Eli, Big Ben and P Rivers

Big Ben

Is this a hard question? Ben is tied for most Superbowls and more appearances. Also more consistent career. How is this even a question?

Rivers doesn't belong in the question

i know it doesn't matter cause the Steelers beat the Seahawks when Big Ben got his first ring but he struggled big time that game.

had a much better game against the Cardinals the second time around and delivered late in the game.

third time around was outdone by Aaron Rodgers who was on fire that year in the playoffs.

Big Ben led pittsburgh to a few more AFC Championship appearances too.

And he's missed more games due to injury than both eli and Rivers. Eli has been real durable despite his spotty play.

Rivers is the better player. Won't get the credit cause he doesn't have the hardware.

Anybody that actually knows the game will tell you Rivers and it's not close.

Big ben
Manning
Rivers

Winning superbowls means something.

quote:

---

Winning superbowls means something.

---

Yeah, it means you were on a really good team.

quote:

---

Winning superbowls means something.

---

quote:

---

Without looking at the numbers I would guess Rivers.

---

if we're going by career, I think that takes out Rivers as that includes accomplishments.

Now who has been the best out of the three, that's a different discussion.

Side by side stats. 83.9 passer rating. Yikes

Just for the record, Ben still producing at a high level, as is Rivers. Eli, on the other hand, is on the bench.