- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- SEC Score Board
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Atomic bombs or fire bombs on Japan
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:17 am
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:17 am
14
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:18 am to Auburn1968
The were both unfortunate consequences to Japan's war of conquest in the preceding years going back to the late 30s in China.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:20 am to Auburn1968
Same thing
Atomic bombs were dropped on cities made of wood and paper. Talk about fueling a fire, the cities were built for it. In Europe you see bricks / masonry still standing but in Japan it is just ash.
Atomic bombs were dropped on cities made of wood and paper. Talk about fueling a fire, the cities were built for it. In Europe you see bricks / masonry still standing but in Japan it is just ash.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:20 am to Auburn1968
The japs of that era were pure barbaric savages. We did what we needed to.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:21 am to Auburn1968
consequences of Japan's horrific actions going back to the '20's.
they were savages and had to be put down.
they were savages and had to be put down.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:24 am to Auburn1968
Atomic bombs were dropped on Japan only as a show of force to prove had them to Stalin and for us to actually see what they would do in real time use, not as a strategic weapon against the Japanese.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:29 am to CBandits82
quote:
they were savages and had to be put down.
Yes and No
Did not help you had a culture where the leader was a God, caught up with Egypt with the Pharaoh till Moses and those pesky slaves took a powder with the help of the God above.
Did not help that Germany and Japan had no oil in an industrialized era was switching from coal to oil. Churchill knew oil navies went faster than coal navies. Europe had Middle East concession (through BP and such) and Merica had Standard Oil.
The issue was less the Emperor and that war group that was the real power behind the throne. Without them Japan may never have gone to war.
NO = Emperor
YES = Generals
NO = People
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:30 am to Snipe
quote:
Atomic bombs were dropped on Japan only as a show of force to prove had them to Stalin and for us to actually see what they would do in real time use, not as a strategic weapon against the Japanese
This is almost 100% spot on. You forgot about Truman's bloodlust.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:30 am to Auburn1968
The descriptions from the fire bombing in "Supernova in the East" are horrific.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 10:33 am to JackieTreehorn
quote:
The japs of that era were pure barbaric savages. We did what we needed to.
^this^
Not only what they did to the Chinese, but to American POWs...
Frick em...
This post was edited on 6/23/25 at 10:35 am
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:01 pm to Cheese Grits
quote:
Cheese Grits
quote:
Same thing
Most definitely not the same thing. Firebombing with incendiaries was much more devastating and deadly.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:05 pm to GEAUXT
quote:I can only imagine the terror of those firestorms.
The descriptions from the fire bombing in "Supernova in the East" are horrific.
Hard lesson to those in wooden houses not to ambush a juggernaut with a formidable Navy, long-range bombers, and incendiaries.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:19 pm to Snipe
quote:
Atomic bombs were dropped on Japan only as a show of force to prove had them to Stalin and for us to actually see what they would do in real time use, not as a strategic weapon against the Japanese.
True. If LeMay's firebombing did not bring them to the table, nothing else was going to other than a - for the time - history changing event.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:21 pm to Sayre
quote:
Most definitely not the same thing. Firebombing with incendiaries was much more devastating and deadly.
You may be arguing quantity instead of quantity
1 Atomic Bomb dropped on a city made of paper and wood.
VS
???? Fire Bomb(s) dropped on a city made of paper and wood.
Unlike firebombs, atomic bombs (radiation) probably kills more humans and more slowly over time. Fire is quick, radiation is not. You rebuild quickly on fire earth, not so fast on radiated earth.
Your thoughts on this point?
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:25 pm to Auburn1968
Dresden.... worst firebombing of all time. WW2.
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:26 pm to Cheese Grits
There were also considerations due to atom bomb placement, at least in Nagasaki. Direct blast area was about 40% smaller than Hiroshima, I think because the bomb drifted towards the mountains a bit more than expected.
But, firebombing "direct" impact area was approx 16 square miles in Tokyo, versus 5 miles for Hiroshima, 3 for Nagasaki. That's what one bomber versus a lot tends to do.
But, firebombing "direct" impact area was approx 16 square miles in Tokyo, versus 5 miles for Hiroshima, 3 for Nagasaki. That's what one bomber versus a lot tends to do.
This post was edited on 6/23/25 at 12:27 pm
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:27 pm to GEAUXT
quote:
The descriptions from the fire bombing in "Supernova in the East" are horrific.
So is the rape of nanjing
frick the japs
Posted on 6/23/25 at 12:34 pm to Tridentds
quote:Nope. Dresden bombing ~ 25k deaths
Dresden.... worst firebombing of all time. WW2.
Operation Meetinghouse in Tokyo (March 9/10, 1945) ~ 100k deaths
Posted on 6/23/25 at 2:07 pm to Cosmo
quote:
frick the japs
OK
Posted on 6/23/25 at 2:10 pm to JackieTreehorn
I dont think I've ever seen a country change its ways as much as Japan. Those old imperial Japanese would cut heads off with Samurai swords and committed all kinds of atrocities.
Now Japan is a close ally and maybe the most civilized country.
Now Japan is a close ally and maybe the most civilized country.
Page 1 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News