- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
So who’s really better? Brennan or Narcisse?
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:26 pm
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:26 pm
Continued from last night...
Looking back at recruiting profiles, Narcisse was more highly recruited than Brennan.
Brennan (#1 ranked QB in MS) didn't even garner an offer from Mississippi St. Nor did Arkansas, Auburn, or Alabama. Vandy, Ole Miss, Kentucky, and LSU were his only SEC offers. He legit only had 1 top tier program offer him in the SEC.
Narcisse (#2 ranked QB in LA) received offers from LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Clemson.
I know recruiting offers don't necessarily mean anything, but you're telling me not even Dan Mullen (who only has 3 scholarship qb's) didn't even extend an offer to brennan? that seems odd for the #1 qb in your own state.
After the random Tua offer, it makes me think that O and staff didn’t have confidence in Brennan and are holding out Lowell for next year because of his knee and to get a lot of reps in. Idk, just my .02
Looking back at recruiting profiles, Narcisse was more highly recruited than Brennan.
Brennan (#1 ranked QB in MS) didn't even garner an offer from Mississippi St. Nor did Arkansas, Auburn, or Alabama. Vandy, Ole Miss, Kentucky, and LSU were his only SEC offers. He legit only had 1 top tier program offer him in the SEC.
Narcisse (#2 ranked QB in LA) received offers from LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Clemson.
I know recruiting offers don't necessarily mean anything, but you're telling me not even Dan Mullen (who only has 3 scholarship qb's) didn't even extend an offer to brennan? that seems odd for the #1 qb in your own state.
After the random Tua offer, it makes me think that O and staff didn’t have confidence in Brennan and are holding out Lowell for next year because of his knee and to get a lot of reps in. Idk, just my .02
This post was edited on 11/12/17 at 4:28 pm
44
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:28 pm to SilverStallion
Narcisse by a mile.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:32 pm to SilverStallion
Brennan had everything but the physical development that coaches like to see. Look at how Jimbo Fisher is doing with an underweight Blackman at QB to see why Brennan wasn't heavily offered.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:34 pm to SilverStallion
We all know about high profile QB recruits. Just look how Harris worked out.
But to answer your question, they are 2 different QB's. Hard to compare since LN hasn't seen the field.
I hope one of them takes control of the offense this off season. If LN can throw the ball like Brennan, then he will be the starter, no doubts. But if he has issues hitting the back out of the backfield in Canada's offense, he will play, but doubt if he will start.
But to answer your question, they are 2 different QB's. Hard to compare since LN hasn't seen the field.
I hope one of them takes control of the offense this off season. If LN can throw the ball like Brennan, then he will be the starter, no doubts. But if he has issues hitting the back out of the backfield in Canada's offense, he will play, but doubt if he will start.
This post was edited on 11/12/17 at 4:36 pm
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:34 pm to SilverStallion
Whoever the backup is
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:44 pm to SilverStallion
Kinda hard to judge until they are running the O against a quality defense. However, just off of arm talent and going through drills. Narcisse jmo
Posted on 11/12/17 at 4:47 pm to SilverStallion
Just my opinion, but I honestly see Narcisse being the better QB. I’m judging in size and the fact that he is a mobile QB. We all saw how hard of a time bama had with a big, mobile QB. I would like to see what both can do, but if we judge on the amount of weapons it would be Narcisse
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:02 pm to SilverStallion
Based on what I've seen from the two, Narcisse is better, even with his accuracy concerns. His upside is higher as well.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:09 pm to SilverStallion
Narcisse will be more dominant
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:12 pm to SilverStallion
I think playing against the competition that Brennan played against in Mississippi hurt him. I think that's why some teams didn't offer him. His biggest test was Bro Martin at Tad Gormley and they only scored 7 points.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:24 pm to SilverStallion
Brennan is by far the better QB. Narcisse is the next "dual threat" which means he can't pass. Not to mention that Narcisse is coming off serious injuries to both knees.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:25 pm to SilverStallion
Will find out next year in camp 
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:31 pm to SilverStallion
I'd say if both were developed to their potential Brennan may have a slightly higher ceiling but Narcisse should have a fairly higher floor. Not sure we currently have the WR's to make Brennan look like Met just yet but they look promising.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 5:42 pm to SilverStallion
Depends on who you like better. Fanboys on both sides
Imagine both will see playing time next year
Imagine both will see playing time next year
Posted on 11/12/17 at 6:15 pm to SilverStallion
quote:
Looking back at recruiting profiles, Narcisse was more highly recruited than Brennan.
Brennan had more offers but they are two different styles of QB so got offers from different schools with the exception of LSU, Memphis, and Southern Miss. Here are all the offers they had according to 24/7
Brennan - LSU, Arkansas State, California, Cincinnati, Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana-Lafayette, Memphis, Oklahoma State, Ole Miss, South Alabama, Southern Miss, Texas-San Antonio, Troy, Vanderbilt, Wake Forest, West Virginia, Wisconsin
Narcisse - LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Arizona State, Clemson, Grambling State, Illinois, McNeese State, Memphis, Nicholls State, North Carolina, Southern Miss, Tulane, Virginia
quote:
Narcisse (#2 ranked QB in LA) received offers from LSU, Auburn, Alabama, Clemson.
Those were some of Narcise's Premiere offers, some of Brennan's were LSU, Cal, Okie State, Wisconsin, and West Virginia.
I do suspect Narcisse is ultimately the better fit for what Canada appears to be doing right now, but Canada is also known to tailor his offenses to fit the talent he has.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 6:58 pm to SilverStallion
Here's my question on LN....with him being a Dual Threat qb but having 2 major knee surgeries, will the coaches actually treat him like a dual threat and let him run like Hurts or not bc of fear for more injury?
Posted on 11/12/17 at 7:28 pm to SilverStallion
We will not know until next year. When one of the players beats out the other.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 7:35 pm to SilverStallion
If O goes Brennon or bust, does the staff keep Narcisse ready purely as a backup? Or can he be taught the WR position?
Posted on 11/12/17 at 7:49 pm to SilverStallion
The honest answer and fair answer is we don't have any idea. Now maybe the coaches know but no one on here does.
Posted on 11/12/17 at 8:05 pm to SilverStallion
Do a little research on the Elite 11 competition last year. I think that’ll give you a better idea of each kid coming in.
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News