Oak tree selection help por favor - selected shumard oak

What's your soil like (check Soil Web Survey)?

We have both willow oaks and shumard oaks in our yard and have planted both. I like both, willow oaks seem to grow faster here (central Arkansas) but they also seem more vulnerable to breaking large limbs in storms.

quote:

---

What's your soil like (check Soil Web Survey)?

---

Will do and post the results.

It is fairly sandy, that much I know.

ETA: I looked. It is called Orangeburg sandy loam

"Thanks! How does leaf raking compare between the 2 types?"

Willow oak leaves are slim and almost disappear. Shumard have bigger leaves.

I also have both, but those willow oak limbs keep snapping as the previous poster mentioned. I prefer Shumard.

Don't waste your time raking. Run over that shite with your mower

Though I don’t have any of the 3, each of my surrounding neighbors have one of the 3, and I’m the beneficiary of much of their winter leaves that I use as mulch.

Each tree is 25 years old. In my opinion the Shumard is the nicest looking, eye appeal, of the 3. The Willow oak is attractive and also the largest with the widest canopy - fastest growing. The Nutall oak, although nice looking, is the “twiggest” of the group and smallest (after 25 years), height and canopy wise.

Leaves of the willow oak can be used directly as mulch in the landscape bed without chopping. In Louisiana, the willow oak is designated as a LSU AgCenter Superplant.

Cherry Bark oak, almost identical to the Shumard, has fuzzy, lighter green color to the underside of the leaf, and has a very attractive eye-catching appeal when spring and fall winds blow and rustle the leaves.

quote:

---

Smaller, urban yard.

---

Based on the smaller, urban yard, Shumards, Nuttalls and Willow Oaks all get 40-50' spread which may be too big for your yard. If you want a smaller oak, look at the Georgia Oak.

quote:

---

Georgia Oak Georgia oaks (Quercus georgiana) are small, deciduous trees that grow 20 to 40 feet tall and with a 15 foot spread. The leaves are small, with three to six lobes; they turn bright red in the fall. Georgia oaks grow in rocky, dry areas of Georgia zones 7a, 7b and 8a. Georgia oaks are well-suited as specimen trees in small yards or along streets.

---

A non-oak but a great tree is the Chinese Pistache that gets 35' tall x 30' wide.

Have you looked into a Japanese Saw-tooth Oak?

I think they grow pretty fast.

Sawtooth Oak

10-4 I don't personally have any but my uncle does and I like their unique look. The Shumards are very nice looking oaks.

Thanks everyone for the recommendations!