any calls that favored one team over the other, minus the "targeting" check that was clear as day not targeting giving Miami a break.
Ref on the field called it incomplete, and don't think there is enough there to overturn. If he had called it a touchdown think that stands too.
Obviously it changes that ND would still have had to go down and score, but ND would have been getting the ball back with ~3 minutes and 3 timeouts. I like the chances still of winning the game.
Miami getting screwed by the refs narrative is stupid. They didn't get a single false start or holding called the whole game and they were doing a ton of each. Refs didn't really make any calls that favored one team over the other, minus the "targeting" check that was clear as day not targeting giving Miami a break.
Posted on 11/9/26 at 10:49 am to East Coast Band
You have to complete the process of the catch. He did not. That's a pretty easy call. No need for any debate.
Posted on 11/9/26 at 12:12 pm to East Coast Band
Control inbounds = catch
Posted on 11/9/26 at 1:03 pm to QJenk
What’s the process of completing a catch beyond catching it with your hands?
Posted on 11/9/26 at 3:06 pm to East Coast Band
Nobody should call that a catch. He did have it for a moment but the DB made a great play to prevent him from securing the ball. You arent getting that catch in the backyard this Thanksgivi
Posted on 11/9/26 at 4:54 pm to East Coast Band
This is an incomplete pass.
Page 3 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News