Do you respect artists who don’t write their own songs?

First off, they aren’t artists, they’re performers.

typically no.
I’ve always been predisposed to singer/band/songwriters. Very few exceptions (Elvis, Johnny Cash, Linda Ronstadt, etc)

Elvis didn't write songs

Well, you're a fool

quote:

---

Was Frank Sinatra not an artist?

---

You can blur the lines like this, sure, but an artist doesn't need other people to create art, and Sinatra needed songwriters and composers.

quote:

---

First off, they aren’t artists, they’re performers.

---

Note that this idea did not exist in popular music before Bob Dylan

Good question. Never really thought about it to be honest. To me it doesn’t matter. A good song is a good song. Who wrote it never enters my mind. I will even listen to songs by bands or artist dealing with politics or religion that I strongly disagree with if the music is good enough. A cool song is a cool song that’s just how I have always rolled when it comes to music.

When you really think about it this question you asked reminds me of PED’s in baseball. Sure players get an advantage by taking them but in order for those PED’s to matter in the least a player must be a superstar in the first place. If a player is constantly swinging at the ball and never makes contact then it doesn’t matter what drugs he is taking to enhance his performance because he won’t stay in the league very long. A band or solo artist is not that different. If that artist or band can’t perform in the first place then it will not matter what person or person’s wrote the music because it’s gonna suck. Like the baseball player on PED’s a band or solo artist must have a certain amount of talent to perform the music in front of them or that person or group of people will not have any type of career no matter who wrote the music or how many times they try to perform it.

When song writers are the performers, the song is written with performance in mind. The two are entwined. That can give higher results, but not always..

When song writers aren't performers, someone has to step in. For instance, Mac Davis needed Bobby Goldsboro to watch Scotty grow. People love that stuff. I like both ways, but more so the former.

When you say "any" maybe a little bit. But in general, when I hear a song I don't typically withhold judgement until I know if the performer wrote the song or not.

OTOH, in classical music almost all the music was written by someone else. That said, those performing it assume some latitude in interpreting the original such that maybe they too may be fairly regarded as artists.