His list will no doubt spawn some debate on this board:

1. George Washington

George Washington tops the list as the commander-in-chief of the Continental Army during the Revolutionary War. His strategic success lay in maintaining the army's cohesion over years of hardship, avoiding decisive defeats, and coordinating alliances, such as with the French at Yorktown. Tactically, he excelled in surprise attacks like the crossing of the Delaware River leading to victory at Trenton, which boosted morale and sustained the revolution.

2. Ulysses S. Grant

Grant's relentless pursuit of victory defined the Union effort in the Civil War. Strategically, he coordinated multiple armies to overwhelm the Confederacy, culminating in the surrender at Appomattox. Tactically, his innovative siege at Vicksburg split the South in two, and his Overland Campaign, despite high casualties, pinned down Lee's forces, demonstrating dogged determination and adaptability.

3. Robert E. Lee

Lee ranks highly for tactical mastery and audacious offensives despite severe resource disadvantages. Victories like the Seven Days Battles, Second Bull Run, Fredericksburg, and Chancellorsville showcased brilliant maneuvers and morale inspiration. Strategically, he prolonged the war far beyond expectations for the South, though invasions (Antietam, Gettysburg) ultimately failed.

4. Dwight D. Eisenhower

As Supreme Allied Commander in World War II, Eisenhower's strategic genius shone in orchestrating the largest amphibious invasion in history at Normandy (D-Day) and managing coalition forces across Europe. Tactically, he oversaw operations like the breakout from Normandy and the Ardennes counteroffensive, balancing resources and egos to achieve total victory over Nazi Germany.

5. George S. Patton

Patton was a master of mobile warfare in World War II, leading the Third Army's rapid advances across Europe. Strategically, he contributed to the Allied push post-Normandy, relieving Bastogne during the Battle of the Bulge. Tactically, his aggressive armored tactics, emphasizing speed and surprise, outmaneuvered German forces, earning him respect even from enemies for his bold, high-tempo operations.

6. William T. Sherman

Sherman's "March to the Sea" exemplified total war strategy in the Civil War, crippling Confederate infrastructure and morale without major battles. Strategically, he captured Atlanta, boosting Northern support for Lincoln's reelection. Tactically, his maneuvers in the Atlanta Campaign outflanked and wore down opponents, showcasing innovative logistics and psychological warfare.

7. Thomas J. "Stonewall" Jackson

Jackson's Valley Campaign distracted Union forces with lightning marches and surprise attacks, while tactical brilliance at Chancellorsville (flanking Hooker) was legendary. His early death limited broader impact, but he maximized limited resources.

8. Winfield Scott

Known for the "Anaconda Plan" that outlined the Union's Civil War strategy of blockade and division, Scott also led decisive victories in the Mexican-American War. Strategically, his plan shaped the war's course. Tactically, he captured Mexico City through amphibious assault at Veracruz and inland battles, demonstrating logistical prowess over vast distances.

9. James Longstreet

Lee's "Old War Horse" excelled defensively (Fredericksburg's sunken road) and offensively when trusted (Chickamauga breakthrough). Strategically, he advocated attrition over risky offensives, with strong tactical execution in key battles.

10. Nathanael Green

Greene's southern campaign in the Revolutionary War wore down British forces through attrition without major engagements. Strategically, he reclaimed the South by forcing Cornwallis into costly pursuits. Tactically, battles like Guilford Court House inflicted disproportionate casualties, setting the stage for Yorktown and demonstrating guerrilla-like flexibility.