- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
Posted on 2/15/25 at 1:47 pm to cypher
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:15 pm to Lee B
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:21 pm to cypher
quote:
while also calling for concessions from both countries to secure a peace deal.
Yes, because when you've been invaded you have to cede things to the invaders.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:39 pm to CitizenK
Hey, y'all. My mom is in the hospital, and I've resolved to waste less time reading tweets from Lord Bebo and ayden (because that's what Chicken apparently wants this thread to be), so I haven't been around much and won't be, but I wanted to write this, because I don't think most people understand what's happening right now.
President Trump is trying to get Ukraine and Russia towards peace. From Trump's point of view, he trying to get both sides to move, but what Trump has been doing is looking at the situation and seeing which side seems more desperate ... and thus more willing to make concessions.
And, a month ago, that looked like Ukraine. Ukraine lost ground fairly consistently throughout 2024, with the exception of the Kursk offensive. The Ukrainian command was badly organized and recruitment was poor. Because units were almost never rotated out, many commanders would unofficially let some guys go home for a while and rest, and so desertion became something that was unofficially ignored in many units.
But so much of that has recently changed. The biggest change is that Ukraine has substantially slowed the Russian advance. Ukraine continues to improve its drone advantage, and their heavy bombers do significant damage to Russian equipment.
And Russia is finally starting to feel the pinch of its now-empty reserves of artillery and many types of armored vehicles. (I've been telling y'all for months that this was on the horizon.) Some donations from the Norks helped a bit, but Russia can't make armored vehicles and artillery pieces nearly as fast as Ukrainian drones destroy them. And improved Ukrainian air defense is resulting in Russian bombers releasing their glide bombs from further back, and that's starting to affect their accuracy.
The net result of all this is that the situation along the front is moving back towards the stalemate that we saw at the end of 2022, before the Ukrainian offensive.
And that means that Zelensky is far, far from desperate to make a deal. He has the $50 billion in loans from the seized Russian assets, and he knows that, ultimately, the EU can "loan" him more of that money (and they likely will by the end of this year, if a peace deal isn't in place).
A stalemate along the front will give Ukraine space to implement the military reforms that it's trying to put in place: reorganizing into several corps, systemizing troop rotation so that getting drafted doesn't seem like a one-way ticket to the front, improving the salary structure of soldiers to encourage enlistment and improve morale, and strengthening existing brigades instead of trying to form new ones.
Meanwhile, the enlistment bonuses Russia is paying new soldiers are unsustainable. When the front stabilizes soon, Putin is going to face the prospect of needing a new general mobilization, which he will resist as long as possible, because it will be extremely unpopular and could send the economy into a death spiral.
About a month ago, I disagreed with some posters here who were suggesting that the Russian economy was in danger of imminent collapse. It wasn't then, and it's not now. But Trump is committed to low oil prices, and Russia is continuing to slowly drain its sovereign wealth fund, and Ukrainian drones are continuing to damage Russian energy infrastructure, and the long-term economic forecast for Russia is still, ultimately, collapse.
All this is why Zelensky isn't going to be pressured into a bad deal. And it's why, very soon, you'll see Trump pivot again to pressuring Putin.
It's important to understand that Trump is NEGOTIATING. He's pushed Ukraine as hard as he could to find out how far they would go, and he's gotten some results. Some of the biggest impacts have been in a number of statements from European countries indicating that they will spend a lot more on their militaries. And make no mistake -- a lot of that spending will be in the form of US-made weapons. The EU is America's largest trading partner, and Trump isn't trying to destroy the transatlantic alliance -- he's trying to rebalance it.
So now, he's going to flip it around and push Putin more. Watch. It's funny to me that there are two groups of people saying that Trump is on Russia's side:
1) The Orban/Tucker faction of MAGA who freakishly think Russia is anti-woke, and
2) The international Left, who pretend that Trump is a Russian agent in order to raise money and mobilize activists.
