Started By
Message

Seriously…your opinion on why Kelly didn’t work out.

Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:06 am
Posted by GA Tiger
Woodstock
Member since Aug 2005
3490 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:06 am
1) I think most of his previous experience was at smaller schools with exception of ND.
2) He didn’t make decisions on needed changes quickly. It was obvious to most observers he needed to at least give VB a shot. Would not do it
3) Early on, some of his transfers and recruits didn’t work out.
4) If he had not been fired, he would have probably averaged out as a 7-4 - 8-3 Coach. That doesn’t win championships.
Posted by Forever
Member since Dec 2019
6630 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:08 am to
He didn’t care enough and didn’t have the right personality to succeed here anyway, on a lot of different levels. It’s not any deeper than that
Posted by SamDonathanKnowsBall
Member since Oct 2025
4 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:11 am to
pride

Posted by TIGERVATO
Spring, TX.
Member since Jan 2008
1899 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:16 am to
Lazy
Posted by Rouge
Floston Paradise
Member since Oct 2004
138107 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:16 am to
Subpar coaching hires when he arrived

Issues with defense first 2 seasons

Losing Denbrock back to Notre Dame appears to be a big hit

Lack of recognition of OL issues

For someone with 30+ years in coaching, as he loves to espouse, Kelly did not do well in the evaluation and alignment of his coaching hires.
This post was edited on 10/28/25 at 5:18 am
Posted by BilJ
Member since Sep 2003
161516 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:17 am to
quote:

experience was at smaller schools with exception of ND.


I mean he was there for 10 years, I don’t think lack of big boy school experience was a factor

It’s just becoming clear Kelly was not all in here. I think he initially tried to adapt, hence the awkward dancing recruit videos but quickly realized he just couldn’t pull it off. Then he just became a distant CEO and that really didn’t work for anyone

Kelly was the right archetype to follow Ed but at the wrong time
This post was edited on 10/28/25 at 5:23 am
Posted by RedlandsTiger
Greenwell Springs, LA
Member since Jan 2008
3112 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:20 am to
Arrogance. He's not near as smart as he thinks he is.

He fired Blake Baker and had to hire him back and make him the highest paid defensive coordinator. He fired Tommy Moffit and we see how that worked out for TA&M.
Posted by TaderSalad
mudbug territory
Member since Jul 2014
25767 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:21 am to
BK was lazy. He wanted his staff to do all the work and have him evaluate at the end of the season.

He was hands off and no one liked him. recipe for disaster. Woody really failed on this hire. Failed miserably and not just because of the results. BK wasn't liked at ND
Posted by jacquespene8
Nashville, TN
Member since Sep 2007
4358 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:26 am to
My complete stab in the dark… His wife probably didn’t want to come to BR in the first place. He said F it and they came anyway. They’ve probably had problems that have made football a distant priority. Thus, he has been detached and probably irritable to everybody.

If wife ain’t happy, it’s hard to get things done the right way.
Posted by saint tiger225
San Diego
Member since Jan 2011
45554 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:27 am to
I think part of it is he's been slow to change or unwilling to change to the new landscape of college athletics. Some of that with NIL I think LSU was a little behind on at first with how they were going to handle NIL as we saw a couple years ago when we couldn't get DTs which led to the quote many will remember of "we're not going to buy players."

You see it all over the country with coaches like him. Mike Gundy, Dabo, Saban retiring because of it and there's more examples.

Also, it seems like he never fully realized the commitment it takes to win at a school like LSU. This isn't the type of job where you can take a few days off essentially from the start of fall camp until the end of the season. With the current state of college football, you have to grind your arse off and that's just something we never saw Kelly do.

I don't buy in to all the he was never a fit here because of his personality and all that stuff. No one cares about your personality when you're winning and competing for championships. However, when you're not competing for those then of course people are going to hone in on things like that.
This post was edited on 10/28/25 at 5:30 am
Posted by BilJ
Member since Sep 2003
161516 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:28 am to
Hot Carl had a lengthy adderal induced post on the Kelly OL problems, basically his lines at OL were stout because they were mostly upper 4-5 year players. He started out with a pretty bare cupboard here and was never able to truly stockpile depth

Some scheme issues magnified the problem no doubt but overall it was another thing in Kelly’s winning football formula that changed that he couldn’t adapt to
Posted by UncleLogger
Freetown
Member since Jan 2008
3058 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:30 am to
Character flaws exacerbated by the razor thin margin for error made it difficult to navigate his way through the adversity. Remember that all these big coaches have frick you money now. Easy to see how someone could slip into that “I don’t need this shite” mindset. It’s all over from there.
Posted by TigerLunatik
Baton Rouge, LA
Member since Jan 2005
102808 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:30 am to
I feel like he's one of those egomaniac narcissists that expects everyone to know what he wants them to do then just yells at them when they don't do it. Last weekend every time something went wrong he was yelling at everyone else about it. He seems like he's always playing the blame game and pointing his finger at everyone but himself. That's just what he allows us to see.

I had a boss like that and it made working there miserable. If he is actually like that ALL the time, I'd imagine that the players are all happy he's gone.
Posted by Rouge
Floston Paradise
Member since Oct 2004
138107 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:31 am to
quote:

basically his lines at OL were stout because they were mostly upper 4-5 year players


Fair. That being said, we had an OL loaded with upperclassmen and talent last season that flat out could not run the football (lower than 100 in team rushing).

These days, good luck with stockpiling depth. After 2-3 years in the program and not playing, those kids are gone.
This post was edited on 10/28/25 at 5:32 am
Posted by GeauxTigers0107
We Coming
Member since Oct 2009
10635 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:31 am to
Holy shite the answers in here....lol.

It's a stark reminder of just how dumb most of this board is.
Posted by I20goon
about 7mi down a dirt road
Member since Aug 2013
18764 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:32 am to
Laziness
Posted by saturncube21
Member since Nov 2015
10521 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:33 am to
Losing motivation to keep coaching in this new era
Posted by sunnydaze
Member since Jan 2010
32401 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:34 am to
Old coaches are not wining in this era of fb
Posted by BilJ
Member since Sep 2003
161516 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:40 am to
quote:


These days, good luck with stockpiling depth. After 2-3 years in the program and not playing, those kids are gone.


I’m not defending his shite OLs, I’m saying it’s another thing Kelly could not adapt to.
Posted by Relham10
Ridge
Member since Jan 2013
19625 posts
Posted on 10/28/25 at 5:43 am to
Didn't put in the work. I felt like from the beginning he tried to get by designating his coaches to do everything, recruiting, developing, relationship building and all he did was be the face of LSU football to the media and coached his coaches. Not much of a player-coach relationship. So I think his downfall was he tried to manage from a distance and not get down and dirty with his staff, the team, players and recruits on a personal level.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 5Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram