Started By
Message

re: Assigning fault for baseball—want your opinion

Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:18 am to
Posted by Tiger Ugly
Baton Rouge
Member since Jul 2008
18699 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:18 am to
quote:

Of course its evaluation, which is ultimately jay’s responsibility. Im confident he’ll get it fixed for the next few years


Exactly, we gave him his flowers and rightfully so for the titles, ultimately he made the decisions on roster construction and the quality of play this year is honestly not acceptable for kids at this level - some of which has little or nothing to do with talent level, just poor fundamental baseball.

And as the head man - in the end that falls on him.

I think he will make the right adjustments. But this year has been very disappointing in almost every aspect.
Posted by PurpNGold1985
Member since Mar 2025
622 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:21 am to
quote:

If this is near the top of concerns in your life, you must live at home.


I made a thread while drinking my coffee and watching the news this morning. sue me arsehole.
Posted by TopWaterTiger
Lake Charles, LA
Member since May 2006
12379 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:25 am to
I still say defense.

If defense was just slightly above average LSU wins last night and a several other games this season.
Posted by canyon
MM23
Member since Dec 2003
22195 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:31 am to
Pitchers not hitting their locations. Killed us last night.
Posted by hashtag
Comfy, AF
Member since Aug 2005
33651 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:34 am to
quote:

Jay is now overthinking things with all the pitching changes at odd times.
bruh. What do you want him to do? He doesn't have a starter that can consistently go 5 innings. That was BEFORE Cooper Moore got hurt. And he has 0 relievers that are consistent. He's flipping a coin from inning to inning, batter to batter because 0 pitchers on our staff have stepped up and proven they can be trusted for any length of time.
Posted by Tigerfan1274
Member since May 2019
4685 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:34 am to
quote:

The portal guys this year across college baseball weren't as good as previous years.


Great point. You can’t make them enter the portal. There were rumors last year that Justin LeBron and Ace Reese were going to enter. Never happened. And with rev share in the P5 and the some schools increasing scholarship numbers, there may be less sure things from good programs (like Tommy White) entering the portal.
Posted by CDawson
Louisiana
Member since Dec 2017
20269 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:42 am to
LSU bought in on the stats and analytics of mid major players thinking it would translate to SEC plate. It doesn’t.

Analytics are only a part of a strategy and shouldn’t be used as the total point of projection.
Posted by JakeRStephenes
Member since Feb 2012
3142 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 8:46 am to
Jay already took responsibility for this - he said it was bad roster construction. He was chasing power numbers to replace Jones and Frey, and it didn't work out. What he failed to realize is that those power numbers didn't come from the approach that Jay likes to implement.

Simple as that.
Posted by Tigris Christi
Member since Jul 2016
2246 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 9:11 am to
Defense is the 1A answer, pitching staff giving up free bases like Oprah gives out shitty books is 1B. I do believe Evan’s and Schmidt’s ERAs would likely in the low 3’s or high 2’s if we had last years infield. Baseball is such a mental game. Errors lead to more earned runs and over the course of the season it can snowball.
Posted by outerstater
Member since Jan 2022
1023 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 9:29 am to
It's probably the hardness thing in the world to think you know what someone will do when the test comes down. You can marry a beautiful woman, but she might turn ugly later. You didn't think that when you married.(just a joke now).
Posted by Chardee MacDennis
Pennsylvania
Member since Jan 2024
351 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 9:34 am to
Ronnie Rantz

We were 8-0 until he started calling games
Posted by easy money
Member since Feb 2005
15403 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 9:34 am to
The team was built for slugging and power pitching. Not enough ball players that can run and defend. Not enough left had pitchers. A lot of pitchers that throw the same stuff from the same arm slot.

Posted by SOL2
Dallas burbs
Member since Jan 2020
8987 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 9:35 am to
My opinion is, this is not a very good team , especially the pitching, fielding and hitting. Fat and slow
Posted by Tzanghi
Member since Nov 2020
1448 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 10:37 am to
There is a global psychological issue with this entire team this year. I see multiple players who won a national championship last year who are now just run of the mill guys. Stanny led the SEC with n doubles last year and is now batting like .230. Cavan Evans has had one good start the whole year against any competition. Even Brown’s average was dropping like a stone before he got hurt. This is a global psychological/cultural issue or you would otherwise see parts of the team performing well.
Posted by Barrylsu
Mandeville LA
Member since May 2009
650 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:17 am to
CJ has done a great job of coaching his team. When he took over he had some CPM players on board along what he brought in and that lasted for a total of four years of his tenure. This is the fifth year now it’s all new and simpley put he flunked the course this time andif the same thing happens next year then I guess we’ll know he’s not the great baseball coach we thought he was. Another words he’s on the clock.
Posted by sharkfhin
Water
Member since Sep 2008
6247 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:33 am to
Like WW said. It ain't the jockey, you gotta have the horses. We ain't got the horses this year.

This post was edited on 4/25/26 at 11:35 am
Posted by Portcityblues
Member since Jan 2017
1616 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:34 am to
Pitching, pitch calling, and recruiting power over all around performance.
Posted by ArcticTiger
North Pole
Member since Nov 2018
2853 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:36 am to
No one group, players or coaches, that can be singlehandedly blamed. Shared blame for sure.
Posted by Dead Mike
Cell Block 4
Member since Mar 2010
4062 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:56 am to
quote:

Jay already took responsibility for this - he said it was bad roster construction. He was chasing power numbers to replace Jones and Frey, and it didn't work out. What he failed to realize is that those power numbers didn't come from the approach that Jay likes to implement. Simple as that.


That seems like a big part of it, and is probably about as forthright as you can expect from a coach.

I think this years team can be summed up by HOLA - How to Lose Awareness. If you look at the expected wins of each SEC team, and you think back to several of the close games that we’ve dropped, there are so many moments where we’ve come up short when we’re primed to win. So many late game defensive blunders, so many atrocious at-bats in advantaged situations - this all goes back to the roster construction.

I also think that defensive lapses at catcher throughout the season have exacerbated this, and have really hurt the pitching performances (thinking of all the exaggerated framing and lack of reliable receiving). I feel like most other teams have a savvy defensive catcher with lackluster numbers, whereas we’ve cycled through two inexperienced catchers with great offensive potential (and performance), but doing no favors for the pitchers.

We should realistically be a mid-tier SEC team right now looking to make a run as we approach the postseason, but they’ve dug themselves too much of a hole, and we still don’t have the timely hitting and solid defensive play to change the outcome of these games.
Posted by Dead Mike
Cell Block 4
Member since Mar 2010
4062 posts
Posted on 4/25/26 at 11:59 am to
quote:

There is a global psychological issue with this entire team this year. I see multiple players who won a national championship last year who are now just run of the mill guys. Stanny led the SEC with n doubles last year and is now batting like .230. Cavan Evans has had one good start the whole year against any competition. Even Brown’s average was dropping like a stone before he got hurt. This is a global psychological/cultural issue or you would otherwise see parts of the team performing well.


Alternatively, maybe Stanfield is still pushing through a more serious injury (and re-injury) than was indicated, and alternatively, maybe Brown was trying to play through injury as well. This is going to the last season of college baseball for both of these guys.

Evans was not a sure Friday-night starter going into the season; I think it’s simply that no one else has stepped up to take that role from him, and he has a high ceiling if he can put it together consistently.
This post was edited on 4/25/26 at 12:01 pm
first pageprev pagePage 2 of 3Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram