Started By
Message

re: history discussion on why SC and Georgia are nicer/classier than Alabama and Mississippi

Posted on 9/20/23 at 2:21 pm to
Posted by justaniceguy
Member since Sep 2020
5866 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 2:21 pm to
Interesting enough a higher percentage of people Identify as scots Irish in South Carolina than in Alabama or Mississippi. I know the self reported ancestry kind of means nothing though.
Posted by scrooster
Resident Ethicist
Member since Jul 2012
40983 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 2:36 pm to
quote:

Assuming you mean 17th century here.

Absolutely 100% correct.

I'll correct that. I had 15 on the brain when I was posting that while being on the phone with BladeHQ at the time correcting a syntax error in my CC number.
Posted by Fraiser
Seattle
Member since Aug 2023
17 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 2:46 pm to
Culture of honor in the Southern United States, sociological theory , Wikpedia link, may have some explanatory value. Also, Culture of Honor: The Psychology of Violence in the South, by Nisbett and Cohen expands on this theory; the book has ISBN 0813319935 and is available on Amazon. I cannot recommend it as worth the price of purchase.

This cross-referenced article, guilt vs. shame vs. fear cultures (Wikipedia link.), presents the hypothesis that a shame/honor nexus in a culture leads to retributive violence.

Edited for grammar, and clarity.
This post was edited on 9/20/23 at 2:49 pm
Posted by LegendInMyMind
Member since Apr 2019
66915 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 3:00 pm to
quote:

There are far more wealthy and influential families in Charleston, Beaufort, Columbia, and Greenville.

Put them under the microscope that the Murdaughs found themselves under and see how it shakes out.
Posted by grizzlylongcut
Member since Sep 2021
12678 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 3:20 pm to
Albion's Seed: Four British Folkways in America

A lot of people need to read this book. It explains so much.
Posted by MetroAtlantaGatorFan
Member since Jun 2017
15598 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 3:21 pm to
quote:

The coastal cities in South Carolina and Georgia are probably worse than the ones more inland so I don’t think so.

You think Savannah is worse than Albany, Columbus, or Macon?
Posted by AlextheBodacious
Member since Oct 2020
2575 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 3:28 pm to
quote:

Put them under the microscope that the Murdaughs found themselves under and see how it shakes out.

They’d be slightly larger fish in slightly larger ponds.
Posted by bayou2
New Orleans, LA
Member since Feb 2007
3538 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:14 pm to


quote:

Georgia, OTOH, was a debtor colony similar to Australia.


^^^^
This

Plus the Cotton farmers of Georgia depleted the red clay soil so bad that these farmers were forced to move west to find better farming conditions. Most cotton farmers ended up in Mississippi.



Posted by Blizzard of Chizz
Member since Apr 2012
19984 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:23 pm to
The difference in bama and Georgia has everything to do with the airport in Atlanta. An international hub brought with it billions of dollars worth of industry… it also didn’t help Bama’s cause in trying to land the airport by having a jackass governor standing in the school house door, or bringing out the dogs and water hoses either.
Posted by bayou2
New Orleans, LA
Member since Feb 2007
3538 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:27 pm to


quote:

Georgia, OTOH, was a debtor colony similar to Australia.



... of course it could be said Georgua has had years of experience stealing stuff,

... votes
elections
yo money




Posted by MeridianDog
Home on the range
Member since Nov 2010
14538 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:29 pm to
There has always been a small segment of the population in Mississippi who had money. They came here before the civil war to make money off the labor of other folks. For them, life was good. For absolutely everyone else black, white, whatever they did not give a shite. Those people ran Mississippi for generations and are still behind whoever is in power here. It might change in another few generations because they do little for society and eventually they will eliminate themselves.
Posted by Auburn1968
NYC
Member since Mar 2019
23239 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:32 pm to
quote:

Alabama is from the inbreeding.


Sometimes looking at the stands in SEC football games, I see a lot of people who could be relatives.

Bear in mind, that America was founded by around 250 families of the original colonies.
Posted by Dixie2023
Member since Mar 2023
3600 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:35 pm to
Interesting. Do you know who they are?
Posted by scrooster
Resident Ethicist
Member since Jul 2012
40983 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 4:39 pm to
quote:

Albion's Seed: Four British Folkways in America

A lot of people need to read this book. It explains so much.

Thanks ... just ordered it. Going-to give it a try when it arrives.

Posted by FlatwoodsForester
Member since Jul 2012
2582 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 5:15 pm to
A lot of this can be attributed to Georgia's ag extension and continued education. Georgia was a pioneer in bringing education to residents across the state in the early 1900s. There was a "College on Wheels" created to reach all corners of the state to promote better farming practices which propelled GA to top of farm production in the south during the early 1900s. It was a train with a passenger car and a flat car that carried new innovative farming equipment. They taught classes reaching over 350,000 farmers across the state. It was one reason Georgia was more successful dealing with the boll weevil. Georgia's economy boomed while others in the south fell behind.

Posted by Santiago_Dunbar
Atlanta, GA
Member since Feb 2021
264 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 6:33 pm to
Albion’s Seed is a great read but is quite the endeavor. I’ve always thought this map was interesting:



It’s not often discussed due to the association between planters and slavery in the colonies, but indentured servants were a primary driver of population growth and labor early on.

IIRC, a ton of English gets underreported due to many Southern Americans listing “American” or something that sounds more interesting as ancestry.

Posted by justaniceguy
Member since Sep 2020
5866 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 7:03 pm to
How many of the original founding families of Mississippi are still there? Pretty sure most are long gone to greener pastures and the people running things are the descendants of carpetbaggers or the Celtic slaves
Posted by justaniceguy
Member since Sep 2020
5866 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 7:04 pm to
What 250 families are you referring to? The south was settled by way more than that. But I do agree there seem to be certain looks that are more common in the south or in certain parts of the south.
Posted by justaniceguy
Member since Sep 2020
5866 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 7:10 pm to
That map is a huge generalization but it’s a fine general rule.

A lot of the English are in fact listed as American as well as other more recent ancestors. If you are completely English and you have a great grandfather from Italy you might say you are Italian even though you are only 1/8.

Same can be said for scots Irish.

Another thing to point out is that these scots-Irish come from the borderlands of England and Scotland initially before Ireland. These people are not like highland scots at all.

My own father always said he was German but I have done extensive research and he is 100% English or scots Irish, at least if you leave out the Cherokee. And his most recent ancestor probably left Europe in the 18th century.
Posted by Santiago_Dunbar
Atlanta, GA
Member since Feb 2021
264 posts
Posted on 9/20/23 at 8:07 pm to
It’s definitely a generalization but I’ve found it reasonably accurate for the family lines I’ve been able to trace.

Most of the Scots-Irish ancestry I’ve researched dead-ends in Ulster. It’s tough to track back to where in the Lowlands/Northern England they would’ve originated.

The English/Welsh generally seems easier to figure out since they came straight over as opposed to camping out in Ulster for a generation or two.

first pageprev pagePage 3 of 4Next pagelast page

Back to top
logoFollow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News
Follow us on X, Facebook and Instagram to get the latest updates on LSU Football and Recruiting.

FacebookXInstagram