Started By
Message
locked post

What if Woodrow Wilson were never President?

Posted on 3/10/19 at 3:39 pm
Posted by OMLandshark
Member since Apr 2009
108360 posts
Posted on 3/10/19 at 3:39 pm
This is what Alternate History Hub on YouTube asks, and it completely shits all over Wilson. I did this morning think that Wilson was only our third worst President (behind Buchanan and Johnson), but he puts forth a pretty convincing argument that Wilson led the world and America to hell with his philosophy. The world would be far better if Teddy had won the election by almost any objective standard.

But for your enjoyment: LINK
Posted by Pdubntrub
Member since Jan 2018
1779 posts
Posted on 3/10/19 at 4:51 pm to
Teddy was a terrible president, he changed the meaning of the 10th amendment and started the FDA. He was a progressive and he and Wilson agreed on a lot of stuff. Teddy would have had us in WW1 in 1915. Lincoln was without question our worst President followed by Wilson.
Posted by Junky
Louisiana
Member since Oct 2005
8375 posts
Posted on 3/10/19 at 8:37 pm to
Teddy was a lot of things, but a terrible leader was not one of them. He basically dragged the Navy into the early 20th century. Secured our public lands. Got peace when the Japs were ruining the Russians in the Russo-Jap war. I don't agree with some of his views, but the dude was a real-life baller.
Posted by volod
Leesville, LA
Member since Jun 2014
5392 posts
Posted on 3/10/19 at 9:39 pm to
The Cynical Historian (one of my favorite Youtubers) did it as well. 2 part series. I even made a thread about it. The US philosophy if international intervention leads directly back to him. The precursor of the Patriot Act also leads back to him.
Posted by lsu480
Downtown Scottsdale
Member since Oct 2007
92876 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 12:33 am to
quote:

Lincoln was without question our worst President.


Only because he never implemented part 2 of his plan
Posted by awestruck
Member since Jan 2015
10940 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 5:50 am to
quote:

quote:

Lincoln was without question our worst President.


Only because he never implemented part 2 of his plan
He wasn't dumb enough to go with, "Kim Jong-un. . . great talks. . . great leader. . . great talks. . . great satisfaction. . ."
Posted by Strannix
District 11
Member since Dec 2012
48917 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 6:07 am to
quote:

He wasn't dumb enough to go with, "Kim Jong-un. . . great talks. . . great leader. . . great talks. . . great satisfaction. . ."


What would you say if Orange man imprisoned journalists and and became a military dictator?
Posted by awestruck
Member since Jan 2015
10940 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 6:31 am to
. . . it wouldn't be great !!!
Posted by Supravol22
Member since Jan 2011
14412 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 7:07 am to
quote:

Teddy would have had us in WW1 in 1915


If you actually watched the video, this was viewed as a positive considering what waiting to get involved led to...
This post was edited on 3/11/19 at 7:08 am
Posted by gthog61
Irving, TX
Member since Nov 2009
71001 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 7:17 am to
But you don't understand

Democrats and Republicans back then completely flipped parties. That racist bad guy Wilson would be a Republican today!

All those southe...on wait, he was from New Jersey?

nevermind
Posted by GeorgiaTiger678
Atlanta
Member since Jan 2019
267 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 8:27 am to
Teddy Roosevelt was the last true Nationalist to hold the title of POTUS. I yearn for someone like him to make a triumphant return to our beleaguered nation.
Posted by AggieHank86
Texas
Member since Sep 2013
42941 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 8:45 am to
quote:

quote:

Teddy would have had us in WW1 in 1915
If you actually watched the video, this was viewed as a positive considering what waiting to get involved led to...
Some interesting discussion in that presentation, but I think they reach the wrong conclusion re an earlier US entry in the Great War.

I have always thought that Germany would have gotten serious about peace negotiations, when looking at a few million new troops in the other side’s trenches, plus associated materiel. But they would have been in a position to get better terms than Versailles, which came to pass after theynwere already “on the ropes.”

From the German perspective, Versailles resulted from negotiating from a position of abject weakness. More of a “peace among equals” in 1916 or so (absent crushing reparations, loss of territory, etc) would definitely have given us a different world over the next 20-30 years, including a likelihood of no European WW2.

Almost certainly no Bolshevik rise to power, also. I think that the video gets this part mostly correct.

Even possible that we see no worldwide Depression in the late ‘20s and through the ‘30s. People tend to forget that it STARTED in Europe and arose in large part from Versailles reparations and their crippling effect on the German economy.

Some say that we still would have gotten a Pacific War with Japan, but I question that. The Pacific positions of the European powers would have been stronger, and I think Japan miay well have been less ... ambitious ... in its territorial fantasies.
This post was edited on 3/11/19 at 9:11 am
Posted by FtHuntTiger
Lafayette, LA
Member since Oct 2011
677 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 9:06 am to
Wilson was born in Virginia, and spent some of early years in Georgia and South Carolina. Didn't move to Jersey till he became President of Princeton.
Posted by AggieHank86
Texas
Member since Sep 2013
42941 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 9:10 am to
quote:

Wilson would be a Republican today! All those southe...on wait, he was from New Jersey?
Wilson was born and raised in the antebellum South.
Posted by CelticDog
Member since Apr 2015
42867 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 9:47 am to
quote:

The precursor of the Patriot Act also leads back to him.


Alien and sedition act.
John Adams
Posted by Pdubntrub
Member since Jan 2018
1779 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 9:58 am to
quote:

Teddy was a lot of things, but a terrible leader was not one of them

He was a great leader but a terrible President. He extended the powers of the presidency far beyond what the constitution allows. As a person to read about he's super interesting and badass, I like TR a lot but as a President he was not good for the country. Luckily Taft followed TR and fixed a lot of his mistakes. As for WW1, we were a different country back then and didn't search abroad for monsters to destroy. We should have never entered the great war and WW2 probably never happens.
Posted by Pdubntrub
Member since Jan 2018
1779 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 10:16 am to
quote:


If you actually watched the video, this was viewed as a positive considering what waiting to get involved led to...

I've read several books about both guys. I've watched those guys before and disagree with a lot of what they say. We had no business in WW1
Posted by AggieHank86
Texas
Member since Sep 2013
42941 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 10:21 am to
quote:

As for WW1, we ... should have never entered the great war and WW2 probably never happens.
I disagree.

If the US had stayed out of the Great War, the result would have been the same... it just would have taken a bit longer. Though both sides were depleted, the Allies simply had a manpowerr advantage that would eventually have prevailed.

If the War had lasted another year or two, Versailles would have been worse. More reparations, more territorial grabs by the Allies. Hitler (or someone like him) would still have arisen.
Posted by Pdubntrub
Member since Jan 2018
1779 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 10:29 am to
But the Germans had a superior military. They were unleashing their subs when we joined and that could've changed the war. Russia was out, France was beaten and Brittain was barely hanging on. Germany was trying to not piss off the U.S. and not sink ships with our citizens and that restricted how affective their subs were.
Posted by MizzouBS
Missouri
Member since Dec 2014
5833 posts
Posted on 3/11/19 at 12:24 pm to
One thing that hurt Wilson was Congress passed a Bill to loan England a Billion dollars for WWI. It took over 90 years for them to pay it back.

By loaning England money, the Spanish Flu(over 600,000 died), and the cost of WWI it hurt anything he wanted to accomplish. He was a president that couldn’t get anything done because there was no money.

He is considered one the worst President’s because of the progressive legislation he passed, but most the legislation was not funded until after he left office.
first pageprev pagePage 1 of 2Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram