re: Overturned "scoop and score" for OSU...what are the thoughts?

Looked like a fumble to me.

I thought it was the right call. Live speed it was incomplete. When you slow it down you can find football moves if you want. It was very similar to Jefferson’s in our game.

The ref the announcers talked to said it would be overturned. When he explained it, it made sense to me.

I think it was a catch and fumble. Anyone surprised that the officiating crew being scrutinized is from the SEC?

I think it was incomplete, but not inconclusive...That is a tough replay to overturn. I would of kept whatever was called on the field.

My thought is that I have no fricking idea what the rational is for that not being a catch. He wasn't bobbling it. He had full control.

Total absurdity

He took 3 if not 4 steps after catch and ball was never loose until defender forced it out. Even if it was a close call and some say it could go either way then it should have gone with the call on the field which was catch/fumble.

From the moment it happened, I said no catch. Still stand by that!

Good call

The three steps were while he was gathering the ball. Whether it takes one step or three or more to land and gather himself, it's not a "football move" separate from the catch.

He didn't turn upfield at all, never had a chance, because he was still catching the ball.

If I'm interpreting that correctly, they would do better to drop "football move" and define it as any action that is distinct from the catch and happens after catch is complete.