These groups make up the vast majority of the online discourse, and they are analyzing the situation from the perspective of their own political desires. Personally, I think that Trump truly wants peace, and I particularly think that he wants a Nobel Peace Prize. If you try to analyze the situation from the perspective that Trump is actually trying to do what he says he's doing, then his actions make a lot more sense.
President Trump is trying to get Ukraine and Russia towards peace. From Trump's point of view, he trying to get both sides to move, but what Trump has been doing is looking at the situation and seeing which side seems more desperate ... and thus more willing to make concessions.
And, a month ago, that looked like Ukraine. Ukraine lost ground fairly consistently throughout 2024, with the exception of the Kursk offensive. The Ukrainian command was badly organized and recruitment was poor. Because units were almost never rotated out, many commanders would unofficially let some guys go home for a while and rest, and so desertion became something that was unofficially ignored in many units.
But so much of that has recently changed. The biggest change is that Ukraine has substantially slowed the Russian advance. Ukraine continues to improve its drone advantage, and their heavy bombers do significant damage to Russian equipment.
And Russia is finally starting to feel the pinch of its now-empty reserves of artillery and many types of armored vehicles. (I've been telling y'all for months that this was on the horizon.) Some donations from the Norks helped a bit, but Russia can't make armored vehicles and artillery pieces nearly as fast as Ukrainian drones destroy them. And improved Ukrainian air defense is resulting in Russian bombers releasing their glide bombs from further back, and that's starting to affect their accuracy.
The net result of all this is that the situation along the front is moving back towards the stalemate that we saw at the end of 2022, before the Ukrainian offensive.
And that means that Zelensky is far, far from desperate to make a deal. He has the $50 billion in loans from the seized Russian assets, and he knows that, ultimately, the EU can "loan" him more of that money (and they likely will by the end of this year, if a peace deal isn't in place).
A stalemate along the front will give Ukraine space to implement the military reforms that it's trying to put in place: reorganizing into several corps, systemizing troop rotation so that getting drafted doesn't seem like a one-way ticket to the front, improving the salary structure of soldiers to encourage enlistment and improve morale, and strengthening existing brigades instead of trying to form new ones.
Meanwhile, the enlistment bonuses Russia is paying new soldiers are unsustainable. When the front stabilizes soon, Putin is going to face the prospect of needing a new general mobilization, which he will resist as long as possible, because it will be extremely unpopular and could send the economy into a death spiral.
About a month ago, I disagreed with some posters here who were suggesting that the Russian economy was in danger of imminent collapse. It wasn't then, and it's not now. But Trump is committed to low oil prices, and Russia is continuing to slowly drain its sovereign wealth fund, and Ukrainian drones are continuing to damage Russian energy infrastructure, and the long-term economic forecast for Russia is still, ultimately, collapse.
All this is why Zelensky isn't going to be pressured into a bad deal. And it's why, very soon, you'll see Trump pivot again to pressuring Putin.
It's important to understand that Trump is NEGOTIATING. He's pushed Ukraine as hard as he could to find out how far they would go, and he's gotten some results. Some of the biggest impacts have been in a number of statements from European countries indicating that they will spend a lot more on their militaries. And make no mistake -- a lot of that spending will be in the form of US-made weapons. The EU is America's largest trading partner, and Trump isn't trying to destroy the transatlantic alliance -- he's trying to rebalance it.
So now, he's going to flip it around and push Putin more. Watch. It's funny to me that there are two groups of people saying that Trump is on Russia's side:
1) The Orban/Tucker faction of MAGA who freakishly think Russia is anti-woke, and
2) The international Left, who pretend that Trump is a Russian agent in order to raise money and mobilize activists.
These groups make up the vast majority of the online discourse, and they are analyzing the situation from the perspective of their own political desires. Personally, I think that Trump truly wants peace, and I particularly think that he wants a Nobel Peace Prize. If you try to analyze the situation from the perspective that Trump is actually trying to do what he says he's doing, then his actions make a lot more sense.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:46 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
My mom is in the hospital,
Best wishes for your mom.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:50 pm to cypher
Thanks, guys. She had a cardiac scare (already has a stent in her heart), but it looks like she's going to be OK for now. She's supposed to be moved to a skilled nursing facility on Monday (they would do it today, but they have to get the OK from the insurance).
