- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Coaching Changes
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
re: My top 5 (w/ metrics)
Posted on 11/11/25 at 1:52 pm to yaherrdme
Posted on 11/11/25 at 1:52 pm to yaherrdme
quote:
What does this mean ?
It means what it says. Example: BK clearly didn't put enough effort into physicality and toughness. Mike Elko does.
Is that a Tommy Moffitt thing? Maybe. But, Elko brought Moffitt in while BK kicked him out.
1
Posted on 11/11/25 at 1:54 pm to MilkJug
Prolly the worst move he made was firing moffit....if he was gonna bring Blake baker, corey raymond etc why not moffit? Js
Posted on 11/11/25 at 1:56 pm to Lark225
quote:
Prolly the worst move he made was firing moffit....if he was gonna bring Blake baker, corey raymond etc why not moffit? Js
I agree. Huge mistake.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 2:00 pm to Bout2Ret
quote:
25.... Nuff said
What hasn't been said enough is that........ HE AIN'T COMING BACK TO LSU.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 2:44 pm to MilkJug
quote:
Mike Shanahan (Indiana OC)
Consistent success - 5
How is this a 5?
Posted on 11/11/25 at 2:46 pm to AlwysATgr
At LSU you have a Georgia grad being the potential big benefactor.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 2:55 pm to IM_4_LSU
quote:
How is this a 5?
He's been an OC for 4 years and has fielded a top 25 offense each of those years. Has fielded the #1 and #2 offense this year and last year. And he's done this at two different schools with completely different rosters.
I consider that consistent success.
This post was edited on 11/11/25 at 3:23 pm
Posted on 11/11/25 at 3:11 pm to MilkJug
I swear some of y’all must not have jobs
Posted on 11/11/25 at 3:13 pm to Chad504boy
quote:
Mike Gundy
Consistent success - 4
Coaches physicality - 4
Success in big games - 4
Recruiting - 4 (won't be a problem at LSU)
Personality/relationship with fanbase - 5
total - 21
Posted on 11/11/25 at 3:36 pm to MilkJug
I think you vastly underestimated Brohm. I’d personally rank him above everyone but Kiffin. I’d also prefer him over Kiffin. Also think you overestimate Freeman.
This post was edited on 11/11/25 at 3:37 pm
Posted on 11/11/25 at 3:36 pm to MilkJug
quote:
He's been an OC for 4 years and has fielded a top 25 offense each of those years. Has fielded the #1 and #2 offense this year and last year. And he's done this at two different schools with completely different rosters.
I consider that consistent success.
But you gave Kiffin a 4....your metric cannot be right. If he hasn't proven to be a successful head coach how can he have a higher success then any other candidate on this list? You can see where that makes zero sense right?
Posted on 11/11/25 at 3:52 pm to MilkJug
quote:
Mike Shanahan (Indiana OC) Consistent success - 5 Coaches physicality - 3 Success in big games - 4 Recruiting - 2 Personality/relationship with fanbase - 3 total - 17
I am apprehensive about MS as a HC due to inexperience but I am all over him as OC candidate. He would need a lot of help in HC jump as in mentors.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 5:45 pm to IM_4_LSU
quote:
You can see where that makes zero sense right?
No. I am rating each of them relative to their own position. Why? Because it's perfectly reasonable to hire a coordinator that doesn't have HC experience. Most on my list happen to be head coaches, Shanahan is not. If "head coach experience" was one of my criteria, he would have a 0 and Kiffin would have a 5, but I don't care about head coach experience.
I think Shanahan has been more consistently successful at his position than Kiffin has been at Kiffin's position over the last 4 years. Does this not make sense to you?
Posted on 11/11/25 at 6:56 pm to MilkJug
The problem here is you didn’t provide a detailed description of your 5 metrics in a rubric that can be followed or calibrated. What you may see a a 5 for consistency I may see as a 3. Recruiting, vice versa. Your defense of your ratings is very subjective “I gave him a 5 here” why? By what measure, what stat line or outcome, what data are used to provide the levels within each 1 - category?
This post was edited on 11/11/25 at 7:05 pm
Posted on 11/11/25 at 7:02 pm to MilkJug
Number of Posts: 14
Registered on: 11/10/2025
Smdh
Registered on: 11/10/2025
Smdh
Posted on 11/11/25 at 7:50 pm to TigerGrad03
Jeff Brohm would be so legit. He's not even on the current odds boards unfortunately....
Posted on 11/11/25 at 8:24 pm to TxWampus
quote:
The problem here is you didn’t provide a detailed description of your 5 metrics in a rubric that can be followed or calibrated. What you may see a a 5 for consistency I may see as a 3. Recruiting, vice versa. Your defense of your ratings is very subjective “I gave him a 5 here” why? By what measure, what stat line or outcome, what data are used to provide the levels within each 1 - category?
They are subjective ratings. I didn't claim these numbers were objective. In fact, I implied that my numbers may be off, because I don't have ALL the info.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 10:05 pm to MilkJug
quote:
I think Shanahan has been more consistently successful at his position than Kiffin has been at Kiffin's position over the last 4 years. Does this not make sense to you?
The logic is flawed. The responsibility of an OC is significantly less than that of a Head Coach. Kiffin also has a much longer track record of fielding good offenses and developing QBs.
Posted on 11/11/25 at 11:13 pm to Johnny Carson
Sit down Frank. You’re never gonna be our Coach.
Posted on 11/12/25 at 7:27 am to sharkfhin
quote:
Number of Posts: 14
Registered on: 11/10/2025
Smdh
I love how yall say this like it means anything at all.
Page 2 of 3
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News