- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Medicare Supplements
Posted on 8/29/24 at 7:38 pm
Posted on 8/29/24 at 7:38 pm
Should I hire someone to help me choose? I am not sure about all these folks trying to sell me policies/plans. I am about 8 months out. Thanks,
Posted on 8/29/24 at 7:42 pm to Texas ellessu
Most people get a plan that covers everything except the Part B deductible. Mutual of Omaha is a fairly popular one, but the same plan (Plan G, Plan N, etc) is pretty much the same for each company. You don't have to worry about network as the supplement just picks up where Medicare leaves off.
Posted on 8/29/24 at 7:59 pm to Texas ellessu
Yes.
End up getting AARP.
End up getting AARP.
Posted on 8/29/24 at 8:25 pm to Texas ellessu
Cardinal Advisors has good informational videos on this as a starting point.
Medicare and Social Security explanations
Medicare and Social Security explanations
Posted on 8/29/24 at 9:16 pm to agilitydawg
I start Medicare Sept.1. I'm still working so I'm using my co. insurance of parts B and D.
Posted on 8/29/24 at 10:29 pm to Texas ellessu
quote:
Should I hire someone to help me choose?
Seriously? All Suppliments are the same. The difference is some companies have higher premiums than others. My mother has Mutual of Omaha and it has been phenomenal.
Do not forget to get a Part D prescription drug plan.
I will post a site tomorrow that can help you decide.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 6:14 am to La Place Mike
In place of parts B and D I meant to say.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 6:16 am to La Place Mike
Thank you all. This helps.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 7:01 am to Texas ellessu
If you feel like you need help, talk to a SHIP counselor. It's free and they aren't trying to sell you anything.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 8:27 am to Texas ellessu
Great that you're seeking advice to try to understand the various coverage options. Particularly helpful to hear from those that actually went through the process themselves or for their loved ones.
I'm going to elaborate on the process further and share my experiences. I work for one of the major carriers that offer Supplement and Medicare Advantage Plans. I also had to go through this process for my wife and myself, so I understand this can be a very confusing and complicated process.
Regarding using an agent or not, here's why you would because they all aren't created equal.
Article On Why
Agents are knowledgeable about the various Medicare plans available and can help you navigate the complexities of Medicare supplements. They can explain the differences between plans and help you understand which options best meet your needs.
There are SO many options and permutations of coverage options. Do you want to find out what's best for you on your own? Maybe you could, but I worked with one I knew that sold our programs and has a great track record helping her clients and friends I knew who raved about her knowledge and helpfulness. And I'm "in the business"' so to speak.
If you can find one with a great track record, comes recommended by friends or associates that have used them, it makes the decision process SO much easier.
AND..maybe more importantly, carriers create new plans, modify existing plans all the time, and you generally aren't ever going to hear about that. Agents do. It can (and did in our case) save you money and you should always review your coverage annually to see if you have the best combination of coverage and costs.
Regarding coverage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans work alongside your Original Medicare plan to help fill coverage gaps, such as deductibles. Because it is used with your federal Medicare coverage, it is also accepted at hospital that accepts Original Medicare.
Your first decision point is between an Advantage Plan or a Medicare Supplement.
Forbes Article On Differences
Generally, Advantage Plans are cheaper and offer certain supplemental benefits. The downside is the network is more restrictive, so it would depend on your location, who you use etc.
Network access (ability to see the providers you want) was important to us. We personally went with the AARP Medicare Supplement and Aetna's Silver Script Prescription Drug Plan (For Medicare Part D, plans that cover prescription drugs) based upon the price and the drugs we use. Our agent helped us weigh the pros and cons of each and that's what we came up with and am very happy with both.
Forbes Article On Supplement Plans
All in all, we are very happy with our coverage and it was MUCH cheaper than the group coverage I could still get.
Good luck!

I'm going to elaborate on the process further and share my experiences. I work for one of the major carriers that offer Supplement and Medicare Advantage Plans. I also had to go through this process for my wife and myself, so I understand this can be a very confusing and complicated process.
Regarding using an agent or not, here's why you would because they all aren't created equal.
Article On Why
Agents are knowledgeable about the various Medicare plans available and can help you navigate the complexities of Medicare supplements. They can explain the differences between plans and help you understand which options best meet your needs.
There are SO many options and permutations of coverage options. Do you want to find out what's best for you on your own? Maybe you could, but I worked with one I knew that sold our programs and has a great track record helping her clients and friends I knew who raved about her knowledge and helpfulness. And I'm "in the business"' so to speak.
If you can find one with a great track record, comes recommended by friends or associates that have used them, it makes the decision process SO much easier.
AND..maybe more importantly, carriers create new plans, modify existing plans all the time, and you generally aren't ever going to hear about that. Agents do. It can (and did in our case) save you money and you should always review your coverage annually to see if you have the best combination of coverage and costs.
Regarding coverage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans work alongside your Original Medicare plan to help fill coverage gaps, such as deductibles. Because it is used with your federal Medicare coverage, it is also accepted at hospital that accepts Original Medicare.
Your first decision point is between an Advantage Plan or a Medicare Supplement.
Forbes Article On Differences
Generally, Advantage Plans are cheaper and offer certain supplemental benefits. The downside is the network is more restrictive, so it would depend on your location, who you use etc.
Network access (ability to see the providers you want) was important to us. We personally went with the AARP Medicare Supplement and Aetna's Silver Script Prescription Drug Plan (For Medicare Part D, plans that cover prescription drugs) based upon the price and the drugs we use. Our agent helped us weigh the pros and cons of each and that's what we came up with and am very happy with both.
Forbes Article On Supplement Plans
All in all, we are very happy with our coverage and it was MUCH cheaper than the group coverage I could still get.
Good luck!

This post was edited on 8/30/24 at 8:30 am
Posted on 8/30/24 at 9:00 am to Nole Man
Ask your doctor what advantage plan he would want for his coverage.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 9:04 am to OlGrandad
quote:
Ask your doctor what advantage plan he would want for his coverage.
Good point. And a bigger question is "do you take Medicare"?
Real issue is with Primary Care Physicians (PCP) taking Medicare due to the reimbursement levels, particularly for new patients. We had to switch from our long-standing Internist (she went concierge medicine) and had a hell of a time finding a new PCP.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 10:10 am to Texas ellessu
Went through this with my mom a couple years ago. If you can afford it, Plan G or N (depends on price diff in your area) are probably the best options.
My mom was on Plan F for many years but premiums kept going up as the amount of people in it were decreasing as they stopped allowing new enrollments. We switched her to Plan G.
Here is a chart comparing different medigap plans:
https://www.medicare.gov/health-drug-plans/medigap/basics/compare-plan-benefits
Also I 've seen this site mentioned on Bogleheads several times. While we didn't use them, they are legit and doesn't affect your cost. They get paid by whatever company you go with:
https://boomerbenefits.com/
My mom was on Plan F for many years but premiums kept going up as the amount of people in it were decreasing as they stopped allowing new enrollments. We switched her to Plan G.
Here is a chart comparing different medigap plans:
https://www.medicare.gov/health-drug-plans/medigap/basics/compare-plan-benefits
Also I 've seen this site mentioned on Bogleheads several times. While we didn't use them, they are legit and doesn't affect your cost. They get paid by whatever company you go with:
https://boomerbenefits.com/
Posted on 8/30/24 at 10:41 am to gpburdell
What's the total monthly cost? My wife will go on Medicare in January.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 11:27 am to VABuckeye
Usually about $300-$350 (yes seriously) per month including Part B.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 11:34 am to Nole Man
My wife and I have also been through the Medicare maze. Great post by Nole Man. I can't over emphasize this point:
New insurers come in, others leave and most prices change every year. A company that might cover you in one part of a state like Texas might not in another part.
