re: Why are Left Handers used only at 1st Base

quote:

---

have a different question, why isn't 1B a lefthanded position like SS is a righty position? Every infielder should make the most common throws across the body with chest toward th infield. A pivot throw with back to plate should be exception.

---

Because the benefits of a good bat outweigh the minimal benefits a LH first baseman provides over a RH first baseman. Basically best bat wins at 1b.

Not so.

Right handed Cs snap throw to 1st base all the time. Throwing down to 3rd in one respect is actually easier for LHs. A RH hitter in the box can restrict or interfere with a RH throwing C, where a LH throwing C's arm is clear.

A simpler answer may just be that there are no LH catcher's mitts at the youth league level, thus LH kids are discouraged from the position in the formative stages.

they are used in left field, where their right hand catching the ball is near the line or wall.

Barry Bonds.

They can play center field too. No advantage to either hand in center.

quote:

---

Yes they do. If there were lefty catchers it would be much easier to steal 3B. Also, the throw to 2B is slightly further for a lefty because he has to throw across his body and in front of the bag. It's not much but in baseball every inch and millisecond counts on a steal. It's an even more difficult throw if the batter is right handed. Now I understand that it's also more difficult for a right handed C with a left handed batter, but a lefty C is baseball suicide for the defense, at least when you get to the higher levels of play.

---

You people have totally missed my point. Lefties who have good enough arms to throw out runner in any steal attempt are pitchers. Hard throwing left handed pitchers are the solid gold of baseball.

Do you know why the term 'crafty lefty' is used? It's because there are so few lefties who can throw 100 mph. If you are left handed and can throw 90 you are a pitcher.

quote:

---

Show me where I suggested making any changes to the game at all.

---

I'm responding to your asinine assertion that baseball is a "flawed" game because, in your mind, it discriminates against left-handed players because they can't play certain positions.

quote:

---

Of course. Where in your pea brain did you come up with the idea to do that?

---

I was mocking you. You're criticizing the game over something that's completely ridiculous.

quote:

---

You have the debate skills of a prepubescent girl.

---

I'm not the one who looks like a fool here. But if you want to continue this discussion I'll be happy to show you my debate skills.

quote:

---

They aren't prohibited from playing the position, which is the point.

---

By this statement once can conclude that you're either criticizing baseball over a completely meaningless factor, being left-handed, or you're implying that there's a fundamental problem with the game that needs to be addressed, which would contradict your assertion that you're not calling for making changes to the game.

Now, I happen to think it's the former rather than the latter. But, that just means you're an idiot. Oh, and one other point: baseball doesn't "prohibit" left-handed players from playing any position, they don't play those positions because they can't play them as well as their right-handed peers. That's not prohibiting them from playing the positions anymore than not allowing a pitcher who tops out at 70mph to be a part of the pitching staff. They just can't play that position. You're criticizing the game over one arbitrary factor.

quote:

---

The difference is that speed, height, weight, athleticism are different from righty/lefty.

---

How so?

quote:

---

Oh, and one other point: baseball doesn't "prohibit" left-handed players from playing any position, they don't play those positions because they can't play them as well as their right-handed peers. That's not prohibiting them from playing the positions anymore than not allowing a pitcher who tops out at 70mph to be a part of the pitching staff. They just can't play that position. You're criticizing the game over one arbitrary factor.

---

I've already addressed what he means by "can't" but got no repsonse.