- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
401k Investment Diversification
Posted on 7/17/24 at 5:28 pm
Posted on 7/17/24 at 5:28 pm
25 year old here that is looking to the rant for some more opinions..
Right now I have full investment into Vanguard 2060. But I have been doing some research and have been debating splitting that into multiple different funds.
Thinking of something like:
40% VANGUARD 2060
20% VANG PRIMECAP (VPMAX)
20% VANG WINDSOR 2 (VWNAX)
20% SP TTL MRKT IDX CL E
Thinking of keeping that chunk in 2060 for stability and try to get some diversification with extra growth with the others. Would this be a mistake given the slightly higher gross expense ratios for the others?
Right now I have full investment into Vanguard 2060. But I have been doing some research and have been debating splitting that into multiple different funds.
Thinking of something like:
40% VANGUARD 2060
20% VANG PRIMECAP (VPMAX)
20% VANG WINDSOR 2 (VWNAX)
20% SP TTL MRKT IDX CL E
Thinking of keeping that chunk in 2060 for stability and try to get some diversification with extra growth with the others. Would this be a mistake given the slightly higher gross expense ratios for the others?
Posted on 7/17/24 at 5:34 pm to GeauxHouston
Don’t see all your options. But I wouldn’t do what you’re doing. Either go all in on the 2060-2070 one or go total market. I personally do 70% total market and 30% international.
Posted on 7/17/24 at 5:47 pm to jsk020
Yeah haven’t done it yet was just getting opinions. My options are basically limited to all the vanguard target funds. There are some supplemental ones and the ones I listed are the ones worth mentioning out of those. I am with fidelity if that makes it easier to know. Why did you decide on 30%?
Posted on 7/17/24 at 5:56 pm to GeauxHouston
If youre gonna use target date funds go all in thats how theyre designed to function. Otherwise you short circuit the auto rebalance and shift to more conservative allocation as you age.
That said, Im not a fan due to higher expense ratio and tendency to go conservative earlier than necessary. I prefer low expense index funds nothing active managed. As you age maybe add some bond funds.
That said, Im not a fan due to higher expense ratio and tendency to go conservative earlier than necessary. I prefer low expense index funds nothing active managed. As you age maybe add some bond funds.
Posted on 7/17/24 at 6:12 pm to GeauxHouston
Just my take..
Focus more over the next 10-15 years on the amount you’re pumping in rather than the investment selection.
Once a solid base is built up, the investment selection will become more important. Amount saved will be the biggest determinant of the size later on.
If you’re pumping in the ~$23k/yr, then ignore my take.
Focus more over the next 10-15 years on the amount you’re pumping in rather than the investment selection.
Once a solid base is built up, the investment selection will become more important. Amount saved will be the biggest determinant of the size later on.
If you’re pumping in the ~$23k/yr, then ignore my take.
Posted on 7/17/24 at 6:26 pm to LSUcam7
I do 30% bc the total world index (VT) is like 65/35. Most on here would probably say go all VTI or whatever the equivalent you have. Either is a fine option. I’m 34, mainly just focus on contributing as much as you can. Trust me you will love what you did when you are in your 30s with kids
Posted on 7/17/24 at 6:44 pm to jsk020
Luckily I’m in a position I can max it out, which is a blessing.
Posted on 7/17/24 at 6:45 pm to LSUcam7
quote:
If you’re pumping in the ~$23k/yr, then ignore my take.
Living below my means so I am able to do this. So how would your take change?
Posted on 7/17/24 at 6:49 pm to GeauxHouston
Pick the lowest fee funds.
Large Cap 35
Small cap. 35
Real Estate 20
International 10
Large Cap 35
Small cap. 35
Real Estate 20
International 10
Posted on 7/17/24 at 7:14 pm to GeauxHouston
Just be aware that Vanguard Target Retirement 2060 has a 35% allocation to foreign stocks. Do you want 1 in 3 of your retirement dollars going into foreign stocks? They have absolutely sucked for the last 15 years and mostly sucked for the last 25.
Not giving advice, just pointing something out that you might not be aware of.
You're young. Go aggressive (but diversify). You've got time to figure something out if you don't like where you are in 15 years.
Do a Google search for "periodic table of investments". It shows, for the most part that what is hot today is usually cold tomorrow, but it will be hot again. Translation: spread out your stock investments in different stock types (large stocks, small stocks, growth stocks, and value stocks) so that when one cools off, the other may be getting hot.
Also, there is such a thing as opportunity costs. Holding cash or bonds, even inside of a fund at your age, may prevent you from realizing years and years of gains in the stock market if you continue to do it over your working life. Get a savings account for cash, at your age, you need your assets to work.
Not giving advice, just pointing something out that you might not be aware of.
You're young. Go aggressive (but diversify). You've got time to figure something out if you don't like where you are in 15 years.
Do a Google search for "periodic table of investments". It shows, for the most part that what is hot today is usually cold tomorrow, but it will be hot again. Translation: spread out your stock investments in different stock types (large stocks, small stocks, growth stocks, and value stocks) so that when one cools off, the other may be getting hot.
Also, there is such a thing as opportunity costs. Holding cash or bonds, even inside of a fund at your age, may prevent you from realizing years and years of gains in the stock market if you continue to do it over your working life. Get a savings account for cash, at your age, you need your assets to work.
Posted on 7/18/24 at 12:55 am to GeauxHouston
I’ve been really heavy on large cap since covid. Will probably rebalance a bit back into mid and small when the economy gears back toward promoting those sectors again.
Posted on 7/18/24 at 4:23 am to GeauxHouston
The main thing is you are starting at 25, which is great. Hit the 401k as hard as you can if one is available, and also fund a Roth if you are eligible. Go heavy on American stocks, at least in the early decades.
To encourage your early stock investment, I'll share an anecdote I've mentioned before. When I was a little older than you in about 1995, I saved up $5,000 and put it in a taxable Fidelity Blue Chip Growth mutual fund. It was my first stock market purchase. It's been riding ever since, with no additional contributions except automatic reinvestment of dividends.
It's seen lots of ups and downs (I recall when it once went from over 20K to about 12k in a few days), but today it is worth $102,000. I don't look at it but once or twice a year, but I did see it was over $105K last week before a recent dip. I'm going to have a hard time ever cashing it out because it's been so interesting to watch over the decades.
Also, I read an article about federal employees who had over a million in their TSP, the equivalent of a 401k for feds. They tended to share three characteristics: (1) started contributing when young, (2) maxed out contributions, and (3) went heavy on the C fund, which is basically the S&P 500. These are folks who don't generally earn big salaries, but they all stacked it up with the power of the market and time.
At 25, you have a golden opportunity: time. Take advantage of it, because you can't get it back once it has passed.
To encourage your early stock investment, I'll share an anecdote I've mentioned before. When I was a little older than you in about 1995, I saved up $5,000 and put it in a taxable Fidelity Blue Chip Growth mutual fund. It was my first stock market purchase. It's been riding ever since, with no additional contributions except automatic reinvestment of dividends.
It's seen lots of ups and downs (I recall when it once went from over 20K to about 12k in a few days), but today it is worth $102,000. I don't look at it but once or twice a year, but I did see it was over $105K last week before a recent dip. I'm going to have a hard time ever cashing it out because it's been so interesting to watch over the decades.
Also, I read an article about federal employees who had over a million in their TSP, the equivalent of a 401k for feds. They tended to share three characteristics: (1) started contributing when young, (2) maxed out contributions, and (3) went heavy on the C fund, which is basically the S&P 500. These are folks who don't generally earn big salaries, but they all stacked it up with the power of the market and time.
At 25, you have a golden opportunity: time. Take advantage of it, because you can't get it back once it has passed.
Posted on 7/18/24 at 6:27 am to GeauxHouston
Swapped over to 100% equity index fund that from what I gather mirrors the S&P 500. Up 16% YTD and the fund's lifetime return averages just over 11%; fee is .01%. So far so good 
Posted on 7/18/24 at 9:13 pm to GeauxHouston
20% VIGIX (growth/tech)
20% VINIX (S&P 500)
10% VMCIX (mid-cap index)
10% VMGMX (mid-cap growth)
10% VSCIX (small-cap index)
10% VSGAX (small-cap growth)
10% VIVIX (value)
5% VTSNX (total international index)
5% VWILX (international growth)
You can simplify and just do (1) 20% small-cap fund and (1) 20% mid-cap fund. Do not choose a target date fund, as they underperform. After a year of playing around with options, I’m most content with the above selections. Don’t plan on revising for minimum 15 years. I’m 38, by the way.
20% VINIX (S&P 500)
10% VMCIX (mid-cap index)
10% VMGMX (mid-cap growth)
10% VSCIX (small-cap index)
10% VSGAX (small-cap growth)
10% VIVIX (value)
5% VTSNX (total international index)
5% VWILX (international growth)
You can simplify and just do (1) 20% small-cap fund and (1) 20% mid-cap fund. Do not choose a target date fund, as they underperform. After a year of playing around with options, I’m most content with the above selections. Don’t plan on revising for minimum 15 years. I’m 38, by the way.
Popular
Back to top

9









