- My Forums
- Tiger Rant
- LSU Recruiting
- SEC Rant
- Saints Talk
- Pelicans Talk
- More Sports Board
- Fantasy Sports
- Golf Board
- Soccer Board
- O-T Lounge
- Tech Board
- Home/Garden Board
- Outdoor Board
- Health/Fitness Board
- Movie/TV Board
- Book Board
- Music Board
- Political Talk
- Money Talk
- Fark Board
- Gaming Board
- Travel Board
- Food/Drink Board
- Ticket Exchange
- TD Help Board
Customize My Forums- View All Forums
- Show Left Links
- Topic Sort Options
- Trending Topics
- Recent Topics
- Active Topics
Started By
Message
0
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:30 am to Decatur
quote:
It's how the audience knows Aaron. Why introduce a new actor as Older Aaron that we get to see during the last minute of the show?
Failure. They already did. We saw 3 year old Aaron several times.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:31 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:30 am to TigerMyth36
did anyone hear what kimmel just said? how do we watch the Q&A thing??
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:32 am to Decatur
quote:
Please move on.
If you don't have the fortitude to defend your points then perhaps you should be the one to move on.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:34 am to TigerMyth36
this is some of the dumbest arguing i have ever seen.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:36 am to tigerguy121
quote:
regardless of when they died why would arron be in purgatory as a baby, to me it is just a plothole
Wrong. If the baby died in the plane crash, the baby would be in the waiting area as a baby. A baby would have nothing to be punished for so the baby could actually be in the waiting room with claire.
If they died on the plane, it makes complete sense that Aaron would still be a baby in the waiting room/Church.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:37 am to noonan
quote:
this is some of the dumbest arguing i have ever seen
I agree. You have been unable to refute a thing I said.
Because when discussing an unknown religious concept like Purgatory, it is just silly to think there may be more than one level. /sarcasm.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:42 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:41 am to TigerMyth36
quote:
Furthermore, you guys are basing the whole island being real based on Christian stating "most important time of your lives."
Christian also said some of them died before you and some of them after you...I really think people are grasping at the island being purgatory but hell the show promoted lots of theories for along time so I understand the second guessing. It seemed pretty obvious to me though that the island was real.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:43 am to TigerMyth36
quote:
You have been unable to refute a thing I said.
apparently you just don't read my posts.
and you already admitted to playing devil's advocate here.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:44 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:43 am to St Augustine
Sure, because more than one level to purgatory is just impossible.
Explain Aaron as a baby, and no baby for jin and sun.
It is a plot hole, is not an explanation. Maybe it was not a plot hole. Maybe you are reading things wrong.
I don't believe it, but I can see why those that think they died in the crash, think that way.
Explain Aaron as a baby, and no baby for jin and sun.
It is a plot hole, is not an explanation. Maybe it was not a plot hole. Maybe you are reading things wrong.
I don't believe it, but I can see why those that think they died in the crash, think that way.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:44 am to noonan
Read your posts. You refuted nothing.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:45 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:44 am to TigerMyth36
It's THEIR mind. THEIR created purgatory. Claire having Aaron is what snapped Claire, Kate and Charlie into "flash" mode....so it was necessary.
I mean, Jack's son wasn't real and Anthony Cooper wasn't actually hurt in a plane crash with Locke....they were just intruments of the mind.
I mean, Jack's son wasn't real and Anthony Cooper wasn't actually hurt in a plane crash with Locke....they were just intruments of the mind.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:45 am to TigerMyth36
there have been a number of reasons for the baby aaron. yet you keep saying no one has addressed it.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:45 am to noonan
I agree that a lot of this arguing is very nitpicky (my posts included) but TM does make a good point. I've seen so many fricking ridiculous theories over the course of this show. Why should his opinion on how he interpreted the show be completely dismissed when this show has inspired some of the most retarded speculation ever?
I like the show, I really do. I just wasn't feeling the last 15 minutes.
I like the show, I really do. I just wasn't feeling the last 15 minutes.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:46 am to Sandkhan
Sand
I get that. But there was no reason to bring fake Aaron to the church. He was FAKE.
Christian said Jack needed to let go. If that was fake Aaron then Claire would have needed to let go for her to move on. Thus there would have been no fake Aaron. If that was real Aaron there is no way he would still be a baby. We already saw him at 3. Plus he would cross over with his loved ones.
I get that. But there was no reason to bring fake Aaron to the church. He was FAKE.
Christian said Jack needed to let go. If that was fake Aaron then Claire would have needed to let go for her to move on. Thus there would have been no fake Aaron. If that was real Aaron there is no way he would still be a baby. We already saw him at 3. Plus he would cross over with his loved ones.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:47 am to TigerMyth36
quote:
Sure, because more than one level to purgatory is just impossible. Explain Aaron as a baby, and no baby for jin and sun. It is a plot hole, is not an explanation. Maybe it was not a plot hole. Maybe you are reading things wrong. I don't believe it, but I can see why those that think they died in the crash, think that way.
I thought it was explained pretty well by the show. Even though you do have to base it on Christian, someone else said it about 30 pages ago, but he said these relationships created ON the island were the BEST part of their lives. On the island, Aaron was a baby, and Sun and Jin only got to be pregnant together. What happens after the island, when Claire is with a growing Aaron, is immaterial to what Christian is saying, even though its kinda fricked up to say raising Aaron wasn't the BEST part of Claire's life. Also, the baby Sun and Jin had wasn't a part of their island life really at all, since she was born off island and Jin never met her.
ETA:
quote:
Christian said Jack needed to let go. If that was fake Aaron then Claire would have needed to let go for her to move on. Thus there would have been no fake Aaron. If that was real Aaron there is no way he would still be a baby. We already saw him at 3. Plus he would cross over with his loved ones.
I get what you are saying about why she would need to bring him along though.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:50 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:48 am to xenythx
quote:
Why should his opinion on how he interpreted the show be completely dismissed
who is dismissing it? he made his argument. multiple people gave their arguments against it. and he ignored them.
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:48 am to noonan
Saying they didn't want another actor. wrong, they did have a 3 year old.
Saying Claire needed him, wrong. She needed to let him go to cross over.
Sorry where is the idea that refutes it wasn't dead plane crash Aaron?
Haven't seen any reasoning for why there was no Jin/Sun baby.
Saying Claire needed him, wrong. She needed to let him go to cross over.
Sorry where is the idea that refutes it wasn't dead plane crash Aaron?
Haven't seen any reasoning for why there was no Jin/Sun baby.
This post was edited on 5/24/10 at 1:52 am
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:49 am to TigerMyth36
quote:
If that was fake Aaron then Claire would have needed to let go for her to move on. Thus there would have been no fake Aaron. If that was real Aaron there is no way he would still be a baby. We already saw him at 3. Plus he would cross over with his loved ones.
What do you mean "fake" Aaron and "real" Aaron?
Posted on 5/24/10 at 1:50 am to Teddy Ruxpin
quote:
said it about 30 pages ago,
And as someone else said 30 pages ago, lives may have a context in purgatory.
Page 65 of 107
Popular
Back to top
Follow TigerDroppings for LSU Football News