re: 10 best college qb's who sucked in the nfl

Yeah, Frazier belongs no where near that list. Same with Moore.

But it's clear that the person who wrote the list is very young.

You could argue who is #1 in college based on accomplishment, awards and media love...

Tebow or Leinart or Young (though Young never won the Heisman.)

Between Tebow or Leinart (not many people took Tebow seriously at the next level.)

So based on college accomplishment, stats, award and perceived ability - Leinart has to be #1.

He produced almost nothing at the next level compared to his college career and where he was drafted...hell, he might have been #1 if he doesn't stay for another year. Unlike Crouch, Frazier or Tebow and Young...scouts saw Leinart as a real deal star QB at the next level.

As much as I hate to admit...Leinart is the poster child for awesome college career with pro potential who didn't do squat at the next level.

Tebow started and won the majority of his games. Got his team almost as far as they got with Peyton Manning.

Tebow sucks, but he's far from deserving to be on the list. He led his team to the playoffs and won a playoff game after passing for 300 plus yards. Most of these other scrubs may have started some games, but never led their teams to the playoffs.

And to say that Tebow led them to the playoffs is a false statement.

quote:

---

Posted by Sophandros And to say that Tebow led them to the playoffs is a false statement.

---

If nothing else, a very liberal use of the word "led."

Also, the thread title is misleading from the intent of the article. The list is top 10 college QBs who never made it big in the NFL.

That at least makes sense then to include guys who never got a real shot like Moore, White, and Crouch.

slideshows are so annoying

I guess Tebow didn't make the throw to beat the steelers either.

1-4 to 7-4. No way a quarterback who came into the starting role after 1-4 and leading then to 8-8 should be classified as leading his team. No way.

quote:

---

I guess Tebow didn't make the throw to beat the steelers either.

1-4 to 7-4. No way a quarterback who came into the starting role after 1-4 and leading then to 8-8 should be classified as leading his team. No way.

---

I mean Denver's offense went from 21 ppg pre Tebow to 18 ppg after he took over, and the defense went from 28 ppg pre Tebow to 22.7 ppg after he took over....the team played better after he became starter no doubt, but it isn't like he was carrying the load

Yes he made his teammates better. Dudes a flat out leader. What's past tense that a leader does? Led.

Just because jamarcus was by far the best qb lsu has seen this century doesn't mean his college career was anything near that of those guys on the list.