re: LHSAA week 10… brackets announced Sunday morning

quote:

---

No Iw A kick is a kick until it is possessed by R Touchback

---

Originally I thought that

But someone on the field told me ref told coaches it was an IW

In St. Louis Catholic any good?

quote:

---

iW would not have placed ball at 20

---

IW while ball is in end zone uncovered?

They 100 percent called it an IW. But I’m thinking maybe it wasn’t really an IW because the ball was dead the moment it broke the plane by being knocked into the end zone by players in the field trying to secure the loose kick?

Maybe wrong explanation but right result?

quote:

---

calling them an opt out is bullshite.

---

I didn’t call them an opt out. Catholic is 18-0 vs the opt outs. 32-1 vs the public 5As including Zachary. 1 loss to Woodlawn who also voted to reunite.

quote:

---

IW while ball is in end zone uncovered?

They 100 percent called it an IW. But I’m thinking maybe it wasn’t really an IW because the ball was dead the moment it broke the plane by being knocked into the end zone by players in the field trying to secure the loose kick?

Maybe wrong explanation but right result?

---

The ball was never possessed by R before it reached the goal line, there for it is a DEAD ball and a TOUCHbACK at that point- if a whistle was blown then(which there was no whistle until much later in the play(which is not an actual IW but a delayed whistle). There was NO whistle while ball was anywhere near goal line. An IW would have led to several different scenarios depending on when it was blown - none of which would have placed ball at 20.

do you know the white hats signal for an IW?


someone that doesn't know the kicking rules, did not see ball cross goal or misconstrued something they heard may have thought it was an IW. but an IW would have led to a completely different scenario after said call.

What also could have happened was either Back, side or field judge or umpire could have said was that an IW(because they are not watching ball on a kickoff and neither is white hat under this years mechanic.
The way a whistle gets blown on a play like that when the crew realizes it should have been killed often appears as an IW, it sucks when a kid gets hurt on a play like that

So wait, are you telling me that people are crying foul and that the referees were cheating for a certain team, when the truth is, that person just did not know the right rules?



Shocked I tell you

quote:

---

So wait, are you telling me that people are crying foul and that the referees were cheating for a certain team, when the truth is, that person just did not know the right rules?

---

What I would have gave to be in the WJ press box when that happened… from Marchese going “what the h, this is ridiculous” to the PA announcer screaming for the whole West Bank to hear “TOUCHDOWN!!!!”…

It’s at 1h 19m of this stream LINK

quote:

---

Catholic would have more playoff losses in the non select playoffs in all sports

---

But it's not fair for Catholic to play the non-selects?

quote:

---

wanted to ensure a 7 man crew, also many schools like scheduling thursday games in week 10 to get an extra day of rest or go scout in person possible playoff opponents. kenny G did this pretty much the whole time he coached at PBS.

---

Booker T. Washington vs. DeLaSalle had a seven-man crew last night. Good thing, too, that was a chippy game.

quote:So wait, are you telling me that people are crying foul and that the referees were cheating for a certain team, when the truth is, that person just did not know the right rules? What I would have gave to be in the WJ press box when that happened… from Marchese going “what the h, this is ridiculous” to the PA announcer screaming for the whole West Bank to hear “TOUCHDOWN!!!!”…


So y’all weren’t talking about Catholic Z game?