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:50 pm to cypher
Posted on 2/15/25 at 2:53 pm to GOP_Tiger
Somehow, I have the crazy suspicion that President Trump isn't going to be working hard for any special deals to bring this guy back to the US.
Loading Twitter/X Embed...
If tweet fails to load, click here.Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:04 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
My mom is in the hospital
I hope all goes well for her.
I'm dealing with my mom being in the last days of a terminal diagnosis.
I have to admit it's made me pissier and edgier than usual.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:10 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
It's funny to me that there are two groups of people saying that Trump is on Russia's side:
1) The Orban/Tucker faction of MAGA who freakishly think Russia is anti-woke, and
2) The international Left, who pretend that Trump is a Russian agent in order to raise money and mobilize activists.
Tell Poland and France and most of Europe.
I can suspend my personal lack of faith in Trump to see that your analysis might be what's going on... but like Elon, Trump doesn't seem to understand that careless messaging creates chaos... and chaos creates instability and destroys faith... and when you've lost people's faith in you, then you're done.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:16 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
because I don't think most people understand what's happening right now.
You’re the one that doesn’t understand.
You claimed in November the appointment of Kellogg signaled Trump vastly increasing Ukraine funding, the exact opposite occured and you never acknowledged being wrong.
Now you’re back to lecture us all?
Humble yourself guy.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:25 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
But so much of that has recently changed
You just typed out a fairytale. You have to be the biggest NAFO troll in this thread. You are filled with hopium and copium and just make shite up in your head that makes you feel good
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:30 pm to Lee B
quote:
I can suspend my personal lack of faith in Trump to see that your analysis might be what's going on... but like Elon, Trump doesn't seem to understand that careless messaging creates chaos... and chaos creates instability and destroys faith... and when you've lost people's faith in you, then you're done.
I'm not arguing that Trump is some 5D chessmaster, but I also don't think he's stupid. I didn't vote for either him or for Kamala. Most of the analysis of this war comes from people who either think that he's God, or who think that he's Satan -- and I don't think either of those.
So, I would turn your argument right around and argue that, for Trump to ultimately get a deal, he needs to be trusted by both sides, not just one. If one assumes that Trump actually wants to get a deal done soon, then that won't happen if Trump can't talk with Putin or isn't seen as pushing both sides to compromise.
I just see lots of anti-Trump people calling him a Russian asset, and I think that's insipid. What does Russia have to offer him? What Trump is trying to do is to get Europe to pay for more of its own defense. He's not trying to destroy NATO and the trading relationship we have with the EU (our largest trading partner) in order to push the EU economically towards China.
At least, that's how this makes sense to me. And, again, I'm not saying that Trump's negotiations will work. But please explain to me what's in it for him to be Putin's buddy.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:32 pm to texag7
quote:
You claimed in November the appointment of Kellogg signaled Trump vastly increasing Ukraine funding, the exact opposite occured and you never acknowledged being wrong.
He always types out these scenarios that are not based on any reality on the ground. That's why he hates the tweets from Lord Bebo and Ayden because it wrecks his fantasy world in his head.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:37 pm to John Barron
quote:
You just typed out a fairytale. You have to be the biggest NAFO troll in this thread. You are filled with hopium and copium and just make shite up in your head that makes you feel good
I suppose that it's time for me to acknowledge the superior wisdom and objective analysis of Lord Bebo, ayden, Russians with Attitude, and Geroman.
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:46 pm to GOP_Tiger
quote:
superior wisdom and objective analysis
They don't post analysis. They post actual video of the War and facts of what is happening on the ground. Your post read just like the Nuland Family owned ISW reports that are based on hopium and copium and not based on reality. Nobody reads ISW reports or your "analysis" unless they are into fan fiction
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:49 pm to John Barron
Posted on 2/15/25 at 3:50 pm to John Barron
Popular
Back to top


1


