re: Greatest Animated Movie of All-Time Tournament!! ROUND OF 64 ***voting closed***

quote:

---

There's no way you could have seen Fox and the Hound in the last 20 years and vote it over a top 2-3 Pixar movie, just no way.

---

Theres no way you could think ratatouille is a top 2-3 Pixar movie. Just no way.

That is definitely the most overrated Pixar film and just isn't that good in general. And I love pretty much everything they do.

quote:

---

frick YEAH!! iN THIS BITCH

---

HELL YEA SON!!

quote:

---

They're all Disney animation studios

---

They’re not under the same banner. The Goofy Movie was not held to the same standards and executives as the Lion King or Beauty and the Beast. Sure Disney owns them both, but they don’t put them under the same banner. It is apples to oranges.

You're right, those are Disneytoon

quote:

---

Ratatouille is mid tier Pixar, but it is superior to the Fox and the Hound. It’s definitely the most overrated Disney film by this board. It’s just ok.

---

This is where the while difference of opinions thing comes in.

In no way do I find Ratatouille to be Superior to the Fox and the Hound. In any way.

Ratatouille's two main characters are almost completely unlikable to me, one being a giant idiot. On the other hand, I absolutely love Tod and Copper.

And Ratatouille was so ridiculously over the top. Remy pulling ol boys hair inside his hat controlling his arm movements was just too much.

Friendship, obviously, is a big theme for both movies, and the Fox and the Hound pulls it off much better. One makes you cry, and one makes you want to punch a kid in the face, I'll take the one that makes me cry.

It has been a solid 15 years since I've seen the Fox and the Hound, and there is definitely nostalgia there, but nostalgia isn't the determining factor for me. Fox and the Hound is just a better movie.

Freaking "somewhere out there" one of the best non Disney songs in a cartoon, and its not getting out this round.


A lot of people don't dig anime. One thing I never ever understood is how come they never make them look Asian? Everyone has huge round eyes.


Akira is a masterpiece and I'll probably retry Mononoke. But it's a popularity contest. All these things are. This board at a time had Memento as the best movie ever. (First tournament I remember )

quote:

---

iwyLSUiwy

---

I want to thank you for this post. This what I’m talking about when I’m asking people to defend a film. You’ve made a hell of a good argument here. I’ve slightly rethought my argument, but I still love the end a bit more to Ratatouille where the critic gives his review. I disagree with you still, but I have a bit more of an optimistic view towards that film.

But with Princess Mononoke, no one has even tried for an argument, and it’s because they’ve never seen the movie and voted for its opposition solely because they saw it as a kid. Sorry, The Sword in the Stone is one of the less impressive Disney movies, while Princess Mononoke is one of the greatest movies ever made. I could show those two movies back to back to any poster here, and I doubt any of them would say The Sword in the Stone is better.

quote:

---

I want to thank you for this post. This what I’m talking about when I’m asking people to defend a film. You’ve made a hell of a good argument here. I’ve slightly rethought my argument, but I still love the end a bit more to Ratatouille where the critic gives his review. I disagree with you still, but I have a bit more of an optimistic view towards that film.

---

quote:

---

The Sword in the Stone is one of the less impressive Disney movies, while Princess Mononoke is one of the greatest movies ever made. I could show those two movies back to back to any poster here, and I doubt any of them would say The Sword in the Stone is better.

---

Dang,i didnt realize it's one of your favorite movies of all time. Man just for your sake and wanting you to keep going on with the tournament and not thinking its BS, I want to change my vote.

But with that vote in particular, it was solely based on which was more memorable for me.

quote:

---

Dang,i didnt realize it's one of your favorite movies of all time.

---

I think I put it as #4 a few years back in MWADS. It may be slightly lower than that now, but still in the top 10.

But thanks man

ANTARCTIC FROZEN NUTS REGION

1) [img]Incredibles[/img]
16) Brave

8) Shrek
9) Heavy Metal

5) Robin Hood
12) Fantastic Mr. Fox

4) Akira
13) Tangled


6) Moana
11) How the Grinch Stole Christmas

3) Toy Story 3
14) An American Tale

7) Fantasia
10) Coraline

2) Kubo and the Two Strings
15) Grave of Fireflies




GHETTO AFRICAN JUNGLE REGION

1) Beauty and the Beast
16) Hercules

8) Watership Down
9) [img]Mulan[/img]

5) The Iron Giant
12) The Hunchback of Notre Dame

4) Finding Nemo
13) Emperors New Groove


6) Ratatouille
11) The Fox and the Hound

3) [img]Toy Story 2 [/img]
14) Isle of Dogs

7) Cinderella
10) The Lego Movie

2) Inside Out
15) Rudolph the Red Nose Reindeer




AUSTRALIAN FOSTERS BEER REGION

1) Lion King
16) Transformers

8) Wreck-It-Ralph
9) Batman: The Mask of Phantasm

5) [img]The Jungle Book [/img]
12) Snow White

4) [img]Aladdin[/img]
13) South Park: BLU


6) Sleeping Beauty
11) Big Hero 6

3) Coco
14) Charlotte’s Webb

7) 9
10) [img]The Secret of Nihm[/img]

2) Nightmare Before Christmas
15) Lady and the Tramp





ASIAN GENERAL TSO'S CHICKEN REGION

1) Toy Story
16) Little Mermaid

8) Ghost in the Shell
9) Despicable Me

5) Spirited Away
12) [img]The Brave Little Toaster[/img]

4) [img]Monsters Inc.[/img]
13) Monsters University


6) Princess Mononoke
11) The Sword in the Stone

3) WALL-E
14) Rango

7) [img]The Land Before Time[/img]
10) Pinocchio

2) Up
15) Yellow Submarine