TD.com QB Value & Tier Thread- Who goes up or down?

Let's set it up. Started from the Parcell's thread and with an assist from the Bill Simmons Trade Value Column. At the end of the rankings, we'll try to separate them into tiers.

Basic idea is trying to see who the most valued quarterback in the NFL.

quote:

---

Rules:

1. Age matters a little bit. Can you still gear your team and franchise around this quarterback or are you having to plan season to season?

2. Pretend the league passed the following rule: For 24 hours, any player can be traded without cap ramifications but with luxury-tax ramifications. So if Team A tells Team B, "We'll trade you Player X for Player Y," would Team B make the deal?

3. Concentrate on degrees. Neither New England nor New Orleans would make a Brady-Brees trade, but the Patriots would at least say, "Wow, Drew Brees is available?" and have a meeting about it while the Saints would say, "There's no frickin' way we're trading Drew Brees." That counts in the big scheme of things.

---

LSU MNC Has given us a starting point Starting Point.

"LET'S MAKE A DEAL"

32. Jamarcus Russell
31. Jake Delhomme
30. A. J. Feely
29. Trent Edwards
28. Matt Moore
27. Josh Freeman
26. Alex Smith

"We're Open to Discussing It"
25. Matt Lienart
24. Matt Hasselback
23. Kyle Orton

"Just Know, He's Worth More To Us Than To You"
22. Matthew Stafford
21. David Garrard
20. Vince Young
19. Chad Henne
18. Kevin Kolb
17. Donnovan McNabb
16. Matt Cassell
15. Carson Palmer

"Effectively Untouchable"
14. Mark Sanchez
13. Joe Flacco
12. Matt Ryan
11. Jay Cutler
10. Eli Manning

"It Makes Us Angry That You'd Even Ask"
9. Tony Romo
8. Matt Schaub

"Lemme Save You Some Time: N-O"
7. Brett Favre
6. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Phillip Rivers
4.Aaron Rodgers

"Completely And Utterly Untouchable"
3. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
1. Drew Brees
---
What y'all think?

I think Schaub's way too high.