re: Madison Brooks case cell phone data now in defense’s hands

Nah but I thought it was pretty cool compared to having traditional cheerleaders. The Midnight Yell practices were awesome.

Dude…. Calm down….. you are just running your mouth with little to no proof. STFU or leave the thread.

quote:

---

Someone in her family ought to beat their asses. Nothing she did before running into these scumbags changes what they did.

---

You mean her getting so drunk she got run over had nothing to do with het getting raped?

Is there a concise list of what each guy was charged with? I see a lot related to the rape but not related to her death. Rape aside, if these guys hadn’t offered her a ride and transported her to the place of her death, she wouldn’t have died. 4 guys offer drunk girl ride home, she ends up dead in a ditch.

quote:

---

Yeh this isn’t necessarily true. She got shitfaced drunk on her own. If these guys didn’t do anything and weren’t even there that night , there is no telling how her night ends.

---

Sure there is. I can tell you she would not have ended up dead when and where she did. The fact she “could” have died another way if they hadn’t picked her up doesn’t change the fact that she did die because they picked her up.

A reasonable and prudent person offers a woman a ride. She forgets her address so what does he do? Does he let her out on a dark, busy, divided highway or somewhere safer (which includes anywhere else.) These guys didn’t do that, probably because they knew how it would look. Semi-conscious, disheveled, probably unable to walk properly due to the anal trauma. The decisions these guys made led directly to her death. Yeah, she could have been hit by a meteor and died. But she didn’t.

quote:

---

change the fact that she did die because they picked her up.

---

Once again this isn’t true and this statement would get laughed out of court by the defense

She died because of a list of reasons, but most importantly, the biggest caveat in her death was her intoxication

The men need to be charged with rape. They need to be punished. Their own words prove they new what they were doing. But your statements are just out there

If the walker guys didn’t exist Brooks would have been extremely intoxicated and still needed a way to get home because she wouldn’t have been able to do so herself.

The walker boys are responsible for her rape. Pinning the death on them wouldn’t stick for me unless other evidence comes out we are unaware of

Even if she found another way home, what is a worse ride than one that ends with you anally raped and dead?

quote:

---

They raped her. Her intoxication and actions led to her death

---

She didn't drive herself to the location of her death.

And the action of getting out of their vehicle didn’t kill her

What killed her was standing in the middle of the street and getting hit by a car

If an Uber driver dropped her off, didn’t rape her, would you still want them charged with her death?

The rape and death are separate manners entirely