re: Shough rated most accurate QB

quote:

---

Carolina has a winning record and just beat the Rams. Tampa has a winning record and has won the division since 2021. The Dolphins have won 5 of their last 6.

---

You can put lipstick on a pig, but it's still a pig.

quote:

---

Spence” is 1-14 in the NFL and finished his senior college year at 5-7.

---

Shough had 7 years of college. What's his records there? All better than 5-7?

I think Shough is a great QB but I don't know if it'll matter if this team can't draft. We will have to wait and see if we get better.

quote:

---

can’t draft

---

We have five starters from last year’s draft

quote:

---

We have five starters from last year’s draft

---

We will need 3 more like that.

Penning plays QB? interesting.

quote:

---

Are you arguing Spence is better? Hard to keep track of whatever it is you are arguing at this point

---

For the umpteenth time, I think shough has played better, not much better like this board is making it out to be, and needs to play better if we're ever going to be a relevant playoff team again.

quote:

---

Penning plays QB? interesting.

---

RAS is a bullshite metric

AI says this:

Key Takeaway
RAS is an excellent tool to gauge a prospect's athletic ceiling and identify potential mismatches, but it must be combined with film study, character evaluation, and coaching context, as it doesn't capture all aspects of football talent.

I'll take the AI response over your bullshite one.

quote:

---

but it must be combined with film study, character evaluation, and coaching context, as it doesn't capture all aspects of football talent.

---

Lol ai is telling you its only one piece of the puzzle.

Some interesting stats here.
Rattler has 174 completions. He is also credited for having 11 passes dropped. but only 183 passes are "On-target"?

On-target throws = would have hit the intended receiver. how were 2 of these passes caught or dropped if it would not have hit the receiver?

He also has 82 incompletions. 3 passes batted away, 8 throw aways, 3 spikes, and the 11 drops. That would be 57 incompletions, of which 27 were "bad throws"

Comparison:
Shough has 120 completions & 9 drops. 133 On target passes. Wonder how they categorize those other 4, some of his 8 batted passes?

Shough has 64 incompletions, 8 bats, 6 throw aways, 1 spike, and 9 drops. Leaves 40 incompletions, of which 28 are "bad throws"

Don't know what to really make of that, just find it interesting when you start piecing together the stats. Especially those 2 "off-target" passes that were caught?

quote:

---

whatiknowsofar

---