re: Worst US General of all time?

Tommy Franks

Ambrose Burnside. And the man was so self-deprecating he probably would agree with that sentiment.

Lee. Gets overhyped by whites in the South. Grant made his arse quit.

Custer would have to be in this conversation.
He marched his men two days and immediately joins into a divided attack. He had two thoughts on his mind Custer glory and getting a presidential nomination.
His loss rate in the civil war raises an eyebrow too.

Custer wasn't a general at Little Big Horn. He was a colonel.

And his performance in the Civil War was actually fairly solid. There's a reason why he was mustered out of the volunteer army as a major general in 1866. He didn't achieve that rank through incompetence. He clearly impressed his superior officers - those officers being Sheridan and Grant.

Custer's downfall was his arrogance and belief that the enemy he was fighting out west was inferior to him.

General Electric ... bought a front load washer from them that was a piece of shite.

General Custer.....

quote:

---

explain to me how MacArthur didn’t uselessly throw his men’s lives away due to his arrogance.

---

They all do this at some point. Picket's charge is a pretty good example. Dan Carlin comments at one point that all generals have huge egos and the more I read the more I realize that this is true. They pretty much have to. McArthur was an egotistical arse and had his failings, some of them pretty large. The Philippines weren't properly prepared for the Japanese attack even though that was anticipated as possible, his insistence on returning to the Philippines is questionable, as was the drive to the Yalu and ignoring Chinese warnings. But he was also #1 in his class at West Point and had the third highest score ever recorded. He performed very well, maybe brilliantly in WWI. Inchon was brilliant. And maybe most importantly he was responsible for transforming Japan into the society there are today and largely wrote their constitution. So while he is often unlikable and needed to be fired he is no where near the worst.

McClellan was certainly worse and cost a huge number of lives due to his hesitance and ineptitude.

I'll nominate my distant cousin, Confederate General Earl Van Dorn. A shitty general who didn't even have the decency to die on the field of battle - he was killed by the jealous husband of his side piece.