- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Stafford vs Rodgers all time
Posted on 11/23/25 at 7:42 pm
Posted on 11/23/25 at 7:42 pm
Both 1 ring with stafford capable of getting a 2nd. Aaron played for the storied Green Bay packers while Stafford played for the lowly Lions and then the rams at the backend of his career. I say from start to finish Stafford gets the slight nod.
8
Posted on 11/23/25 at 7:45 pm to JamalMurry27
The fact that you could even ask this question is testament of the rapid downfall of Rodgers. Rodgers was supposed to break every NFL passing record and now he is sort of a bum.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 7:45 pm to JamalMurry27
Who was the best receiver Rodgers ever had? Adams? Jordy Nelson?
Rodgers never exactly had a great stable of receivers or backs.
Rodgers never exactly had a great stable of receivers or backs.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 7:57 pm to JamalMurry27
quote:
storied Green Bay packers
The Packers roster as a whole was largely dog shite for Rodgers entire career. He always had a talented receiver but that was about it.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 8:00 pm to Tangineck
quote:
The Packers roster as a whole was largely dog shite for Rodgers entire career. He always had a talented receiver but that was about it.
He had great production out of his wr corps but the defense was always their downfall in the playoffs. They used their 1st rd picks on defense nearly every year but they typically picked late.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 8:21 pm to grizzlylongcut
quote:
Who was the best receiver Rodgers ever had? Adams?
Old man Stafford currently has an ancient Adams and 5th round Puka, but is playing at an MVP caliber level.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 9:14 pm to bad93ex
quote:
Rodgers was supposed to break every NFL passing record and now he is sort of a bum.
Rodgers didn't start his first game until he was 25 because he had to back up Favre for three seasons and then he missed half of two seasons with injuries. Nobody expected him to catch Manning and Brady.
Stafford is having a crazy good year though. I think most people assumed he would be retired by now and might win the MVP.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 9:26 pm to JamalMurry27
2 years ago I would of laughed at this but it’s a discussion
Posted on 11/23/25 at 10:30 pm to Ghost of Colby
quote:
Old man Stafford currently has an ancient Adams and 5th round Puka, but is playing at an MVP caliber level.
I think it’d do well to also consider who they’re playing for.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 10:35 pm to JamalMurry27
I think Stafford is a hall of famer. Rodgers is an all time great.
Rodgers - 4 All Pros
Stafford - none
Rodgers - 10 Pro Bowls
Stafford - 2
Rodgers - 4 League MVPs
Stafford - none
Stafford spent over a decade with a horrible team and was largely invisible but not by his opponents. They knew how good he was/is.
But Rodgers has been relevant since his first start and has the individual hardware to make a legitimate claim for top 7 all time.
Rodgers - 4 All Pros
Stafford - none
Rodgers - 10 Pro Bowls
Stafford - 2
Rodgers - 4 League MVPs
Stafford - none
Stafford spent over a decade with a horrible team and was largely invisible but not by his opponents. They knew how good he was/is.
But Rodgers has been relevant since his first start and has the individual hardware to make a legitimate claim for top 7 all time.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 10:42 pm to ATCTx
quote:
Stafford spent over a decade with a horrible team and was largely invisible but not by his opponents. They knew how good he was/is.
Was he the last QB taken before the restructuring of the rookie deals?
Posted on 11/23/25 at 10:44 pm to JamalMurry27
This isn’t a real discussion.
Rodgers still has the second highest Passer rating of all-time, the lowest int% of all-time, has 4 MVPs, has 4 first team APs and a second team All-Pro, and is in the top 5 all time in Passing Yards and Passing Touchdowns.
Stafford is a slam dunk HOF QB. Rodgers has a chair at the table of discussion of greatest QB of all time with Manning, Montana, and Marino (and eventually Mahomes).
Rodgers still has the second highest Passer rating of all-time, the lowest int% of all-time, has 4 MVPs, has 4 first team APs and a second team All-Pro, and is in the top 5 all time in Passing Yards and Passing Touchdowns.
Stafford is a slam dunk HOF QB. Rodgers has a chair at the table of discussion of greatest QB of all time with Manning, Montana, and Marino (and eventually Mahomes).
Posted on 11/23/25 at 10:56 pm to bad93ex
Bradford I think but not 100% sure
This post was edited on 11/23/25 at 10:58 pm
Posted on 11/23/25 at 11:00 pm to Madking
quote:
Bradford I think but not 100% sure
Those deals hamstrung the hell out of the teams with the 1st overall pick
Posted on 11/23/25 at 11:02 pm to bad93ex
Yea, it’s much better now. They still reach on a lot of QBs but there’s a lot more instances where guys can struggle early, move around and resuscitate their careers now.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 11:16 pm to bad93ex
quote:and he made sure to always remind everyone
but the defense was always their downfall in the playoffs.
Posted on 11/23/25 at 11:19 pm to SuperSaint
quote:
but the defense was always their downfall in the playoffs.
quote:
and he made sure to always remind everyone
The loss to the Brady-led Bucs was on him though and I believe the signal to the Packers organization that Rodgers was no longer that guy
Posted on 11/23/25 at 11:38 pm to TheePalmetto
quote:Based on what? 2 Pro Bowls? #9 in career passing yards is impressive but how much of that was a function of those Lions teams constantly playing from behind? How much of that goes away throwing to a generic WR1 instead of the beginning of his career overlapping with the prime of the best receiver of his generation?
Stafford is a slam dunk HOF QB
It's an easy argument that he wasn't even Top 3-5 at his position in his 2 best seasons (2011 and 2021). He was reliably a Top 10-15 QB but he was never elite. Certainly not elite over a sustained enough period of time to deserve consideration
This post was edited on 11/23/25 at 11:49 pm
Posted on 11/24/25 at 12:10 am to bad93ex
quote:
but the defense was always their downfall in the playoffs
Remember when the Packers D in the Playoffs were busy tailoring CK's Gold jacket?
Hard to win Playoff games when your D gives up 45 points in the Divisional round and they gave up 37 points the year before in the Divisional round as the #1 seed.
These were prime Rodgers years after the Super Bowl win and the Packers mucked it up.
This post was edited on 11/24/25 at 12:11 am
Posted on 11/24/25 at 1:06 am to grizzlylongcut
quote:from his 1st start he had arguably the best WR group in the league.(Jennings Driver etc) Adams is a borderline HOFer. Cobb was a top 5 slot. Graham was still solid. Jones was a top 10ish back for nearly decade
Who was the best receiver Rodgers ever had? Adams? Jordy Nelson?
Rodgers never exactly had a great stable of receivers or backs.
Page 1 of 2
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News