We’re learning.. recruits not portal

I think it’s a combination of both depending on the season. Jay knows he needs to be adaptable.

He leaned too hard into transfer this year. He tried to trade up at 2B, 1B, 3B and struck out. Meanwhile the guys he let walk are performing well for someone else.

Retention is tough when you have a season like this, but that has to be the priority for the staff. The young guys can play.

We still need to portal the left side of the infield for next year.

Mikey Ryan, hitting .326 at NC State, 11 SBs, 9 HRs

Mikey Ryan is about it.

Hogg went to a juco looks like and Costello is hitting .246 at Maryland.

I don’t think we’d have kept Larson just to play 1st, though I think with hindsight being 20/20 keeping Ryan instead of getting either Simpson or Carraway to compete for 2nd or 3rd would have been smart.

You don’t think Ryan would have stayed to play 2B for a year then slide over to SS?

Jay told him we’d portal a couple infielders and let them all compete for 2B and 3B. Right or wrong, Jay’s recent comments about developing guys in the program tells me he wouldn’t make the same decision this year.

They tried to retool Simpson’s swing and it didn’t work. He came in a productive college hitter. Run him out there and see if it’ll work in the SEC. That’s what UGA does. I think frustration on both sides has led to what’s become of Simpson’s year with LSU.

Braun has covered up how much of a miss Yorke was. Caraway was always going to be a project, but they really thought Yorke would hit 4th every game and be an All SEC guy.

quote:

---

I think we are drawing bad conclusions from one bad crop of portal players.

---

And that will happen every year. The drawing conclusions from the most recent example I mean.

Both Yorke and Carraway were late adds after the draft. Both with familiarity, Yorke due to family, Carraway due to HS recruiting. I think if the draft or other portal guys worked out better, neither is here.

I have zero issue with Dardar being brought in. We were forced to put too much on his plate, but I love bringing in Louisiana guys when possible.

Simpson is the most puzzling to me. He was an early commit, so not a fallback. And while he tore up his conference, he was terrible against power conference pitching. And the best pitchers in his own conference were on his team. He’s not a supreme athlete, so he couldn’t grab and hold any positions defensively, and he can’t hit at this level.

Pitching wise, we didn’t get either of the top of the market starters (reddeman and Mack) but I’m not disappointed with Moore. I don’t think Garcia or Lachenmayer have been busts either. Both are better than what Justin Loer was. I really don’t hate the portal pitching class.

quote:

---

I think Austin roellig would have been useful to keep around. But the infield spot filled by the portal that year was Dickinson. He would definately be on the field for us most nights this year.

---

He would have had to have been okay with not playing much last year here. This is his second year away. I don’t disagree he would have helped, same with Kucherak, but they left for more playing time they wouldn’t have gotten here last year.

I just wish we woulda recruited Trey Halsey to play first base. That’s all

Stop saying Brady Neal we had him for two years he couldn’t field his position at catcher even tried him at outfield couldn’t even dh. We tried and tried to play that guy for 2 years he got to bama sucked last year found someone who taught him how to hit. He has done better but three years of sucking arse for one good year ain’t it.