My wife and I have an agent that has a data base of all the plans offered in our area. Every year she asks us to update her with a list of all prescriptions and a list of our doctors. Once the enrollment period begins, I think in October, she emails us options. We can meet with her in person or simply reply to her emails.
We started our learning process by going to small group meetings that agents would hold for people that were soon eligible for Medicare. Each put on a presentation and handed out some literature. Try to find a few of those in your area. It was a great way to start the process.
quote:
AND..maybe more importantly, carriers create new plans, modify existing plans all the time, and you generally aren't ever going to hear about that. Agents do. It can (and did in our case) save you money and you should always review your coverage annually to see if you have the best combination of coverage and costs.
New insurers come in, others leave and most prices change every year. A company that might cover you in one part of a state like Texas might not in another part.
My wife and I have an agent that has a data base of all the plans offered in our area. Every year she asks us to update her with a list of all prescriptions and a list of our doctors. Once the enrollment period begins, I think in October, she emails us options. We can meet with her in person or simply reply to her emails.
We started our learning process by going to small group meetings that agents would hold for people that were soon eligible for Medicare. Each put on a presentation and handed out some literature. Try to find a few of those in your area. It was a great way to start the process.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 12:34 pm to Texas ellessu
Whatever you do stay away from Advantage plans. They limit your ability to get care when you need it. They limit who you can see and what type of care you get.
From a rehab stand point, good luck finding someone who will take them in the next couple of years. Reimbursement rates are ridiculously low so no PT clinics are wanting to deal with them. They also extremely limit your visits.
They’ll lure you in with “discounts and perks” or whatever, but make no mistake about it, they do not give you an advantage over traditional Medicare with a Part B for comprehensive healthcare.
From a rehab stand point, good luck finding someone who will take them in the next couple of years. Reimbursement rates are ridiculously low so no PT clinics are wanting to deal with them. They also extremely limit your visits.
They’ll lure you in with “discounts and perks” or whatever, but make no mistake about it, they do not give you an advantage over traditional Medicare with a Part B for comprehensive healthcare.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 2:01 pm to Nole Man
Nole Man; do you agree with this viewpoint?
Our premiums are $0/ month. Nonetheless, I’ve been thinking about changing to a supplement plan while we are healthy enough to get one. If that is even possible; not sure what the process is to switch from an Advantage to a Supplement plan.
I agree that Advantage plans do limit you to in network providers but we haven’t had any issues with getting the care we need. But we haven’t needed a lot.
quote:I’ve been on Medicare for 10 years and have had a BCBS NC Advantage plan that entire time. As has my wife. We are both relatively healthy; but of course that could change suddenly.
Whatever you do stay away from Advantage plans. They limit your ability to get care when you need it. They limit who you can see and what type of care you get.
Our premiums are $0/ month. Nonetheless, I’ve been thinking about changing to a supplement plan while we are healthy enough to get one. If that is even possible; not sure what the process is to switch from an Advantage to a Supplement plan.
I agree that Advantage plans do limit you to in network providers but we haven’t had any issues with getting the care we need. But we haven’t needed a lot.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 2:15 pm to nctiger71
quote:
Nole Man; do you agree with this viewpoint?
Whatever you do stay away from Advantage plans. They limit your ability to get care when you need it. They limit who you can see and what type of care you get.
Pros and Cons
Pros and Cons 2
Well, we didn't, so I guess the answer would be yes!

BUT..
Medicare Advantage plans offer several benefits that some consider important and they have their place. It's like the difference between the traditional HMO programs of years ago vs. PPOs. Do you want higher benefits, lower costs, but are willing to live with a restricted network of providers? In some cases, some people are just fine with that. See California and the Pacific Northwest with systems like Kaiser, Providence, Sutter. Maybe you're ok with that and maybe you don't worry about out of network or travel issues.
My experience is they don't sell as well in the South where open access has always been more important to consumers than other parts of the country.
Posted on 8/30/24 at 3:43 pm to Nole Man
I went to the Largest hospital system in our city and asked them which companies plans were most accepted by them and acted accordingly.
Popular
Back to top
