re: Hey Haters, Meet Justin McMillan, LSU QB

quote:

---

And you based all of that on what? When did Brennan show those great attributes? Do you feel dual threat QBs are incapable of passing in general or just at LSU? Who had the better passing game on Saturday? Who was more effective on Saturday?

---

He made some throws Saturday that neither of the other two would have or could have made. I did notice McMillan miss multiple very short, what should be high percentage throws. Missing those are drive killers. I feel like dual threat quarterbacks in the offense we’re trying to run aren’t capable of succeeding. Especially when you look at the guys that have been our backs for the past many years, we haven’t needed a dual threat guy. We’ve needed a guy that can keep the defense from putting nine in the box.

I don’t give a damn about a glorified scrimmage in which sacks aren’t counted apparently and they haven’t even installed the entire offense. I do know that I saw a guy more than capable of making every throw and for what we’ve been wanting recently, he seems to fit the mold.

quote:

---

Well actually someone did know. A number of players have said McMillan was legit and could win the job, including Harris, Etling, Chark and Moreau

---

Yeah because his teammates are really gonna say that he sucks.

quote:

---

Mett couldn’t beat out Jordan Jefferson or Jarret Lee

---

Zach Mettenberger was better than either jefferson or lee and should have been on the field from day one.

Claiming he didn't know the offense is LSU fan speak for, Duh.

quote:

---

. Ever heard of Deshaun Watson, who threw for 400+ yards in back to back years against the vaunted Bama defense? He is a dual threat.

---

McMillan isn't Deshaun Watson We beat out the likes of Arkansas State for his services. I realize teams find a diamond in the rough occasionally but let's be realistic. He's a dual threat guy with a below average arm who's older and more experienced than our other 2 options

quote:

---

The dude couldn’t beat out Anthony Jennings, Brandon Harris, or Danny Etlin

---

Jamarcus coundnt beat out ......

quote:

---

He was having a good Senior year until he got ran over by Miles for his love child JJ. Always hated Miles for this.

---

We don't win the sec if that change wasn't made. Don't lose in the title game. Maybe Les is still here because that rematch would never have happened.

I feel like more people we're pissed for losing that game, then if we just never made it and won whatever bowl game.

quote:

---

You saw McMillan miss some passes? Did you see Brennan miss any passes?

---

I didn’t see Brennan miss any 2 yard flat routes to running backs. I didn’t see Brennan’s balls dying on him out there like McMillan’s and our quarterback from last year. I did however see Brennan be on time and accurate with a lot more of his throws than McMillan.

Take away two throws that would’ve been sacks on both Narcisse and McMillan and Brennan looks the best.

Hell, those two didn’t even manage to complete 50% of their passes.

quote:

---

You never answered which you thought performed better in that scrimmage. Or which passed better?

---

I think, Brennan threw better. Yep, that’s right. I think Brennan showed that he has what it takes to be our quarterback. If you fix the offensive line, Brennan blows the other two away.

quote:

---

Somehow you and many like you feel a dual threat can't stop a defense from putting 9 in the box. And you assume every dual threat at LSU will be the same as any that came before them. Ever heard of Deshaun Watson, who threw for 400+ yards in back to back years against the vaunted Bama defense? He is a dual threat.

---

First, I never said dual threats can’t perform at LSU. I said that with the offenses we’ve trotted out there for years does not allow for a dual threat to flourish.

Second, your comparison of a two time heisman trophy finalist and a guy that would’ve won offensive rookie of the year this passed year in the NFL to what we’ve put out there is laughable to say the least.

You don’t know a thing about quarterbacking and it shows.

quote:

---

J. Lee was a top three Texas QB as well.

---

J Lee was benched with 152 QB rating and going 14 TD's vs 3 Int's in the 2011 season while playing for a offensive coaching deficient team according to this board.
Whatever you think of Lee he was the best on that team.

No one hates McMillian, but I do hope the best qb plays and CEO chooses the best of the 3.

He looks like the best option.

You won’t get most of the guys here off the Myles Brennan train though. In their minds he is already the starter which I think is ridiculous. In my eyes he looks too small.