Is Brady already the GOAT?

if he loses does it solidify he isnt?

quote:

---

If not, does winning another solidify it?

---

he either is already the goat, or he isn't. This game won't firmly plant him as the goat or otherwise

Yes cmon man

In pro football, yes.

I don't think he's the GOAT but I do think he has the best story in NFL history.

yes. And its dumb to even question it

Brady is the goat already.

This is such a tough question. He's had so much success, and is continuing said success into his 40's, and it's painfully obvious he has never had the arm talent of a Favre, Manning, or even Cutler.

That being said, I hate comparing QBs across generations, and even in this generation Peyton Manning has done some amazing things. Peyton Manning managed to go from a down the field, arm strength style passer to an elite version of Chad Pennington with a brand new supporting cast. That's simply amazing, and I honestly have no idea if Tom Brady could have done that. I also think Manning grew up quite a bit when he played for the Broncos. I always remember him famously throwing his offensive lineman under the bus multiple times, but I was impressed with him and how he handled his time with the Broncos.

GOAT cheating system qb, sure