re: Douglas Murray: 15 million Jews dying would be worse than 15 million Christians

quote:

---

Douglas Murray: 15 million Jews dying would be worse than 15 million Christians

---

quote:

---

His point is fair

There are only around 16 million Jews on earth. 15 million of them dying would be the end of the religion/culture/people.

15 million Christians dying is a rounding error. Albeit a horrific one

---

You are correct. I wouldn't be a supporter of either scenario, but 15 million Jews dying would be a substantial number.

quote:

---

Sadly, millions of “America first patriots” agree with him. They could care less as to how Christians are treated by Israelis, too

---

America First agrees with Douglas Murray?

Not the America First people I socialize with. I think the majority of America First believe Israel is an ally of the US but US interests do not always align with Israel's

America First cares about the best interest of the American people.

America First consists of people who are willing to fight for the preservation of the constitutional republic and to work towards the elimination of the enemies from within along with defending the nation against immigrants, both legal and illegal who desire to destroy what remains of the last bastion of western civilization.

quote:

---

This is what Jews think of Christians. Read the Talmud.

---

The Jews denied their Messiah's arrival because the ruling class Sanhedrin, consisting of the Pharisee and Sadducees were threatened by their loss of political power within their ruling jurisdiction as defined by Rome.

So many Christians and non Christians like to repeat the old saying of never mixing politics and religion but for those who read their Bible.....politics and religion are hand and glove.

quote:

---

You mentioned genetic or practice as an argument on perceptions of what is worse in the loss of 15 million Jew’s or 15 Christian’s. One group is substantially larger than the other but both are practices of faith. That said there are certain diseases that affect Jewish people only and for the most part and the accepted standard for Jewish is both ethnic and religious

---

Youre all over the place for me.

What is the MINIMUM thats necessary to preserve what Israel is?


If only the Arab population survives, is that adequate to say Israel is "preserved"? Or does it have to be the genetic Jews only?


Who is worth more than Christians?

quote:

---

What is a "people" exactly? Are even the Jews who have outright hostility to their own customs and traditions as valuable as the ones who do?

When you speak of Jews or even Israelis, what is the precise definition of what you refer? Are Arab Israelis as important as Jewish Israelis?

---

You go be cute on your own.

quote:

---

They hypothetical was 15 million (i.e. "all") Jews being killed.

---

Why ? So Murrary is effectively saying "ethnic Jews are more important and valuable than Christians".


It's pure Jewish supremacy.

Jewishness is 99% ethnic. Israel has some very secular areas of its country that do not practice Judaism in any sense yet we are called upon by the likes of Murray and other allies to see them as "special".

Why? What makes any Jew more special than any American ?

Lmfao your leftist and Muslim overlords thank you for joining their team

Nobody is worth more than Christian’s and that wasn’t the intention I believe he was making but rather the effect in percentages. As far as what is the minimum to maintain Israel is you moving the goalposts because Israel has about 40% Arab population. Jewish is unique as I stated before, it is both an ethnic and religion. You could technically kill the ethnic part without killing the religion which would be the definition for genocide