Thoughts on George B McClellan

Never heard of her

The Little Giant?

Pass.

I get my kicks above the waistline, sunshine.

I think it was best said about him he put so much effort into putting the army together, he couldn’t bear to have it torn apart

So why did you get kicked out?

Probably the only Presidential candidate in American history to publicly repudiate the platform of the political party he represented.

I was short in some of my answers. Maybe a little...short. Their loss, because I asked very popular questions.

I got warned for saying “the divine comedy should be read within context of the time it was written in”

And banned for saying answering a question “why was xxxxxxx so hated for being an unreliable narrator” to which I responded “he was an u reliable narrator. That is why they didn’t like him”.

An excellent organizer and administrator who was too afraid to take risks on the battlefield.

Part of that was due to the constant belief that Lee outnumbered him, but I think part of it was also due to the fact that the man had become so accustomed to success in life that he was too afraid to gamble out of fear of failing.

But you do have to give the man his due. In September 1862, Lee invaded Maryland just days after routing the Union army from the field at Second Manassas. The situation was beyond dire and Confederate victory seemed imminent. He was tasked by Lincoln with a seemingly impossible situation: "To reorganize the Union army and bring it out of chaos."

Within days he had organized a ragtag force of veteran and green troops, many of whom knew not how to march or load their rifles, and marched them into the Maryland Campaign, successfully checking Lee at Antietam. Had McClellan been a little more daring, he could have turned the stalemate at Antietam into a decisive victory. Nevertheless, he took the momentum away from Lee and the Confederacy in the late-summer of 1862.

quote:

---

His overestimating Confederate forces is baffling. Simply baffling.

---

It most definitely is baffling in hindsight, but the fog of war was real and McClellan had an intelligence service (the Pinkertons) that he relied upon for information. They were the ones telling him that Lee had the superior force.

He definitely comes off looking foolish though.

I always thought he was old school old money aristocrat, but after doing some research, while he was fairly well to do ore civil war, he was only making 10,000 dollars a year as president of a railroad. That’s about 300k now: hardly noteworthy.

quote:

---

is overestimating Confederate forces is baffling. Simply baffling. To the point o don’t even know if he believes it.

---

If my memory is correct didn’t Lee do a lot of marching men basically in circles to give the Union an appearance that he had a larger numbers than he actually had.