Started By
Message

re: Who’s on your Mt. Rushmore of LSU football?

Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:20 pm to
Posted by tigger1
Member since Mar 2005
3476 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:20 pm to
quote:

The 4 most decorated players in LSU history are:


That is the problem, the farer you go back in college football history the less awards there are to the point there are none.

Also All American is subjective to votes of region and who and how many players one could see in a season, the farer you go back on All American teams the less likely the list is good.

I know Camp only saw about 20 games max a year on his All American teams and most of those games he saw were in the northeastern area.

Coaches All American team votes were commonly filled out by assistant coaches, trainers and sometime team managers back in the day.

Johnny Robinson can not get into the college football Hall of Fame, this is due in part because he was never an All American and in those days it is normally the top rushers, touchdown leaders who made All American.

Johnny is as good as any back you can name.

Doc Fenton would be an all world player had TV been around in his day.

Tinsley is an end and he was light years ahead of his time for that position.

Steve Van Buren is not an All American but as the Miami paper said after the Orange Bowl, forget everything you heard or read, Steve Van Buren is the best college football player in American. Had Steve played at Notre Dame, Michigan, Army, Ohio State, he would have been an All American.

Old south football did not get the awards that should have been given due to lack of press.
This post was edited on 1/16/21 at 10:24 pm
Posted by Rudy40
Baton Rouge,La
Member since Jan 2007
2781 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:29 pm to
Burrow
Cannon
Casanova
Michael Brooks
Posted by Tiger1988
Houston
Member since May 2016
24228 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:29 pm to
I go WAY back. Stovall (6’2”-200 bs) was more recognized than Dorsey if you think about winning the Walter Camp and runner up for Heisman. HE WAS ROBBED of the Heisman. You have no idea how great he was. In fact, I believe he was a better overall player than

With that, Johnny Robinson was also a GREAT player. Had it not been for Cannon, he might have gotten the recognition he deserved, plus he won the SEC in Tennis.
This post was edited on 1/16/21 at 11:32 pm
Posted by lesgeaux
Member since Jul 2008
3362 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:37 pm to
Ryan O’Neal
Josh Booty
John Corbello
Demetrius Hookfin



But seriously, where the hell is Rohan Davey?

Burrow
Cannon
Faulk
Dorsey
Posted by cj35
Member since Jan 2014
6153 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:47 pm to
Casanova
Cannon
Burrow
Mathieu
Posted by KC Tiger
Member since Sep 2006
4617 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 10:57 pm to
Any list that doesn't include Casanova and Y.A. Tittle is not a serious list. Furthermore, any list that doesn't include the Heisman winners is not a complete list; therefore, the correct list for LSU's Mt. Rushmore is:

Y.A. Tittle
Billy Cannon
Tommy Casanova
Joe Burrow
Posted by lsuhunt555
Teakwood Village Breh
Member since Nov 2008
38405 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 11:21 pm to
Burrow
K Faulk
Cannon
Hester
Posted by JollyGreen
Las Vegas
Member since Dec 2007
156 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 11:22 pm to
Cannon
Burrow
Faulk
Alexander
Posted by Tiger1988
Houston
Member since May 2016
24228 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 11:33 pm to
quote:

Y.A. Tittle
Billy Cannon
Tommy Casanova
Joe Burrow


Sub Tittle for Stovall a s you’re golden. With that Johnny Robinson could be on there from 1958’s team.
Posted by Lsutigerturner
Member since Dec 2016
5736 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 11:34 pm to
Cannon
Burrow
Mathieu

That's all

Maybe dorsey as number four but I hear the old timers talking about casanova he would prob be number 4 maybe.
Posted by RileyTime
Gulf Breeze, FL
Member since Oct 2008
6928 posts
Posted on 1/16/21 at 11:57 pm to
Burrow
Cannon
Faulk
Casanova
Posted by TheSearch
Mediocrity, LA
Member since Jan 2018
399 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 12:43 am to
To be fair to OP,

It might be a generational thing, but I always thought Glenn Dorsey was one of the most dominant college players ever.

Obviously it didn't play out for him on Sundays.

but I would have had him as close to the top for all-time tigers before Joey B.
Posted by LSUPHILLY72
Member since Aug 2010
5356 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 2:03 am to
quote:

Faulk holds the SEC record for the most all purpose yards...



Fault was not good enough to sit out his Bowl game his Junior year
Posted by HighlandRD_ZERO25
Member since Jun 2016
622 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 2:45 am to
The top four:

Joe Burrow
Tyrann Matheiu
Glenn Dorsey
Billy Cannon


The most elite and talented players are as follows


1. Patrick Peterson
2. Leonard Fournette
3. Odell Beckham
4. Jamal Adams

Fournette has rushing records that will never be touched with today's offenses. And he did it against 8 man fronts play after play. Would've had 2000 if the game early that year wasn't cancelled. Bama game stung and the 3 losses at the end stole that Heisman from him. But that didn't change just how dominant he was from day one on campus. He honestly is the best player I've ever gotten to see play live. Was a pro going against middle schoolers that season it looked like. Would just run over feared tacklers from the start.
Posted by bkline19
Member since Aug 2014
42 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 3:06 am to
Burrow, OBJ, Glen Dorsey and Mathieu were so much fun it was absurd. It’s unreal the pro Mathieu has become. Don’t be a lame and think otherwise. OBJ can hand me cash any day. How awesome would this mountain look?? And for all you old white folks; imagine Billy Cannon shooting the laser to carve out their faces. That is pretty bad arse.
Posted by Liltiga
Member since Oct 2020
28 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 3:11 am to
I'm going Burrow, Cannon, Dorsey, Patrick Peterson.
Posted by TampaTiger
Red Stick
Member since Jan 2004
1130 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 4:16 am to
Burrow
Casanova
Cannon
Tittle

Honorable Mention:
Mathieu
Faulk
Van Buren
Posted by VeryReauxna_ish
Bossier City
Member since Dec 2020
1956 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 5:07 am to
Jamarr Chase
Terrace Marshall Jr
Kary Vincent
Arik Gilbert
Posted by TexasTiger89
Houston, TX
Member since Feb 2005
24246 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 5:27 am to
My Rushmore would be 30 guys or more. Lot a great dudes in this program.
Posted by munchman
Baton Rouge
Member since Feb 2006
10321 posts
Posted on 1/17/21 at 6:21 am to
quote:

Burrow
Cannon
Dorsey
Devin White or Kevin Faulk


Looks about right.
first pageprev pagePage 4 of 8Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookTwitterInstagram