Started By
Message

re: Let’s get this clear once and for all: the internet is NOT a utility

Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:00 am to
Posted by gthog61
Irving, TX
Member since Nov 2009
71001 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:00 am to
The assholes pushing net neutrality do not believe in companies having a competitive advantage when they innovate because that is not "fair".
Posted by Loserman
Member since Sep 2007
23151 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:03 am to
Are we clear yet?

Are we clear?
Posted by Eurocat
Member since Apr 2004
17240 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:06 am to
You do realize that innovation can happen with little guys?

Listen carefully....Net Neutrality helps a guy like Chicken make Tigerdroppings.com

Eliminating it will help the huge ones like scout.com and rivals.com and the sites owned by ESPN.com (you want more bamers with 2015 brave sports person of the year Kaitlyn Jenner?).

Net neutrality makes things doable for the website you are on.
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
80521 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:41 am to
How about the ISPs include in their terms of service that they won't throttle or otherwise alter speeds based on content. If they violate that, they're open to lawsuits.

How is this a bad approach?
Posted by Eurocat
Member since Apr 2004
17240 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:48 am to
But that is what we have now! Under Net Neutrality!

And that is exactly what they want to get rid of!
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
80521 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:53 am to
No, it's not.

Title II is way more than just terms of service.

Net Neutrality as currently structured is a solution looking for a problem. And it allows the government to control the internet legally when they so choose.
This post was edited on 12/16/17 at 3:55 am
Posted by KoachKletus
Member since Jan 2015
1103 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 4:00 am to
Ummm,,who decides what content? KomKast is the largest ISP in the states and people are idiots if they truly believe Komkast will be "fair and balanced" when your new 'internet bundle" is rolled out in the next year. Oh well,,November 2018 will fix this fricked up ruling.
Posted by KosmoCramer
Member since Dec 2007
80521 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 4:03 am to
Huh?
Posted by starsandstripes
Georgia
Member since Nov 2017
11897 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 4:28 am to
NN means internet will be controlled by govt. So, for me NN is a non-starter.

As for what the internet is, that whole debate needs to be re-framed. There is nothing close to consensus with regard to status as a utility or not. That tells me we need to start from scratch in defining the essential characteristics of what the internet is, its parts, its functions, etc.

Posted by LSUGrrrl
Frisco, TX
Member since Jul 2007
46368 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 8:05 am to
quote:

Like electricity, water, or gas.
And it isn’t essential for life. That is all.


I would agree with you 15 years ago. However, the world and the way information is disseminated has changed. The internet is a game changer much the way electricity and running water was for society generations ago.

I’m sure people once believed electricity wasn’t essential for life. As electricity changed the way humans lived, that changed. The same is true for the internet. It has become essential for information. If you restrict who has access to information you are creating an almost insurmountable roadblock that prevents the “have-nots” from learning and improving. You are essentially creating 2 classes in society that is self-perpetuating.
Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 8:11 am to
quote:

Ummm,,who decides what content?


The people who consume the product? If it sucks for the people who purchase the product and they identify the suckage, they don't buy the product?
Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 8:21 am to
quote:

The internet is a game changer much the way electricity and running water was for society generations ago.


That seems a little dramatic.
If you were cut off of water or electricity, your life would suck in a very dramatic way.

If, somehow, you internet connection was --not cut off-- but slower? at times, which would be the one you'd choose to be fully up and running?
That being said, your premise is no more than a fearful guess.





quote:

If you restrict who has access to information you are creating an almost insurmountable roadblock that prevents the “have-nots” from learning and improving. You are essentially creating 2 classes in society that is self-perpetuating.


Again...fear based on...fear.
Are you saying that laws would be written and passed that would prevent any other than existing provider from entering the market?


Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 8:31 am to
quote:

If you're not willing to lose the internet or live without it then you're not really in the place to have that opinion. You're kind of off on this one.

I think you're kinda off on this one. No one is claiming anyone would lose their connection, one way or the other. It's an implied False Choice.
Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 8:37 am to
quote:

In Europe people think that because of the importance of it, it is a utlity


Considering the derpy and self destructive nature of what they allow to happen to their once strong culture, people in Europe seem kinda dumb and gullible.

That said...who cares what a bunch of limy poofters think?
Posted by Houma Sapien
up the bayou
Member since Jul 2013
1688 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 9:57 am to
quote:

Like electricity, water, or gas.


water's not a utility, get a cistern

gas isnt a utility, they still make wood burning stoves

electricity isnt a utility, they still make candles


see what im getting at here? just because something doesnt keep you alive doesnt mean its not a 'utility.' like it or not, the internet has become just as much of our daily lives as electricity, gas or water.
This post was edited on 12/16/17 at 9:58 am
Posted by Freder
Member since Aug 2014
809 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 12:28 pm to
quote:

Not if they want to be considered as part of the functioning society...which is what utilities are all about. Passive forms of entertainment are not necessary for a functioning society.


Wait... are you saying the only use for the internet is to provide passive forms of entertainment?
Posted by bmy
Nashville
Member since Oct 2007
48203 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 2:45 pm to
quote:


How about the ISPs include in their terms of service that they won't throttle or otherwise alter speeds based on content. If they violate that, they're open to lawsuits.

How is this a bad approach?




Why would they do this? I mean, Comcast used to promise to do that.. but since the NN ruling became imminent they deleted it from their website
Posted by CajunTiger_225
Baton Rouge
Member since Jan 2015
9233 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:27 pm to
quote:

No one is claiming anyone would lose their connection, one way or the other. It's an implied False Choice.

Neither am I. Im just pointing out he said it's not essential to life while he is not willing to live his own life without it which makes it just an emotive response which gives it no truth.
Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:50 pm to
quote:

Wait... are you saying the only use for the internet is to provide passive forms of entertainment?

No not at all. I would guess that for the overwhelming number of people it is more than it is not.
Posted by Dale51
Member since Oct 2016
32378 posts
Posted on 12/16/17 at 3:52 pm to
quote:

Im just pointing out he said it's not essential to life while he is not willing to live his own life without it which makes it just an emotive response which gives it no truth.
And I'm pointing out that it is a false choice to claim one "has to do without it". Nowhere have I heard that "You pay our stated price or 'No internet for YOU'".
first pageprev pagePage 17 of 19Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram