Started By
Message

How do other states handle Public vs Private in HS football?

Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:03 pm
Posted by EvrybodysAllAmerican
Member since Apr 2013
11120 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:03 pm
I get both sides of the argument but hate the current set up. Too many teams making post-season is a joke, and the regular season/district standing now means nothing. But i also see the advantages a private school has.

Surely some other states have this figured out.
Posted by 5thTiger
Member since Nov 2014
7996 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:08 pm to
In Missouri, everyone is part of the same state association. Private schools numbers are doubled (or some other formula) for classifications.

That is pretty much it. Everyone plays everyone.

For example: Rockhurst HS (private boys HS in KC) has around 1000 students. Normally, that would put them in Class 4 (out of 6). But since they are private, their numbers are doubled. Then they become Class 6 for competition.

This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 4:11 pm
Posted by EvrybodysAllAmerican
Member since Apr 2013
11120 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:14 pm to
Do they double the number for a co-ed private school too? because they would have half as many boys. Interesting.
Posted by 5thTiger
Member since Nov 2014
7996 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:20 pm to
quote:

Do they double the number for a co-ed private school too?


Yep. Double single sex privates...and just looked it up 1.35 multiplier for private schools.

So if you are a single sex, you double, then add 1.35 multiplier.

Co-ed private has 1.35 multiplier after doubling as well
This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 4:30 pm
Posted by CelticDog
Member since Apr 2015
42867 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:21 pm to
in California the Catholic schools dominate football. they give scholarships to the best players coming up. De La Salle is #1 year in year out. Other Catholic, Lutheran and protestant Christian schools win the smaller school classifications.

Mater Dei dominates basketball.

2015 results
BERKELEY -- The Bishop O'Dowd High boys basketball team took down four-time defending state champion Mater Dei-Santa Ana 65-64 in overtime in Saturday's Open Division final, finally putting an end to more than three decades of state title game frustrations.

a generation ago, a small division public school defeated Mater Dei in a match game between the Class A champ public school undefeated and the big class champs. the coach was the father of one of the players. Cap Lavin, and his son went on to coach UCLA and St Johns.
This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 9:32 pm
Posted by stlslick
St.Louis,Mo
Member since Nov 2012
14054 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:22 pm to
quote:

Do they double the number for a co-ed private school too? because they would have half as many boys. Interesting.


yes, which screws over some of the smaller, religious, co-ed schools.

They had to put in the multiplier, especially when you have 1 school, who literally recruits kids from 2 states to go there(Rockhurst)
Posted by genro
Member since Nov 2011
61788 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 4:24 pm to
Private schools in AL use a 1.35 multiplier in classification (6 classes)

Some of the smallest privates have their own organization completely separate from the AHSAA
This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 4:27 pm
Posted by AlonsoWDC
Memphis, where it ain't Ten-a-Key
Member since Aug 2014
8748 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 5:13 pm to
Tennessee, to the best of my memory and keeping up with this thing since playing, works like this.

There is one HS athletic body in the state (TSSAA) and the vast majority (95%+) compete in what is known as DI. DI includes all of Tennessee's public schools and a portion of its private ones. DI is grouped A through 3A in non-football sports by enrollment and region. Football is grouped A through 6A. Private schools that offer athletic scholarships get a multiplier applied to their enrollment.

DII is much smaller and consists of private schools primarily (if not entirely) from the metro areas of Memphis, Jackson, Nashville, Chattanooga, and Knoxville. They are divided into A and 2A for all sports by enrollment.

My HS is private and did not offer athletic schollies and competed in DI in an A region during my time there. They have since moved to DII to be with other private schools in the Memphis and Jackson area. The Jackson private schools were all DI at the time but now I think all of them have moved to DII with us.

I could be wrong, but that's the nuts and bolts of it.

Edit. I am wrong. DI schools that charge tuition must not offer scholarships of any kind. Those that do must be in DII. Private schools in DI still get a multiplier.
This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 5:19 pm
Posted by mizzoubuckeyeiowa
Member since Nov 2015
35387 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 5:17 pm to
Yeah Cali is overwhelmed with big famous private high schools...like Mater Dei and De La Salle (which won 151 games in a row without losing - national record.)

But California public schools like Long Beach Poly was named by Sports Illustrated as the #1 Sports School of the Century.

So, it's not like Louisiana where public schools just lost to private schools.

It's a good balance in Cali.

Posted by BamaSaint
Mobile, Al
Member since Mar 2013
2938 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 7:38 pm to
quote:

(6 classes)

There's 7 classes now. The upcoming season will be the third year with class 7A
Posted by ShaneTheLegLechler
Member since Dec 2011
60090 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 7:41 pm to
Texas they are completely separate leagues and classifications. Strake Jesuit and Dallas Jesuit play in the highest public class (6A formerly 5A) but they are exceptions.
Posted by brewhan davey
Audubon Place
Member since Sep 2010
32775 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 8:37 pm to
quote:

Strake Jesuit and Dallas Jesuit play in the highest public class (6A formerly 5A) but they are exceptions.



