re: Who’s your top 10 heavyweight boxers of all time?

I said up front in my OP that my personal rankings are not based on head to head competition. Otherwise I wouldn’t have Marciano so high.

Holyfield and Dempsey are my 11 and 12 and I think when you get to the end of the top 10 and the beginning of the second 10 it’s all pretty close.

Prime young Foreman would be a difficult assignment for Holyfield. As would Tyson 10 years earlier.

I wasn’t a Holmes fan in real time but I have grown to appreciate him more with the passage of time.

quote:

---

Prime young Foreman would be a difficult assignment for Holyfield. As would Tyson 10 years earlier.

---

That’s the problem with Tyson when judging his career. He was devastating in his prime under cus but lost alot mentally when cus died and the riff raff moved in. I’d put him up against anyone in his early career.

Joe Frazier was another of my favorites.

Prime Frazier vs prime Tyson would have been one for the ages…. Btw. Tyson went sideways when he got rid of Rooney. Buster beat him and the invincibility was gone.

No Klitschko? I'm a little surprised.

I will say this … peak young Tyson with Rooney in his corner had the chops to beat anyone who ever lived on a given night. Like you said he didn’t sustain it.

I won’t disagree here.

A lot of boxing fans don’t like Larry because as great as he was, he had a bit of the mercenary in him, he fought because it was his profession, not because he was driven and compelled to, and folks gravitate to warriors who “would have fought for free.”

But the man got out of boxing with his brain and his bank account intact, and still married to the same woman for 46 years. He did all right for himself.

Holmes Norton was one of the great fights of all time and rarely gets talked about.

No doubt…..