re: Official Rate My Team Thread: Drop rosters in here with league settings...

My buddy drafted last night after shutting down bottomless mimosas and is currently melting after drafting this gem of a team

Does he have cause for concern?

12 team league
.5 PPR
Had #2 pick

QB: M. Stafford, J. Garopollo
RB: D. Johnson, D. Henry, N. Chubb, D. Booker
WR: M. Evans, J. Gordon, J. Smith-schuster, J. Nelson, D. Moore, D. Moncrief
TE: K. Rudolph, O. Howard
Def: Ravens,
Kicker: C. Boswell

Not a huge fan of this one either to be honest.

I like Jimmy G a lot, but he’s still an unkown at this point. So I prefer pairing him with someone who’s more reliable than Mariota, I would've tried to target Stafford, Ryan, Rivers, or Roethlisberger to make sure you at least had a low-end QB1 if Jimmy G doesn’t live up to the hype.

Gurley is obviously legit, and I actually like Lewis enough for him to be an RB2 in your lineup. I’m fading Miller and McCoy hard though, McCoy obviously has serious challenges this year and I suspect Foreman will overtake Miller by year’s end.

And I like your WRs, but not in the roles you need them to play. Fitz looks more WR2 to me, and Fuller is more WR3/Flex. I like Fuller and Lockett as the second receivers for elite QBs, but they’ll both have a number of weeks where they only give you 3-4 point performances, potentially costing you a couple games. Gallup and Richardson are both candidates for early drops as the elite free agents make themselves known over the first couple weeks. And I’m not a big fan of Williams either. Obviously a big natural talent, but I don’t think he’s a good enough route runner to generate the seperation he needs to be a starter in your lineup. His ceiling this year is a TD dependent flex imo.

Delanie is probably a safe bet as a low-mid range TE1.

I think it’ll be tough for you to make the playoffs honestly. Gonna need Garappolo to be a top 5 QB, Fuller to nearly match his ridiculous TD percentage from last year, Lewis to get a good number of goal line touches over henry, and one of your other WRs to really step it up big time. It’s possible, but I think you’re fighting an uphill battle.

Yea, he should be pretty bummed with that result. QB pair is great, but not enough RB depth after DJ, and I hate his WRs. Especially considering the folks typically going in the same range as Evans/Gordon/Schuster. Around those draft slots, he potentially could’ve had Devante Adams, TY Hilton, and Jarvis Landry, which would be a MUCH more intimidating wr set. Your buddy flopped hard.

10team 1/2 PPR

Brees
Gordon
Collins
Hopkins
Hilton
Miller
Engram
Ravens
Gostkowski

Garcon
Woods
Jordy
Aaron jones
Barber
Ty mont <- likely dropping for eckler or connor

12 team, Standard

QB: Newton, Mariota
RB: Cook, McCaffery, L. Miller, Chubb, Breida
WR: Thielen, Baldwin, Tate, Funchess, Cobb
TE: Engram
K: Tucker
D: Lions

Hard to tell really because 10 team leagues tend to have better all around rosters, but I don’t see any glaring issues, but one thing to keep an eye out for is your WR are thin af, and a pretty big drop off after DB.


10 Team PPR (bonus @40+ yd plays, 100yd rush/rec yd, 6pt PA TD)
QB, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, FLEX, FLEX, K, D/ST
5th pick; snake.

QB Newton
RB DJ, Cook, R. Freeman, K. Johnson, M. Breida, J. Kelly
WR Diggs, D. Thomas, C. Davis, DJ Moore, C. Meredith, A. Callaway
TE Njoku
K Gould
D/ST Baltimore

Thought I did well because some players fell to me that definitely shouldn’t have, but yahoo’s analysis shite all over my team. Worst draft grade and predicted to finish last. Can’t wait to outperform my rating.

Hopkins/CMC is a phenomenal pairing for a 12 man league. I am super high on McCaffrey this year. Top 2 TE, solid QB. Landry take a slight dip with it being .5 PPR, but still a good WR2. Corey Davis probably ends up as your flex.

I like your team quite a bit. Hard to imagine that roster being bad. High chance of playoffs







My team. 10 team PPR. 5th pick in draft

QB Wentz
RB Zeke Elliot
RB Devonta Freeman
WR Keenan Allen
WR Adam Thielen
TE Evan Engram
FLX Derrick Henry
DST Eagles
K Matt Bryant

Bench:

Brandin Cooks
Chris Thompson
Robby Anderson
Alshon Jeffery
Philip Rivers
Trequan Smith

Is it really asking too much to rate someone else's team and then post your team?

12 team ppr league

QB: Garrapalo, Tyrod Taylor
RB: Melvin Gordon, Rex Burkhead, AP, Chris Thompson, Matt Breida, Aaron Jones
WR: Deandre Hopkins, Larry Fitzgerald, Pierre Garcons, Anthony Miller, Christian Kirk
TE: Zach Ertz
DEF: Jags
K: Greg the leg