re: Best RB in your favorite NFL team history

Fred Taylor
MJD

Really my only choices

Deuce McAllister

quote:

---

Rueben Mayes.

---

I was him for Halloween in the mid/late 80's. I think the number on the generic Walmart saints jersey just matched his but I thought it was awesome. No black face though.

quote:

---

A lot of people say Steve Van Buren is the greatest Eagles RB ever, but it was a very different game when he played.

---

tell us more

Deuce
Hilliard
PT
Muncie

quote:

---

1) Deuce McAllister
2) Dalton Hilliard
3) George Rodgers

---

I know this will ruffle feathers around here, but Rodgers was much much better than Hilliard -- and better than Deuce. He would have made the HOF if not for cocaine.

quote:

---

I know this will ruffle feathers around here, but Rodgers was much much better than Hilliard -- and better than Deuce. He would have made the HOF if not for cocaine.

---

Rodgers had horrible balance

quote:

---

For the Saints it is obviously Deuce McAllister. Honorable mention goes to the very underrated Pierre Thomas.

---

And a huge 'could have been' to Chuck Muncie

deuce mcallister before his first acl tear was so good. i think that 2003 season was the one where he had over 60 catches as well. even in 2006 after the injury he managed over 1,000 yards which at the time was still pretty rare for a RB to do coming off an ACL. deuuuuuuuce

for pats

1 - curtis martin
2- corey dillon
3-because this is a lsu board will say kevin faulk