re: What should be their punishment?

Lancaster PA has Amish. But is not an amish community


Maybe 15 % is amish.

quote:

---

Not trying to be all edgy but what's the actual crime?

---

Possession and distribution of child porn. Real or fake is illegal as hell.

Lifetime social media ban.

That’s it. Law school should be mandated in this country just as much as home economics. Hardaases sitting behind computers always threatening vigilante justice as tech progresses. These boys’ parents suck. Need better families with real parents. Not baws saying “give me a minute with them” when you’d prolly get your arse kicked

quote:

---

Not trying to be all edgy but what's the actual crime?

---

The creation of child porn using face of girls who did not consent and passing it around so that other people can get off on it. Likely also made its way to older perverts. Image your 15 year old's face imposed on a nude AI body that 45 year old scum are watching.

quote:

---

The creation of child porn using face of girls who did not consent and passing it around so that other people can get off on it. Likely also made its way to older perverts. Image your 15 year old's face imposed on a nude AI body that 45 year old scum are watching.

---

I agree that this is absolutely Creepy as hell, and needs to be stopped. I am just not sure how...

for example, how closely can you approximate someone's face and say, "oh that's not that person, it just looks similar..."?

Or, this is not that THAT person, its a similar look alike... and sure, this look alike could be a 16 year old girl, but could, also, be an 18 year old girl.
She is not real. She has no verifiable age....

quote:

---

Lancaster PA has Amish. But is not an amish community

---

Lancaster Country Day is my Alma Mater. I grew up in neighboring Hershey and I can tell you that there are zero Amish kids attending that school. LCD is the closest thing to Newman in New Orleans that Central Pennsylvania has besides boarding schools. Despite being a shitty student, I got into a good private college because of the school. I ended up graduating from LSU because I was a shitty college student too.

Public lashing on bare arse, 5 per kid.

I guarantee they won't do it again after that.

quote:

---

law should penalize the creation of AI video created to mimic a realistic depiction of a living person with intent to cause them psychological or reputational harm. There should be an enhancement on it if the victim is a minor, and maybe a further enhancement if the victim is under 13. I think that would survive an 1st Amendment issues, but haven't fully researched it.

---

I would definitely support the law.

I’m no lawyer… but I think it presents challenges from a prosecution standpoint. Such as, how closely does the depiction in the video have to resemble the supposed victim? Who decides if it “looks like” that person?

For example: hypothetically, a high school kid created an adult video or image depicting a blonde person about the same age.
Some say it depicts a classmate, but person who created it says, “it’s an entirely fictitious person who is just similar to that person”.

How do you prove if it was meant to be that person? Who decides if the AI creation is close enough to say it depicts that person?

Another point- “with intent to cause psychological or reputational harm…”
It’s hard to prove a person’s intent, absent other corroborating evidence like a witness telling you, “they told me they were doing it to hurt that person”. Etc.

It’s just tough to prove. But I certainly think we have to set precedents and laws…

I’d be in support of a law that very clearly says, if using AI to create adult/nude content is a crime….
There is enough of that already out there, without AI…