- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Which is better: American Pie vs Superbad
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:47 pm
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:47 pm
23
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:49 pm to boomjosh
I wonder if your breakdown of choice is dependent more of age
I was 10 when American pie came out.. and yes it still dropped into the lexicon and zeitgeist such as MILF, the pie
But I was 17 when Superbad came out and entering freshman year of college.. and everyone my age quoted it relentlessly and our friends still do. It was a seminal movie experience for me
Superbad is my vote
I was 10 when American pie came out.. and yes it still dropped into the lexicon and zeitgeist such as MILF, the pie
But I was 17 when Superbad came out and entering freshman year of college.. and everyone my age quoted it relentlessly and our friends still do. It was a seminal movie experience for me
Superbad is my vote
This post was edited on 3/31/26 at 5:51 pm
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:51 pm to boomjosh
Peak Shannon Elizabeth is a tough out in this matchup
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:56 pm to boomjosh
Superbad for me but it was a big part of my generation. I was a sophomore in hs when it came out. American Pie was for the 90s teens, although it is solid as well.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:57 pm to Lawyered
I was thinking about it, and I like how Lawyered responded to the question.
I was 20 when American Pie came out so they were kind of in my wheel house.
I was 28 when Superbad came out and was already a Dad
I love both movies, but will probably always gravitate towards American Pie.
I was 20 when American Pie came out so they were kind of in my wheel house.
I was 28 when Superbad came out and was already a Dad
I love both movies, but will probably always gravitate towards American Pie.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 5:58 pm to boomjosh
quote:
American Pie
More universal in my opinion. It had something for everyone, and it was able to cover all of the different types of relationships for 90s kids in like one film. Sort of brilliant in that respect. More relatable to a wider group of people.
quote:
Superbad
Tighter, better overall humor. Better script.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:09 pm to boomjosh
3, 1, 2, 4
This post was edited on 3/31/26 at 6:10 pm
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:09 pm to boomjosh
I graduated high school just a year or 2 before American Pie and that movie really clicked with me.
Both movies are awesome though. There's no wrong answer.
and Shannon Elizabeth ...
Both movies are awesome though. There's no wrong answer.
and Shannon Elizabeth ...
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:27 pm to boomjosh
Superbad, and it’s not close. Granted, I was in high school when superbad came out, so it really spoke to my experiences a lot more than American Pie did.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:31 pm to boomjosh
Superbad by a country mile
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:33 pm to boomjosh
American Pie’s music puts it ahead of Superbad.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:38 pm to boomjosh
American Pie for me. Embraced all the innocence and purity of youth vs expectations. Also was in college when it came out.
Superbad was just some nerds trying to get laid at all costs. Also the ‘hot chick’ in the movie was a ginger OT 4 at best.
Overall, I think AP hit on a covered all types of dudes. The sensitive jock, the jock, the wanting to get laid dude, and the awkward guy. SB just focused on nerds and over the top punch lines.
Superbad was just some nerds trying to get laid at all costs. Also the ‘hot chick’ in the movie was a ginger OT 4 at best.
Overall, I think AP hit on a covered all types of dudes. The sensitive jock, the jock, the wanting to get laid dude, and the awkward guy. SB just focused on nerds and over the top punch lines.
This post was edited on 3/31/26 at 6:43 pm
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:39 pm to SonicAndBareKnuckles
quote:
American Pie’s music puts it ahead of Superbad.
On the contrary I think Superbad’s music is part of what makes it feel timeless vs American pie being extremely era specific
Love both but I think over the long haul American Pie is just the 90s Porkys and Superbad is closer to a Ferris Buehler in terms of cultural impact
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:42 pm to Lawyered
AP
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:46 pm to boomjosh
American Pie was my generation so I will go with American Pie
Superbad was great but Jonah Hill is aggravating in it.
Superbad was great but Jonah Hill is aggravating in it.
This post was edited on 3/31/26 at 6:47 pm
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:46 pm to boomjosh
Superbad.
As someone that was a senior when American Pie came out, I should pick it. But I can’t.
I laughed way more at Superbad. So Superbad for me. Every character in it was funny.
American Pie had Stifler and Jason Biggs. And the Dad was funny. But I hated that little geek that was Tara Reid’s boyfriend. He was so annoying, And Oz was pretty dull. It just wasn’t that funny to me.
As someone that was a senior when American Pie came out, I should pick it. But I can’t.
I laughed way more at Superbad. So Superbad for me. Every character in it was funny.
American Pie had Stifler and Jason Biggs. And the Dad was funny. But I hated that little geek that was Tara Reid’s boyfriend. He was so annoying, And Oz was pretty dull. It just wasn’t that funny to me.
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:48 pm to boomjosh
I’m too old to have a big attachment to either. I saw Superbad for the first time about a year ago. Thought it was pretty funny. Never saw American Pie. Worth a watch I guess?
Posted on 3/31/26 at 6:55 pm to boomjosh
Both are all time classics but I gotta go with Superbad
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News