What's the reason behind that? Are they the only two private schools playing in a public class?
Posted by ShaneTheLegLechler
Member since Dec 2011
60090 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 8:41 pm to
I don't remember the original story around them joining, I know Strake was indepedent for a bit. They are the only two privates that play with public schools though and both are pretty competitive.


A lot of public schools play the larger private schools out of district, especially in basketball and baseball.
This post was edited on 6/7/16 at 8:42 pm
Posted by BayouBengal
Member since Nov 2003
28275 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 9:28 pm to
quote:

What's the reason behind that? Are they the only two private schools playing in a public class?


I think what lends to the public schools being so strong in Texas is the ISD setup. It's not County based. Meaning an individual town or part of a town can form an ISD with primarily higher income and high property values to fund just their schools. They don't have the expenses of a real city or at a much smaller scale and leech all of the benefits of being near a big city while contributing nothing back to that city. See Southlake just outside of DFW, they can set up zoning and laws to essentially keep "the poors" out. That is unless you can play football or baseball real well then I'm sure an affordable apartment suddenly becomes available.
Posted by GeorgiaTide
Georgia
Member since Aug 2012
673 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 10:39 pm to
In Georgia, the stark contrast isn't so much private vs. public as it is city vs. county schools. City schools here are allowed to admit out of district students if they pay tuition and of course the city schools offer scholarships to out of district athletes. This results in the city schools basically acting as private schools with even larger resources and alumni base. The city schools in the larger counties dominate because they are basically fielding county all star teams pulling from the surrounding county schools.

There are a few private schools that do well in the smaller classifications, but for the most part high school athletics, especially football and basketball, are dominated by city schools.
Posted by KCM0Tiger
Kansas City, MISSOURI
Member since Nov 2011
15507 posts
Posted on 6/7/16 at 11:35 pm to
quote:

In Missouri, everyone is part of the same state association. Private schools numbers are doubled (or some other formula) for classifications.

That is pretty much it. Everyone plays everyone.

For example: Rockhurst HS (private boys HS in KC) has around 1000 students. Normally, that would put them in Class 4 (out of 6). But since they are private, their numbers are doubled. Then they become Class 6 for competition.



And it's extreme bullshite. Private schools can recruit, especially those in KC and STL that can draw talent from entirely different states (ks and IL). Yeah they have a "multiplier" on private schools that move them up a class, but they still have an unfair advantage over public schools (see Rockhurst in KC, SLUH, Vianney, CBC in STL).

Private schools should compete against private schools. Public schools should compete against public schools. Simple as that.
Posted by chalmetteowl
Chalmette
Member since Jan 2008
47419 posts
Posted on 6/8/16 at 12:16 am to
And as a result yall dont have the best football possible... I get private schools have to attract kids, but public doesn't. They can just draw a line and get every kid in it. If they don't have enough money, they just hit up taxpayers like you and me for more
Posted by Buckeye Backer
Columbus, Ohio
Member since Aug 2009
9228 posts
Posted on 6/8/16 at 6:08 am to
In the state of Ohio, Catholic schools have been dominating for the better part of 40 years. It reached a point of no return and a vote to split the public/private schools took place. Once that happened the OHSAA put in place a multiplier that will take place in 2017. Basically, the new policy will make it harder for kids to transfer just to play sports....in both public and private.

Public Schools:

Kids who transfer during high school will be counted as x2.

Private Schools:

Kids who transfer during middle school will eventually be counted as x2. Kids who transfer during high school will be counted as x3.
Posted by tress4pres
Columbus, OH
Member since Dec 2007
3855 posts
Posted on 6/8/16 at 6:52 am to
Further in Ohio, there are 7 divisions all based on number of boys per HS, with the largest being Div 1. Each division is broken up into 4 regions, with the top 8 teams making the playoffs based on total computer points (about 1/3 of the teams the state). All publics and privates compete vs each other in all divisions and all sports. Competitive balance is supposed to help even it out in 2017, but all it will do is bump smaller private schools up to larger divisions. Since 2000, publics have only won the D1 title 4 times (Upper Arlington - 2000, Cincinnati Colerain - 2004, Hilliard Davidson - 2006 & 2009). The rest have been won by Cincy and Cleveland private schools.
Posted by BatonrougeCajun
Somewhere in Texas
Member since Feb 2008
6056 posts
Posted on 6/8/16 at 7:25 am to
In regards to the two Jesuits in Texas the reason they are in The UIL(public league) and not TAAPS (private) is because they are both overwhelmingly larger then every other private school in the state. TAAPS refused them membership so they petitioned the UIL and an exception was made. If Both Jesuits were in TAAPS they would never lose in any sport ever.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram